'Does this logic apply to Harry Potter books too?': Twitter in splits after Bombay HC judge terms 'War and Peace' 'objectionable material'

A Bombay High Court observation is being ridiculed on social media, after a single-judge bench questioned rights' activist Vernon Gonsalves motive behind keeping (and reading) Leo Tolstoy's classic novel, War and Peace

FP Staff August 29, 2019 10:04:23 IST
'Does this logic apply to Harry Potter books too?': Twitter in splits after Bombay HC judge terms 'War and Peace' 'objectionable material'
  • A Bombay High Court observation is being ridiculed on social media, after a single-judge bench questioned rights' activist Vernon Gonsalves motive behind keeping (and reading) Leo Tolstoy's classic novel, War and Peace

  • Calling the critically acclaimed novel objectionable material, the single-judge-bench of Justice Sarang Kotwal, hearing the bail plea of Gonsalves and others also said that

  • Meanwhile, people took to Twitter to comment on the bizarre question, some even suggesting if being well-read had now become a crime in India.

A Bombay High Court observation is being ridiculed on social media, after a single-judge bench questioned rights' activist Vernon Gonsalves motive behind keeping (and reading) Leo Tolstoy's classic novel, War and Peace. Calling the critically acclaimed novel "objectionable material", which is about Russia during Napoleonic wars, the single-judge-bench of Justice Sarang Kotwal, hearing the bail plea of Gonsalves and others also said that "such books" and CDs prima facie indicated they contained "some material against the State".

The books and CDs the high court referred to included copies of Marxist Archives, a CD titled ‘Rajya Daman Virodhi’ released by Kabir Kala Manch, and 'Jai Bhima Comrade' among others.

"The title of the CD 'Rajya Daman Virodhi' itself suggests it has something against the State while War and Peace is about a war in another country. Why did you (Gonsalves) keep objectionable material such as books like War and Peace, books and CDs at home? You will have to explain this to the court," said Justice Kotwal. The Pune Police probing the case claimed that the book was part of the "highly incriminating evidence" it had seized from Gonsalves' house in Mumbai during raids conducted a year ago.

Meanwhile, people took to Twitter to comment on the bizarre question, some even suggesting if being well-read had now become a crime in India.

Lawyer Gautam Bhatia announced a mock distress sale of books to point out the irony of the situation.

One user pointed out how a book, which is part of varsity curriculums across world can be termed incriminating material.

Journalist Salil Tripathi took a pun-tended stand to comment on the bizarreness of the situation.

While some Twitter users relied on pure wit and humour to walk the fine line of commenting on a statement and criticising the judiciary.

However, during the hearing, judge did acknowledge the defence' charge that a book cannot be judged by its cover, and the police must come up with a stronger against Gonsalves. The judge also said the Pune police too have to do "much explaining" to convince the court that the material found on such CDs and in the books is incriminatory against Gonsalves.

"So far, the police have failed to provide details of what was on the CDs or in the books and pamphlets recovered that linked Gonsalves to the case. Merely stating that they have objectionable titles is not enough. Have you tested these CDs? What if they turn out to be blank inside?" the judge asked. "If you (prosecution) do not place on record the content and details of such material, the court will have to ignore them," said Justice Kotwal.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Kangana Ranaut's petition against office demolition is 'abuse of process', BMC tells Bombay HC; next hearing on 22 Sept
Entertainment

Kangana Ranaut's petition against office demolition is 'abuse of process', BMC tells Bombay HC; next hearing on 22 Sept

The 33-year-old actress has alleged that the Maharashtra government is targeting her because of her fight with the Shiv Sena

Supreme Court on Maratha reservation: Apex court stays 2018 law granting community quotas in education, jobs
India

Supreme Court on Maratha reservation: Apex court stays 2018 law granting community quotas in education, jobs

The bench referred the pleas questioning the law's validity to a larger Constitution Bench to be set up by Chief Justice of India SA Bobde

BMC urges Bombay HC to dismiss Kangana Ranaut's petition of seeking Rs 2 cr in damages
Entertainment

BMC urges Bombay HC to dismiss Kangana Ranaut's petition of seeking Rs 2 cr in damages

The BMC demolished a part of Kangana Ranaut's Pali Hill bungalow, claiming that she had made substantial structural alterations without due permission.