Whenever you are tempted to buy wool, remember the cruelty that has gone into its production
Wool users support butchery by subsidising the production cost of lamb and mutton joints — even though they may not consume them.
Many animal lovers think that wool is one animal product they can use, "knowing" that no creature has suffered to provide it. Many like Australian wool and look for the label 'Merino', which is the sub-species of sheep from which the wool has been shorn. For such people, here are some facts on wool:
What is wool? Hair grown by sheep to protect themselves from the weather. Is it a natural product? It should have been, but Nature has had, for many years now, no hand in it. Without human interference, sheep would grow just enough wool to protect themselves from the weather, but hybrid sheep, that the wool industry use as "wool machines", are scientifically bred to grow huge amounts of wool, far more than their bodies need or can carry.
Research scientists have bred a Merino sheep which is exaggeratedly wrinkled — the more wrinkle, the more wool. Unfortunately, greater profits are rarely in the animal's best interests. More wrinkles mean greater perspiration and greater susceptibility to fly-strikes, a ghastly condition interlinked with maggot infestation in the sweaty folds of the sheep's over-wrinkled skin. To counteract this, farmers now perform an "operation", without anaesthetic, called "mulesing", in which sections of flesh around the anus are sliced away leaving bloody wounds to prevent fly-strike.
The wool around the buttocks can retain faeces and urine, which attracts flies. The scar tissue that grows over the wound does not grow wool, so is less likely to attract the flies that cause fly-strike.
The unnatural overload of wool (often half their body weight) causes misery to the sheep in the summer months when they often die from heat exhaustion. On the other hand, the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation reminds farmers that a closely shorn sheep is more sensitive to cold than a naked man. Every year, hundreds of thousands of sheep die of cold soon after shearing. Presumably, the farmer is aware of the possibility of this occurring but, no doubt, it is a calculated risk and the high price of wool covers the cost of the dead sheep. In such commercial ventures, the suffering of the animals is irrelevant.
You probably think that, because they are so valuable as wool producers, sheep must warrant proper handling and treatment. Here is the truth: all over the world, and especially in Australia from where we import a lot of wool, they are appallingly treated. When you see a sheep shearing demonstration on television, you are not aware that these are "demonstration experts" who handle the animal well and do the job neatly and quickly without causing obvious distress. But these are not the run-of-the-mill shearers. There are a lot of unskilled farmhands who work in a hurry and leave bloody gashes on the sheep whenever their scissors cut too close. Every shearing operation has one boy standing by, called a "blood stauncher", whose job it is to put tar on the wounds to stop the bleeding.
In Australia, as anywhere else in the world, it is not necessary to use anaesthetics for operations performed on farm-bred animals, so mulesing, tail-docking, ear-clipping and castration of sheep can be performed by unskilled farmhands. The methods of castration are still quite barbaric: a rubber ring may be used to cut off the blood supply to the testicles, causing them and the scrotum to wither; or the testicles may even be bitten off by farmers, who refer to them as "oysters of the bush"! Still more suffering is caused by foot-rot and other harrowing complaints to which these poor creatures are subject to. There are photographs of animals literally trying to walk on their knees because their feet are so painful.
Now there is a special breed of sheep which will never see the outdoors, but is bred intensively, like chickens, in sunless, concrete coops, to produce a "super wool" called "Sharlea". Also, a new drug, cyclophosphamide, is being injected into sheep because it has been found to have a hair-loosening effect. Instead of shearing, sheep can now have their hair pulled out in handfuls! Of course, the drug has the aftereffect of making sheep blind. But then, who wants a seeing wool-machine anyway.
What will happen to the absolutely naked sheep after the hair has been pulled out? Since they are very sensitive to weather, one of the options is to spray the sheep with a waterproof chemical. What happens when the farmer feels that sheep are wearing out? Obviously, they are ready for the slaughterhouse. Some are transported vast distances in unsuitable trucks and trains. Crowded in layers for a three or four-day journey to the slaughterhouse, they receive neither food nor water and must stand all the way. The sick or clumsy ones who may fall are trampled by their frightened fellow creatures.
Of course, some are dead on arrival. Those that can still stand are hurled or harried down the gangplank by men and electrocuted. The dead and the dying are dragged off and thrown into heaps. Some may also suffer the greater cruelty of being exported live to the Middle East. They are herded on to ships (upto 1,20 ,000 per ship) where they are forced to stand in their own urine and faeces in dark holds. Amidst the stench, sheep lie dying as their fellows try to survive on powdery pellet food and urine-contaminated water.
Further horrors await the sheep in the Middle East.
Witnesses have seen a sheep's throat cut with a knife in the street where it slowly chokes to death on its own blood, or is then blinded and bundled into the boot of a car to be quartered at home later.
Journalists have reported the intense suffering of badly handled sheep during transport. In one instance, we are told of 12 wagons loaded with 800 ewes who had been shorn the day before, and had spent a bitterly cold night in the open, leaving Dover on a cargo ship. Two hours after they arrived at Dunkirk, they were re-loaded, 80 to a truck, bound for Marseilles. On arrival there, 25 were lame and one so weak that she could not stand. This ewe, along with the others, was taken further to Algiers where she was dragged off the ship to die on the dockside. At Algiers, the ewes, which had neither been fed nor watered since leaving Marseilles, found a bundle of hay on the dockside and fought each other to reach it. A lorry driver, trying to get through, drove straight at them, sending a few flying and breaking their legs. Even these were loaded onto the slaughterhouse trucks. All this cruelty abroad is duplicated a million times on sheep in India.
Nevertheless, you may say, wool is necessary since it keeps us warm in winter. But wait, that is true only if you are a sheep. Wool is not the ideal fabric for humans. Our skin eliminates wastes all the time. The best clothing allows these wastes to pass through them so that the body is not infected with its own excretions. As we say, the skin needs to breathe. Clothing that holds perspiration, and other body wastes, against the skin limits its cleansing activity by obstructing the free access of fresh air and sunlight, thereby laying the ground for all sorts of skin diseases. Woollen fabrics make the worst clothing in this respect.
If we don't use wool, how do we keep warm? There are alternatives which are so much better. Clothes and blankets which wash easily, do not shrink and keep their colours, cost far less and are far superior to wool. In future, whenever you are tempted to buy wool, remember the cruelty that has gone into its production. As always, the buyer has the power to put an end to organised cruelty. Wool users support butchery by subsidising the production cost of lamb and mutton joints — even though they may not consume them. Can one live with the knowledge that one has abetted the callous exploitation of these gentle animals?
To join the animal welfare movement contact email@example.com, www.peopleforanimalsindia.org
Subscribe to Moneycontrol Pro at ₹499 for the first year. Use code PRO499. Limited period offer. *T&C apply
In October 2020, Mumbai appeared to show the future pathway — and potential end-point — for the COVID-19 pandemic. That certainty has been irreparably dented
Women run fewer than 13% of India's MSMEs; inaccessibility of credit, govt schemes and now COVID are key hurdles
The biggest challenge faced by women entrepreneurs in India is gender bias in access to finance as studies show that their loan applications are more likely to be delayed or rejected as compared to men
That angry Indian debates involve young people pitted against the values of their parents’ generation suggests an upheaval in values lies ahead