Pregnancy not ground for bail, Delhi Police tells HC in response to Jamia student Safoora Zargar's petition

The Delhi Police, in its status report opposing Zargar's bail plea, said a clear and cogent case has been made out against the accused woman and as such she is not entitled for bail for the grave and serious offences.

Press Trust of India June 22, 2020 22:40:39 IST
Pregnancy not ground for bail, Delhi Police tells HC in response to Jamia student Safoora Zargar's petition

New Delhi: The Delhi Police Monday opposed in the Delhi High Court the bail plea of Jamia student Safoora Zargar, arrested under the anti-terror law —UAPA— in a case related to communal violence in northeast Delhi during protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act, saying the severity of offence is in no manner mitigated by the factum of her pregnancy.

The Delhi Police, in its status report opposing Zargar's bail plea, said a clear and cogent case has been made out against the accused woman and as such she is not entitled for bail for the grave and serious offences which have been meticulously and surreptitiously planned and executed by her.

Pregnancy not ground for bail Delhi Police tells HC in response to Jamia student Safoora Zargars petition

Safoora Zargar. Image via Facebook

It said there is strong, cogent, reliable and sufficient material available proving the direct involvement of Zargar, M Phil student of Jamia Millia Islamia University, who is 23 weeks pregnant.

The police said she has been lodged in a separate cell and chances of her contracting coronavirus from any other person does not arise. Further, it maintained that there there is no exception carved out for pregnant inmate, who is accused of such heinous crime, to be released on bail merely because of pregnancy and said that 39 deliveries have taken place in Delhi prisons in the last 10 years.

Jamia Coordination Committee member Zargar, who was arrested by the Special Cell of Delhi Police on 10 April, has challenged in the high court the 4 June order of the trial court denying her bail in the case.

The report, filed through DCP of special cell, said statements of witnesses and co-accused clearly implicate Zargar as being a leading co-conspirator in commissioning of serious offence of causing large-scale disruption and riots, not only in the national capital but also in other parts of the country.

The present case pertains to grave offence against the society and nation. The investigation is at a very crucial juncture, and therefore, considering the sensitivity and the broad nefarious conspectus of present case, it would not be in the interest of justice as well as in public interest to grant bail to the accused at the present stage, it said.

The report said the motive and the idea behind this conspiracy was to go to any extent possible', be it a small scuffle with the police during blockage or instigation of riots between two communities or to advocate and execute a secessionist movement in the country by propagating an armed rebellion against the lawfully constituted government of the day.

It added funds were used and supplied to organise the protest sites and fake vouchers were manufactured/ forged. Acid bombs, iron roads, swords, nailed sticks, knives, sling shots, stones were used in the Delhi riots which were pre-planned in a systematic and organiser manner.
It said that protests were organised following the Shaheen Bagh Chakka-Jaam' model and 21 protest sites were organised and converted to chakka jaam resulting in tensions being heightened and riots in North East, Shahdara and South Districts of Delhi.

It was decided that the "anti-government feeling of Muslims" will be used at an appropriate time to destablise the government, the police claimed, adding that the protests were carried out during the visit of US President Donald Trump to India "to attract international media attention to propogate a narrative that the Government of the day was anti-muslim," the report said.

"This sinister and nefarious conspiracy was designed in various levels according to which the facade of a civil disobedience or protest was to be maintained to buckle the government to agree to the illegitimate demands of the accused," it said.

During the hearing, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and Additional Solicitor General Aman Lekhi urged Justice Rajiv Shakdher to grant them a day's more time for seeking instructions on the issue, saying it will be in larger interest if they are given indulgence.

The court, which conducted the hearing through video conferencing, allowed the request after Zargar's counsel said she has no objection to it and listed the matter for Tuesday.

Advocate Nitya Ramakrishnan, appearing for Zargar, said the woman is in a delicate state and is in a fairly advanced stage of pregnancy and if the police need time to respond to the plea, she be granted interim bail for the time being.

In the status report filed through advocates Amit Mahajan and Rajat Nair, the police said Zargar is also being provided with complete care to prevent any COVID-19 infection and she has been lodged in a separate cell and chances of her contracting coronavirus from any other person does not arise.

"There is no exception carved out for pregnant inmate, who is accused of such heinous crime, to be released on bail merely because of pregnancy. To the contrary, the law provides for adequate safeguards and medical attention during their custody in jail," it said, adding that 39 deliveries have taken place in Delhi prisons in the last 10 years....the health status of the accused (both mental and physical) is satisfactory and normal. Further all medical care and prescribed medication is being provided to her to ensure the well being of the accused and her foetus, as such on this ground also no case for bail has been made out by her," the police said and prayed for dismissing the bail plea.

The hearing also witnessed exchange of words between Mehta, Lekhi on one side and Delhi government standing counsel Rahul Mehra who objected to the appearance of the two senior law officers on behalf of Delhi Police in the case.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Medical aspirant seeks NEET exemption for overseas course, Delhi HC asks MCI to consider plea
India

Medical aspirant seeks NEET exemption for overseas course, Delhi HC asks MCI to consider plea

According to a March 2019 gazette notification by the Medical Council of India (MCI), the NEET has been made mandatory for pursuing MBBS courses abroad

Delhi OBE exams case: Can final year exams be based on MCQ, assignments, HC asks UGC to clarify
India

Delhi OBE exams case: Can final year exams be based on MCQ, assignments, HC asks UGC to clarify

The court asked the UGC to explain the import of April guidelines on July guidelines and has listed the matter for further hearing on 24 July.

Delhi court dismisses Tahir Hussain's plea seeking action against cops for filing 'false' report
India

Delhi court dismisses Tahir Hussain's plea seeking action against cops for filing 'false' report

Hussain alleged that the Delhi Police didn't furnish information on a sixth FIR filed against him, and only gave details of 5 cases