ICAI withdraws advisory asking members to not criticise demonetisation
Hours after the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) issued a gag order on its members, asking them not to criticise government policy on demonetisation, the advisory was withdrawn
Mumbai: Hours after the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) issued a gag order on its members, asking them not to criticise government policy on demonetisation, and instituted a probe against some of them for "professionial misconduct", the advisory was withdrawn on Saturday.
A top ICAI official, declining to be named, said there were some objections from members on the advisory issued on Friday by ICAI president M Devaraja Reddy, after which it was removed.
The advisory carried on its website said notices had been slapped on four chartered accountants for their "alleged acts of professional misconduct" following demonetisation of Rs 500 and 1,000 notes. "The members are strictly advised not to indulge in any nefarious act to subvert the intentions of the government in any remote possible way," it said.
It also sought to put a gag order on the CAs. "Members are also advised not to share/write any negative personal views by way of an article or interview on any platform regarding demonetisation," it said.
On Saturday, a leading Mumbai RTI activist, Anil Galgali, who tweeted on the ethics behind the advisory's aim to stop criticism of the move, was also blocked by the ICAI from its twitter handle.
"They don't want to listen to any criticism. Probably, some politicians may have objected, as they are advised by their CAs on how to manage stashed illegal funds. Instead of heeding to fair criticism, ICAI resorts to crushing it," an indignant Galgali said.
He wondered whether the so-called advisory would still be effective after its erasure from the ICAI site. On Friday, Reddy had said three CAs — whose identity had not been revealed — had been served notice under the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, and Chartered Accountants (Procedure of Investigations of Professional and Other Misconduct and Conduct of Cases) Rules, 2007.
Apart from these three, two more were also in the process for initiating similar disciplinary action by the ICAI, Reddy said. In one case, the ICAI had sought information from the principal commissioner of the Income Tax Department in Pune.
In another case, the details had been solicited from the Income Tax Department in Ahmedabad, while the ICAI has sought information from a private television channel, News18 India, in a third case.
"It is a matter of grave concern and distress to our profession when certain news reports/video clippings have come in the public eye depicting certain CAs indulging in such acts of illegality which go against the efforts of the government in eradicating corruption and black money from business and commercial transactions," Reddy said, in his sharp advisory to ICAI members.
Reddy urged CAs to work towards the best interest of the nation in keeping with true spirit of the principle of ICAI — 'Partner in Nation Building'.
ICAI, a statutory body set up by an act of Parliament, has over 250,000 members as fellows or associates with more than half in full-time practice. The maximum number of members hails from western India while eastern India accounts for the lowest membership of ICAI.
The application window will remain open till 11.59 pm on 6 May and applicants will have to pay a late fee of Rs 600
Candidates who wish to apply for CA Intermediate have to pay Rs 1,500, while CA Final applicants need to pay Rs 1,800