Decision on delay in Class 10 exam results to be taken later: Education Secy
Decision on delay in Class 10 exam results to be taken later: Education Secy
Today's decision only for welfare of children; move on preventive, retributive action to be taken later
"Our immediate concern of the children who have suffered and this decision is in that context. We will nail the person who did this," Secretary education said.
Best emergency measure taken in paucity of information: HRD ministry
This is not a perfect solution, in such a case there is no perfect solution possible. But we tried our best to limit the damage as much as possible. The information is limited and we are yet to ascertain what went wrong. Thus in such a situation, this decision was the best alternative we had.
Accept process was breached but action against guilty only after further probe: HRD ministry
HRD ministry secretary said that he admitted that there were problems in the process as well, but the fixation of blame is a process for a later time. The new processes and security measures will be implemented only in the next academic year. However, the situation at hand warranted that the future of Class 12 students should not be left in limbo, so the best possible solution was taken.
The email received on the night before did not contain leaked paper; decision to cancel exam taken after police probe: CBSE chief
CBSE chairperson Anita Karwal said that the email received the night before did not contain the leaked paper, so they did not take the decision to cancel the exam immediately. "However, the next day we received a lot of emails from students looking at which the police also decided that the papers indeed leaked the day before. This is why we took the decision for a retest only later," Karwal said.
Clarification on leak came only after exam was underway: Education secy
The HRD ministry secretary acknowledged that media reports stating that CBSE chief received an email at around 1.30 am on 28 March was true. He said that the chairperson did not check her email at 1 am but noticed the message at 8.55 am the next day. She intimated the controller of examination immediately, who went on to verify the details.
The confirmation came back only after 10 am when exams at all centres were underway. It was a balanced solution that the board decided to take. Even at that time a re-exam would have to be announced but it would have created unsurmountable panic.
Class 10 exams to be rescheduled in July, if at all, in Delhi and Haryana regions only
The ministry said that since in the case of Class 10 students, it was possible to wait for a detailed enquiry, we have decided to take a final decision later. However, preliminary enquiry suggests that the leak affected papers only in Delhi and Haryana region only, so a retest, if at all needed will be held in that region only.
HRD ministry says Class 12 re-exam for economics to be held on 25 April
The HRD ministry has said that the re-examination for Class 12 economics paper will be held on 25 April. The decision was taken to not keep the students in limbo any longer as they have to take entrance tests as well. The Education secretary accepted that this was not a perfect solution but it was the most viable solution in the lack of a detailed probe.
We may not have the perfect solution, there are no perfect solution: HRD ministry
HRD ministry press briefing begins
Union Minister Prakash Javadekar to address press conference shortly
Amid nationwide protests from aggrieved students and parents and Opposition parties, Union Human Resource Development (HRD) Minister Prakash Javadekar met examination body officials on Friday to seek resolution of the crisis.
Javadekar is expected to give some clarity on the date of re-examinations as the students remain in a fix. He is also expected to explain the reasons for the paper leak shortly.
Updates for 30 March 2018 begin
CBSE chairperson Anita Karwal breaks silence, says final decision will favour students
CBSE chairperson Anita Karwal finally gave a statement on the paper leak issue and she said that the board will take a decision that will be in favour of students. She said that the dates of the fresh examinations will be issued soon.
CBSE chairperson Anita Karwal met HRD minister before his press conference: Reports
Chairperson of CBSE, Anita Karwal had a concise meeting with HRD Minister Prakash Javadekar this morning at Shastri Bhawan. The meeting, which happened before the Union minister’s press conference, lasted for almost 2 hours, CNN-News18 reported.
NCERT books to have QR codes from nest year, says Prakash Javadekar
NCERT published textbooks would have QR codes from next year (2019-20) which will help students to understand chapters better by watching a film or reading additional content on laptops and digital boards, Union minister Prakash Javadekar said today.
Leak in everything, 'watchman' is weak: Rahul Gandhi
Congress President Rahul Gandhi on Thursday attacked Prime Minister Narendra Modi on the CBSE paper leak, saying he is a "weak watchman" as there were leaks in everything.
"How many leaks? Data leak! Aadhaar leak! SSC exam leak! Election date leak! CBSE papers leak! There is leak in everything. The watchman (Narendra Modi) is weak," Gandhi said in a tweet.
The CBSE on Wednesday said it will re-conduct examination in the maths and economics papers for Class 10 and Class 12 respectively following the leak of question papers.
Delhi Police say Coaching centre owner Vicky was named in CBSE's complaint
The police have said that they got the accused tuition teacher Vicky's name from CBSE. He got the papers and forwarded it to his students, the police said.
Students plans to protest tomorrow at Jantar Mantar: Report
CNN-News18 reported that the students are now planning to protest again on 30 March at Jantar Mantar.
Rahul Gandhi slams Centre over CBSE paper leak, says this is only the beginning
The exam leaks destroy the hopes and futures of millions of students.— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) March 29, 2018
The Congress always protected our institutions. This is what happens when institutions are destroyed by the RSS/BJP.
Believe me when I say, this is only the beginning.
Delhi Police says haven't traced any money trail yet, papers were leaked over WhatsApp groups
"We haven't yet found proof of any being offered or exchanged anywhere in this case. But the investigation is still on," Delhi Police said.
Scope of investigation limited to Delhi, police say no information of nationwide leak
Delhi Police in a press conference said that the police is right now focusing its investigation in Delhi only as there was nothing to suggest a nation-wide leak as of now. The police, however, denied to share any details of the investigation.
Delhi Police say it quizzed 25 people in CBSE paper leak case
The police has questioned 25 people in the case so far, RR Upadhyay Special Commissioner crime branch, told reporters on Wednesday, even as he refused to share more details about the investigation.
Upadhyay said that the police have been questioning 25 people in all, including 18 college students, five tuition teachers and two others.
The police also said that the 18 college students were mostly alumni of certain schools or former students at some specific coaching centres. Upadhyay, however, said that it was not prudent for him to reveal any names at this point.
How to beat tech-savvy cheaters at their own game
The Mumbai University has a model whereby question papers will be downloaded by colleges after a facial-recognition scan. The downloading and printing process would also be recorded via CCTVs to prevent a leak at that stage.
Herold D'Costa, CEO of Intelligent Quotient Security System (IQSS), who devised the system for the University, also suggests the use of a centralised server, which would house a variety of question papers. Question papers would then randomly be selected and links sent to exam centres to downloaded and print them. The paper would be downloaded by an authorised person or the principal just a few minutes before the exam.
The primary hiccup in this method, however, is connectivity in rural areas and the time taken to print the question paper on the morning of the exam.
Another solution is to install mobile jammers at exam centres to prevent students from using Bluetooth-enabled devices to cheat.
Arvind Kejriwal demands strict action against culprits in CBSE data leaks
Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal today demanded strict action against people involved in the alleged leak of CBSE examination papers, and said he feels "sorry and sad" for students who will have to re-appear for the exams.
I really feel sorry and sad for the students who have to give their exams again for no fault of theirs. Responsibility shud be fixed n strict action shud be taken against those responsible.— Arvind Kejriwal (@ArvindKejriwal) March 29, 2018
Congress slams Modi govt's education policies, calls Centre 'Leak Sarkar'
"It is absolutely shocking and heart rendering that the future of 24 Lakh students is in severe jeopardy... It may just turn out to be the tip of the iceberg as multiple news reports and social media stories on how the Biology, Chemistry and English papers have also been leaked are also surfacing now. Despite registration of an FIR and an enquiry, shockingly; CBSE has admitted the leak of 3 exam papers," Congress said in a press release. Here is the complete press statement of the body.
Kamal Haasan reacts to paper leak controversy, says not fair to punish students for govt's fault
"Since we call them warriors, I'll tell you they did their job. They cannot be punished and the tension among the parents and students is going to be enormous. I think it's not fair to make the students go through mistakes of the government," Haasan said.
Police accuses delhi-based tuition teacher Vicky for paper leak, quizzes 9 more in case
The Delhi police have accused a Rajouri Garden-based coaching teacher for allegedly being involved in the paper leak. CNN-News18 reported that the teacher is being questioned and eight more people are under scanner.
Police registers two cases in CBSE paper leak case; forms SIT to probe case
Why was CBSE chief's tenure cut shot in September 2017, asks Congress
Congress spokesperson Randeep Singh Surjewala questioned the government over leak. He asked the Centre to clarify why it cut short the tenure of previous CBSE chief in September 2017. He questioned that why did the government give the job to someone who had previously worked with prime minister Narendra Modi.
Will try our best re-exam dates don't clash with other entrance exams: CBSE sources
CBSE sources have said that the exam body will try its best to choose a date for re-examination that doesn't clash with other exams, CNN-News18 reported.
Students say CBSE must be held accountable for their action
Tejaswi, a class 10 student of St Thomas School, Mandir Marg says students cannot go into the CBSE office and leak papers. Her demand is that the CBSE officials have to be held accountable for what has happened to students like her.
Students allege that more papers were leaked as well
A student of Class 12, shows a scanned copy of the Economics paper on his phone. He says that it was available for two to three thousand rupees before the examination and if the students were aware of it, then why was the board so oblivious? He also alleged that Economics wasn't the only paper that was leaked and there should be a re examination for other subjects as well.
Without removing Union HRD Minister Prakash Javadekar and CBSE Chairperson Anita Karwal from their current positions, a fair and impartial investigation into this paper leak issue is impossible
Without removing Union HRD Minister Prakash Javadekar and CBSE Chairperson Anita Karwal from their current positions, a fair and impartial investigation into this paper leak issue is impossible: @rssurjewala— Congress Live (@INCIndiaLive) March 29, 2018
Private tuition teachers want either all papers to be cancelled or none at all
A tuition teacher who runs a private centre in Janak Puri, West Delhi, said that as he had faith in the system, he didn't trust the rumours and asked his students to ignore them. After the Economics exam, some students blamed him for not letting them use the leaked paper. He says the re-examination will hamper their preparation for entrance exams for university, which will start in April.
Private tuition teachers tell @r_pallavi_ that they want either all papers to be cancelled or none at all. #CBSEMaths #CBSEPaperLeaks #CBSEPaperLeak photo— Firstpost (@firstpost) March 29, 2018
Follow #LIVE updates on #CBSE paper leak at https://t.co/Dyhamo6c5H pic.twitter.com/zc7CzpO2jF
Two cases registered in relation to the paper leak
The Crime Branch of the Delhi Police has registered two cases in connection with the paper leak. An SIT comprising 2 DCPs, 5 ACPs and 5 inspectors has been constituted to investigate these cases.
Less than 50 students at the protest near Jantar Mantar
Less than 50 students from schools like Kendriya Vidyalaya, St Thomas, St Columbus and Dr SRS International are protesting against the leak at a tiny nook adjacent to Jantar Mantar's famous protest street. NGT had banned all protest activities here in 2017.
The contingents of paramilitary and police forces outnumbered the students. There were no representation from the administration of these schools. A couple of teachers running private tuition centres were there, alleging that they were well aware of the paper leak.
Some girls were chanting the slogan 'abki baar paperleak sarkaar'. Another group was waving the Indian flag and screaming 'bharat mata ki jai'.
Students threaten boycott of re-exams
Class 12 students of Kendriya Vidyalaya, Naraina say they will boycott the exam alleging that if the CBSE had a fair idea about the paper leak around 9 am on the day of the exam, then why was the exam held? They ask if 28 lakh students boycott the re-examination, then what can the government do?
Javadekar promises to make efforts to make system foolproof
Javadekar further insisted that the authorities will not let anyone go scot-free. The police is on the case and he has faith in them. He has instituted an internal inquiry into the matter as well.
He added that he will make all efforts to ensure that exams continue without any breach and will work to make the system foolproof.
Prakash Javadekar addresses CBSE leaks
Javadekar called the event unfortunate. He said that he understood the pain and anguish of both parents and students. He insisted that CBSE has earned a name for conducting exams well.
He pointed out that when NEET was being implemented, CBSE was chosen as the body to helm it. It did so even while being overloaded with work.
President of Delhi School Association, Ramesh Chand Jain calls incident condemnable, asks for statement by CBSE chairman
Govt should put culprits behind the bars. First step they should take is set the system right. CBSE chairman should atleast give a statement, why hasn't she spoken to students & parents? This's condemnable: Ramesh Chand Jain, President, Delhi School Association on #CBSEPaperLeak pic.twitter.com/0HcjIGvF95— ANI (@ANI) March 29, 2018
Students are fed up of giving exams after exams
Students tell @r_pallavi_ that they are fed up of giving exams after exams.#CBSEMaths #CBSEPaperLeaks #CBSEPaperLeaked— Firstpost (@firstpost) March 29, 2018
Follow #LIVE updates on #CBSE paper leaks at https://t.co/Dyhamo6c5H pic.twitter.com/LOs8a1r3fO
Delhi Police asks CBSE for the sequence of events, names coaching institute founder as main suspect
Students want CBSE to be held accountable and find the culprit
Students want #CBSE to be held accountable and find the culprit. They shouldn't just get away with giving students a re-test.#CBSELeak #CBSEPaperLeak #cbseretest— Firstpost (@firstpost) March 29, 2018
Follow #LIVE updates at https://t.co/Dyhamo6c5H pic.twitter.com/6mRNtxkT8Q
Other papers were leaked too, then why re-test only for Eco and Maths, ask students
Speaking to Firstpost, Class 12 Students of Dr SRS Mission School protesting against the CBSE paper leak at Delhi's Jantar Mantar said, "Aside from English paper, there were rumours about every paper being leaked. Then why re-examination only for Economics."
Image by Pallavi Rebbapragada
Perpetrators had sent hand-written answer sheet of the Economics paper to CBSE a day before the exams
According to reports, the perpetrators who leaked the Economics paper had sent the answer-sheet (which was hand-written) to the CBSE Academic Unit on Monday. The exam for the Economics paper was supposed to be held on Tuesday.
What is important to note is why didn't the CBSE cancel the exams on Monday itself?
Delhi police had registered two cases
In a statement, the Delhi Police said that they have registered two cases. The first case in connection with the leak of economics paper was lodged yesterday while the case pertaining to mathematics paper was lodged today, following a complaint by the regional director of CBSE. The cases were registered on charges of criminal breach of trust, cheating and criminal conspiracy.
"We have received snapshots of the handwritten paper circulated through Whatsapp from the complainant. We are trying to ascertain the source of these messages. Since Whatsapp messages are end-to-end encrypted, we are facing a bit of difficulty in tracing the source," said an officer privy to the probe. The officer said they have not questioned any official from any of the examination centres or from the board. The questioning will happen once the source of messages is traced.
Either conduct re-examination of all papers, or none, say protesting students at Jantar Mantar
Students took to the street in Delhi's Jantar Mantar as angst against re-test loomed large over their heads. Protesting students said that either there should be re-examinations of all subjects or else of neither. Students also raised 'we want justice' slogans.
Delhi: Students protest at Jantar Mantar against #CBSEPaperLeak, say 'either there should re-examinations of all subjects or else of neither'. Raise 'we want justice' slogans pic.twitter.com/iymbkfavDe— ANI (@ANI) March 29, 2018
Latest update on CBSE re-examination dates: The CBSE failed to take action because of wealth of misleading information of paper leaks. But a probe is underway and the responsibility will surely be fixed, the secretary at Human resource Development ministry said.
Vociferous protests by students and Opposition leaders over the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) paper leak controversy continued on Friday. Amid the agitations, Union Human Resource Development (HRD) Minister Prakash Javadekar met examination body officials to seek resolution of the crisis.
Javadekar is expected to give some clarity on the date of re-examinations as the students remain in a fix. He is also expected to explain the reasons for the paper leak.
The Union HRD minister, who also addressed students at a hackathon in New Delhi on Friday, accepted that the exponential development in information and technology tools warrants an upgrade in the security mechanism of the exam bodies too, as he told students he understands their anguish and will take action to prevent such incidents in future.
— ANI (@ANI) March 30, 2018
Meanwhile, police investigation in the case revealed that around 10 WhatsApp groups were used to spread the leaked question papers and parents had paid as much as Rs 35,000 to buy the leaked question papers, NDTV reported.
The police has reportedly also asked Google for help to trace down the whistleblower, who alerted the CBSE days before the examinations were actually held, the news channel said.
While the police has refused to name any schools, coaching centres or individuals in the case and has not yet made any arrests, the CBSE already seems to have reached the conclusion that its officials were not at fault.
CNN-News18 reported that CBSE sources have ruled out the possibility of an insider hand. The sources are said to have claimed that exam superintendents, who are tasked with taking the exam papers to centres, may have been involved in the leak.
The police has, however, refused to comment on the specifics of the case. The Delhi Police crime branch has also questioned the controller of examinations, CBSE in the case.
All this while, the question remains as to why the CBSE did not take preventive action, or cancel examinations, despite a whistleblower sending exact inputs two days prior to the exam via e-mail and courier.
Meanwhile, protests raged on in the national capital and other parts of the country as students were still unclear over the dates of retest, and whether or not they will clash with their other entrance tests. A parents and teachers association in Mumbai has written to the CBSE and the home ministry claiming that the paper leak has not affected the examination process in the state of Maharashtra, and therefore the students there should not be compelled to take a retest.
The aggrieved parents and teachers have turned down offers of political parties to back their protests.
CBSE students protesting against the cancellation of their Class X Mathematics examination have rejected an offer of intervention made by the National Students' Union of India (NSUI), saying the Congress party's youth wing didn't consult them before formulating a memorandum.
Furthermore, Section 144 of the CrPC has been imposed outside Prakash Javadekar's house in New Delhi.
An anonymous email sent to the CBSE chief on the night before the Class X Mathematics exam urged for cancellation for the paper stating that the question paper was leaked on WhatsApp, the second FIR filled in the CBSE exam paper leak has revealed.
According to the FIR, a person named Dev Narayan had emailed CBSE chairperson Anita Karwal's official ID at around 1.39 am on 28 March, urging her to cancel the exam. In the email, the FIR reveals, the sender stated that "the mathematics paper has been leaked today on WhatsApp, please cancel tomorrow Maths paper (sic)".
The email also contains 12 pages of jpg attachments comprising of hand-written question paper of mathematics, says the FIR, which News18 posted on its website. The maths exam took place on 28 March.
The police is also investigating the handwritten notes.
In the meanwhile, News18 quoted a source at the HRD ministry as saying on Friday that dates for the re-exam have not been fixed yet. Citing a source, the news channel said that the government is still gauging the extent of the paper leak and that it's still unsure if a leak indeed took place.
Karwal had broken her silence on the paper leak on Thursday, stating that fresh exams will be announced soon. She had said that the decision to conduct fresh exams were taken in the interest of students.
However, students across India are not happy with the decision, accusing the central board of negligence. Students protested outside Jantar Mantar in Delhi on Thursday and they were back on the streets on Friday as well.
The Class XII accountancy paper was also reportedly leaked on WhatsApp and social media, which prompted Delhi deputy chief minister Manish Sisodia to order a probe and lodge a complaint with the CBSE.
More than 28 lakh candidates appeared for the Class X and XII examinations conducted by the CBSE from 5 March.
A total of 16,38,428 candidates had registered for the Class X examination, while 11,86,306 candidates had registered for the Class XII examination.
With inputs from PTI
Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go to Firstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.
Updated Date: Mar 30, 2018 19:41:33 IST
Ahead of board exams, CBSE chief asks students to ‘firewall’ distractions, ‘download’ competencies and life skills
CBSE Class 12 examination to begin on 2 March, Class 10 on 7 March; education board aims to release results a week earlier
Karol Bagh fire: Delhi Police arrests hotel's general manager, another staff; case transferred to crime branch
Oscars 2019: IMDb to stream ceremony live from Elton John Aids Foundation Academy Awards Viewing Party