Alwar lynching case: Rajasthan Police admits 'error in judgement', says officials thought victim's condition wasn't serious
The probe panel set up by Rajasthan Police said it was not a case of “custodial death” and whatever happened on the part of the local police was an 'error of judgement” in responding to the situation.
Alwar/Jaipur: The Rajasthan Police on Monday admitted "error of judgement" in handling the case of alleged lynching of 28-year-old Rakbar in Alwar, as it suspended one and transferred three policemen, even as it refuted allegations of "custodial death".
Amid allegations of negligence on part of the local policemen, including for delay in taking Rakbar Khan to hospital, a high-level panel, set up by the state police, found four policemen guilty of dereliction in duty and suspended assistant sub-inspector Mohan Singh, who was in charge of the Ramgarh police station at that time, and shunted three constables to police lines, officials said.
“Since the policemen thought the victim was not serious, they decided to take him to the police station first so that the cows could be first shifted to a shelter. They also offered him water and tea, so it appeared an error of judgement,”Additional Director General (law and order) NRK Reddy, a member of the enquiry panel, said.
In the primary investigation, Reddy claimed the policemen have not been found involved in beating the victim. However, police said it was not a case of “custodial death” and whatever happened on the part of the local police was an "error of judgement” in responding to the situation.
Earlier in the day, DGP OP Galhotra had set up a four-member committee.
The panel comprised special DGP (law and order) NRK Reddy, Additional DGP (CID-Crime Branch) PK Singh, Inspector General (Jaipur Range) Hemant Priyadarshi and state nodal officer (cow vigilance) Mahendra Singh Chaudhary, Galhotra said.
The action was taken after a video purportedly showing the assistant sub-inspector, who was posted at the Ramgarh police station, admitting to his "mistake", went viral.
"Mere se galti hogai... kaise bhi maan lo... saja de do ya chhodh do... seedhi si baat hai(I made a mistake... punish me or pardon me... it is simple and straight)," the assistant sub-inspector can be heard purportedly saying in the video.
The video of the ssistant sub-inspector surfaced hours after allegations that the Alwar police delayed by nearly three hours the shifting of Khan to the Ramgarh community healthcare centre.
While two persons, Dharmendra Yadav and Paramjeet Singh, were arrested on Saturday, a third accused, Naresh Singh, was nabbed on Sunday and they are under police custody for five days, police said.
"There are certain allegations that local police had beaten up Khan and delayed in taking him to hospital, which are being looked into," Superintendent of Police (Alwar) Rajendra Singh said.
The incident was reported to police at 12.41 am on Saturday. Police reached there at 1.15 am, but they reached the hospital, which is nearly 4 kilometres away from the scene of crime, with Khan at 4.00 am, where he was declared brought dead, as per police and hospital records. Congress leader Ashok Gehlot demanded a CBI probe into the alleged case of lynching.
“This is a mystery. It was the duty of police to take the victim to hospital but instead he was taken to the police station. This is a matter of investigation. Is it not duty of chief minister Vasundhara Raje to set up an impartial probe? In my view, the case should be handed over to the CBI for an impartial inquiry,” Gehlot said.
Former Congress MP from Alwar Bhanwar Jitendra Singh also demanded a judicial inquiry into the matter and said that such incidents occur when elections are around.
Rajasthan home minister Gulab Chand Kataria earlier in the day said that appropriate action would be taken if there was any negligence on the part of police.
BJP MP from Rajasthan's Nagaur CR Chaudhary said,"It's not like that. Police did its work. Police have arrested the accused and took injured to hospital immediately. Sometimes, media doesn't give proper message. I don't think that police lacked in its action."
The incident has created a political stir where the BJP MLA from Ramgarh constituency in Alwar, Gyan Dev Ahuja, blamed local police and the opposition Congress held by the Raje-led government responsible for the incident and demanded a judicial inquiry or a CBI probe into the case to ensure “unbiased investigation”.
Rajasthan Pradesh Congress Committee president Sachin Pilot demanded a judicial inquiry into the matter.
Khan, along with his friend Aslam, was taking cows to their villages in Haryana through a forest area in the Ramgarh area of Alwar, where they were caught by the mob. Aslam had managed to flee.
As per the FIR registered with the Ramgarh police station on Saturday, Naval Kishore Sharma, the chief of the VHP's 'Gau Raksha' cell in Ramgarh, had informed the police at 12.41 am (on Saturday) about the incident.
Police reached the spot at 1.15 am. Khan's statement was recorded and he was taken to the police station. As per the CHC entry register, a body of a 28-year-old man was brought at 4 am.
Following the allegation, the probe into the alleged lynching incident was handed over to additional SP (Crime and Vigilance), Jaipur Range, yesterday.
"The investigation will be carried out in a fair and transparent manner," IG, Jaipur Range, Hemant Priyadarshi had said.
Meanwhile, the police investigation has revealed the past record of the victim.
On 30 December, 2014, Nauganwa police station in Alwar had registered a case against Khan under Sections 5 (prohibits the export of bovine animals for slaughter) and 8 (penalty for contravention of Section 5) of the Rajasthan Bovine Animal Act, after allegedly retrieving two cows from him. Nauganwa police station Station House Officer Mohan Singh said a 'challan' was filed in the 2014 case.
The Congress leader was embroiled in controversy after he recently launched his new book 'Sunrise Over Ayodhya: Nationhood in Our Times.'
The former Union minister was embroiled in a controversy for allegedly "defaming and comparing Hinduism with terrorism" in his recent book "Sunrise Over Ayodhya: Nationhood in Our Times"
Delhi Mahila Congress chief slams Kangana Ranaut for 'Independence was 'bheek' remark, demands FIR against actor
The actor has stoked a controversy after she at an event called India's Independence in 1947, not freedom but 'bheek', adding that India 'got real freedom in 2014', a reference to the BJP coming to power at the Centre