Kamal Haasan's jibe at Brahmin thread: MNM chief pandering to Dravidian-Periyar ideology, but is he alienating others?

Kamal Haasan was asked a question in Tamil on Twitter on which book had inspired him the most. Haasan's tweet came under a lot of criticism from the Brahmin community which saw it as pandering to the anti-Brahmin Dravidian-Periyar-esque ideology which has a wider following in Tamil Nadu.

TS Sudhir July 02, 2018 10:58:37 IST
Kamal Haasan's jibe at Brahmin thread: MNM chief pandering to Dravidian-Periyar ideology, but is he alienating others?

In November 2017, Congress spokesperson Randeep Singh Surjewala described Congress chief Rahul Gandhi as a "janeu-dhaari Hindu". Janeu is the sacred white thread worn by Brahmins and in the run-up to the Gujarat elections, this was seen as an attempt by the Congress to claim the Hindu space, occupied by the BJP. The emphasis on being 'janeu dhaari' was panned because it was seen as reinforcing a certain hierarchical superiority within the Hindu fraternity.

The exact opposite happened on 1 July, 2018 when Kamal Haasan was asked a question in Tamil on Twitter on which book had inspired him the most. The book is called 'nool' in Tamil and the same word with more or less the same pronunciation also denotes the thread. Kamal said: "There is only only 'nool' (book/thread) that I avoided. The poonal that I missed."

'Poonal' is the Tamil word for janeu. Kamal Haasan, who is a Brahmin, was pointing to the fact that he had forsaken the poonal. Sources close to him say his father respected his decision to do so. Haasan who calls himself a rationalist and not an atheist, also revealed that he did not fill in the caste and religion column in his admission forms of his daughters.

Haasan's tweet came under a lot of criticism from the Brahmin community which saw it as pandering to the anti-Brahmin Dravidian-Periyar-esque ideology which has a wider following in Tamil Nadu. The two main Dravidian parties and various smaller offshoots believe in the Periyar school of thought. A Brahmin in Tamil Nadu is likely to have less political equity and therefore Haasan's comment is seen as distancing himself from his roots.

Kamal Haasans jibe at Brahmin thread MNM chief pandering to DravidianPeriyar ideology but is he alienating others

File image of MNM chief Kamal Haasan. PTI

How fair is the criticism? While Haasan can be faulted for going off on a tangent when the question was specifically about books, in his defence, the tweet is not malicious and he did not advocate that Brahmins should not wear the sacred thread. He merely said it did not work for him.

The reason why Haasan is getting the stick over social media from Brahmins is because of the socio-political environment of Tamil Nadu. This is a land where attacks on Brahmin priests while celebrating Periyar's ideology have been witnessed. Periyar was a social activist who started the self-respect movement and Dravida Kazhagam and opposed the marginalisation of the non-Brahmin Dravidian people of South India. The famous quote, "If you see a snake and a Brahmin, kill the Brahmin first'." is attributed to Periyar, as proof of his anti-Brahmin sentiment.

Even though the OBCs in Tamil Nadu like the Thevars and the Gounders who keep the Dalits at arm's length are the new 'Brahmins' in the caste order, Brahminical hegemony has been a useful political card to employ. When DMK's A Raja was embroiled in the 2G case, Karunanidhi described it as a "Brahminical conspiracy" against Raja, who is a Dalit.

In July 2017, on the occasion of  'Avani Avittam', the day Brahmins in Tamil Nadu change their sacred thread once in a year, a fringe Dravidian outfit made a pig wear the holy thread in Chennai in a deliberate attempt to insult. More recently, this March, threads of ten bare-bodied Brahmins were cut in Chennai in retaliation to BJP leader H Raja's call to bring down Periyar's statues. Which is why the community feels Haasan by mocking the thread as something he found worthy of avoiding, has only provided ammunition to the Dravidian sentiment that insults Brahmins.

Was it then an inadvertent remark or is Haasan playing politics? His supporters say he was only talking about himself as an individual and was not making a general comment on Brahminism. They say it is in sync with his aspiration of a caste-less society. But in a political world where there is trust deficit, the Brahmin community will not give Haasan the benefit of doubt. They feel they are being targetted to climb up the political ladder.

Jayalalithaa, too, was a Brahmin but she had spent enough number of years schooled in the Dravidian ecosystem. Despite being born into a Brahmin family, Haasan perhaps sees the need to emphasise that he does not represent a Brahminical mindset. Politically this will help him reach out to the larger non-Brahmin electorate that for reasons historical, sees the Brahmin minority (just about 2 percent of Tamil Nadu's population) as an adversary. The flip side is that the Brahmin population that would be inclined to back Haasan since they see him as one of their own, now would be put off with his comment.

So if the Congress does not boast about Rahul Gandhi's 'Janeudhaari' status while in Tamil Nadu, you will know why. The Congress president may have taken a leaf out of Haasan's 'nool'.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

From building the wall to ending wars, four years in, Trump has plenty of unfinished business
World

From building the wall to ending wars, four years in, Trump has plenty of unfinished business

Since taking the oath of office in 2016, US president Donald Trump has faced the same hard truth that each of his White House predecessors learned: Governing is rarely easy

'Price of independent reportage': J&K leaders condemn sealing of Kashmir Times' office in Srinagar
India

'Price of independent reportage': J&K leaders condemn sealing of Kashmir Times' office in Srinagar

A group of journalists from the UT of Jammu and Kashmir also alleged that there are renewed attempts 'to throttle' Kashmir Times which has been 'at the forefront of fighting against govt curbs on communications and press freedom in Kashmir, especially post-5 August'

Madhya Pradesh to move SC against HC order restricting physical political rallies in state, says CM
Politics

Madhya Pradesh to move SC against HC order restricting physical political rallies in state, says CM

The Gwalior bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court on Wednesday had ordered nine districts under its jurisdiction to grant permission for public rallies only if virtual meetings were not possible