Vantage | Why we can't depend on Big Tech to make Internet safe of children

In a recent and highly charged US Senate hearing, the spotlight was cast on major tech companies as they faced intense scrutiny over their platforms’ involvement in facilitating harmful activities among teenagers. The discussion expanded beyond the incidents of teen drug use to encompass issues such as online bullying, harassment, sexual exploitation, self-harm and predatory marketing – collectively referred to as the seven plagues of social media.

Executives from Meta, Snap, TikTok, X and Discord found themselves on the receiving end of probing questions, enduring nearly four hours of relentless interrogation about their platforms’ perceived failure to adequately protect children. The exchanges with Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg and Snap CEO Evan Spiegel drew particular attention. Senatorial interrogation Senator Josh Hawley, a Republican from Missouri, confronted Mark Zuckerberg with alarming statistics, revealing that 37 per cent of teenage girls between 13 and 15 were exposed to unwanted nudity on Instagram. Despite these revelations, Zuckerberg maintained a defensive stance, refraining from disclosing significant actions taken against those responsible. In a pivotal moment, Zuckerberg eventually issued an apology, stating, “I’m sorry for everything you have all been through. No one should go through the things that your families have suffered.” While the apology appeared sincere, doubts lingered regarding its authenticity and the lack of concrete actions taken to address the issues at hand. Ineffectual responses The hearing laid bare the defensive responses of tech executives, offering tepid answers to queries about child safety measures on their platforms. The proposed Kids Online Safety Act, designed to compel social media sites to prevent harm to minors, failed to garner unanimous support, with three out of the five CEOs withholding their pledge of backing. Adding to the drama, three out of the five CEOs were served government-issued subpoenas, underscoring their reluctance to attend the hearing voluntarily. This reluctance highlighted the tech giants’ hesitance to confront the pressing issue of child safety on their platforms. Social media as a public health hazard New York City Mayor Eric Adams heightened the gravity of the situation by classifying social media as a “public health hazard” and an “environmental toxin.” Disturbing statistics revealed a surge in child sex images online with over 36 million pornographic images of children circulating in 2023. While social media companies like Meta and Snapchat reap substantial profits from user engagement, the hearing exposed the inherent conflict of interest in self-regulation. With the majority of their revenue derived from advertising, these companies have a vested interest in keeping users on their platforms, potentially compromising user safety. As tech giants continue to prioritise financial gains over user safety, the responsibility falls on governments to regulate and protect vulnerable users. Public regulation becomes crucial in acknowledging the negative impacts of social media and ensuring that companies prioritize user safety over profits. While the apologies voiced during the Senate hearing may have been a step in the right direction, they remain insufficient to address the deep-rooted systemic problems afflicting the social media landscape. Urgent action is imperative, calling for the establishment of stringent laws, decisive measures, and a comprehensive framework dedicated to safeguarding children online. The responsibility now squarely rests on the shoulders of governments to not only recognise the deficiencies of tech giants but to implement and enforce policies that prioritise user safety over profit. It is only through stringent regulation that we can hope to rectify the pervasive issues plaguing social media platforms, ensuring a safer and more secure digital environment for the younger generation. Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely that of the author. They do not necessarily reflect Firstpost’s views. Read all the Latest News , Trending News , Cricket News , Bollywood News , India News and Entertainment News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.