Uttarakhand is paying the high price of anti-environmentalism

Faced with environmental disaster, Bahuguna refuses to rethink a single tourism project or ill-advised dam, insisting on development at any price.

Lakshmi Chaudhry June 24, 2013 15:12:56 IST
Uttarakhand is paying the high price of anti-environmentalism

"Do you think the cloudburst at Kedarnath happened because of wrong or commercial construction on the river beds of Haridwar? Kedarnath doesn’t even fall in the eco-sensitive zone and the dhabas on the walk path couldn’t have  triggered calamity of this magnitude." declares Vijay Bahuguna when asked by Times of India if Uttarakhand is a "man-made disaster.

A "calamity of this magnitude" may make a lesser leader second-guess his decisions or rethink his future policies, but not Mr Bahuguna. He has no plans to reassess a single tourism or hydro project just because some "activists" are making a fuss.

Bahuguna's searing contempt for all things environmental is hardly remarkable in a nation of development fundamentalists obsessed with growth rates. In political discourse, the E-word is synonymous with bleeding heart activists. It's the bogeyman raised by NGO jholawala types who rant about consumerism, tribals, nuclear plants et al; or worse, hypocritical Westerners who want to keep us in mud huts while they power up their washing machines. This knee-jerk disdain may be ideologically satisfying but is, in the long run — as the Uttarakhand tragedy reveals — wholly self-destructive.

Uttarakhand is paying the high price of antienvironmentalism

Vijay Bahuguna in this file photo. PTI

"There are of course links between climate change and extreme weather events as has happened with the torrential rain in Uttarakhand. But this has been exacerbated by the reckless construction of buildings, dams and roads in a fragile environment. Many of the settlements have been built right next to the rivers in blatant violation of environmental laws," says director general of Centre for Science and Environment, Sunita Narain.

It's fashionable in free market circles to pooh-pooh environmental laws as wrong-headed obstacles to development, but doing an end run around them has turned out to be a recipe for disaster. The state and centre governments indiscriminately green lighted hydro-projects without proper environmental clearance, despite a CAG audit that warned of flash floods, uncontrolled construction and deforestation.

Even though the CAG warning has come tragically true, Bahuguna is still beating the development drum. He continues to oppose a December, 2012, Ministry of Environment notification banning all construction activity and ordering the shutdown of all hydro-projects along the Bhagirathi river.  His reasoning:

If you take a decision, then stick to it and not scrap it because some activists raised uproar... We got nod for 53 run of the river hydro projects and we have started the process for 36 of them. We will roll them out for bidding by December after getting all clearances.  By 2016, Uttrakhand will be a power-surplus state.

A power-surplus state with a high fatality rate in flash floods, mudslides and avalanches — but, hey, that's the price of development.

The Chief Minister isn't interested in any talk about unsustainable tourism either. "Without tourism, development will take a hit. It will lead to poverty, unrest and migration and raise a major security issue," he insists. But what about thousands of dead, stranded and starving tourists? Do they not represent a blow to development?

Bahuguna is determined to ignore the other hard lesson of the Uttarakhand tragedy: the Himalayas are not a resort where we can romp at will and in ever greater numbers. "The mountains have a certain carrying capacity. A place where there should be 10,000 to 15, 000 settlements is now flooded with lakhs of pilgrims," environmental expert Maharaja K Pandit tells India Today. Tourists in turn fuel the unplanned construction of hotels, shops and shanty towns which inevitably prove hazardous to human life.

In our national debate, every policy issue becomes a political football, expediently defined to fit ideological calculations. As with Uttarakhand, scoring political points becomes more important than dealing with a national crisis. The truth is that there is little disagreement between the national parties on the matter of the environment, destroying it, that is. Unplanned growth and its unhappy side-effects reflect 20 years of uninterrupted bipartisan consensus which embraces short-term gain over long-term sustainability. It's why we now live with swarms of dengue-carrying mosquitoes, mountains of unprocessed waste, polluted ground water, deforestation, decimated coastlines — the list goes on, and we add to it each day.

And yet we nod our head like sheep each time the free market pundits warn us against environmental extremists.

It's easy enough to roll one's eyes when eco-activists like Narain say “we need to look at ways of development without destroying natural resources.” It sounds absurdly utopian and impractical in the face of our languishing growth rate — and when China is blithely mowing down entire villages to create insta-cities. But what comfort will our disdain bring when our rivers run dry, air turns to smoke, and the mountains come tumbling down?

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

UK Board 12th result 2020 DECLARED: Uttarakhand Board announces HSC results; check official website ubse.uk.gov.in
India

UK Board 12th result 2020 DECLARED: Uttarakhand Board announces HSC results; check official website ubse.uk.gov.in

UK Board 12th result 2020 DECLARED | The Uttarakhand board results are usually released in the first week of June, but got delayed this year due to COVID-19 pandemic.

UK Board 12th result 2020 Pass Percentage: 80.26% students clear Uttarakhand Board HSC exams; girls outshine boys
India

UK Board 12th result 2020 Pass Percentage: 80.26% students clear Uttarakhand Board HSC exams; girls outshine boys

UK Board 12th result 2020 Pass Percentage | The Class 12 or HSC results have been declared by the Uttarakhand Board of School Education (UBSE) today (Wednesday, 29 June)

UK Board result 2020 DECLARED: Alternative websites to check Class 12 scores if official site ubse.uk.gov.in is down
India

UK Board result 2020 DECLARED: Alternative websites to check Class 12 scores if official site ubse.uk.gov.in is down

UK Board result 2020 DECLARED: If the official website is slow or unresponsive due to the heavy traffic after results are out, students can log on to third-party websites to check their scores.