Think India needs to learn how to crush terrorism in Kashmir from Israel? Think again

Lots of Indians think Israel’s better at killing terrorists. Not so. Between 2009 and 2019, Indian forces killed 1,828 non-state combatants in Kashmir whereas Israeli forces killed 1,254 terrorists in Palestine

Praveen Swami August 09, 2019 19:17:07 IST
Think India needs to learn how to crush terrorism in Kashmir from Israel? Think again
  • Israel’s counter-terrorism response is much tougher on civilians; Kashmir had 9.3 civilian fatalities per 100,000 population, whereas, it was 36.7 in Palestinian territories

  • Indian forces killed many more non-state combatants than Israeli forces in 2009-2019 — 1,828 to 1,254

Israel kills a lot more civilians — but isn’t better than India at fighting actual terrorists.

Israel’s counter-terrorism response is much tougher on civilians. Between 2009 and 2019, Israel killed 1,771 Palestinian civilians while Kashmir saw 647 civilian fatalities, however, over half of them were victims of terrorists, not Indian forces. Adjusting for population, Kashmir had 9.3 civilian fatalities per 100,000 population, whereas, it was 36.7 in Palestinian territories.

Think India needs to learn how to crush terrorism in Kashmir from Israel Think again

Indian soldiers in Kashmir. PTI

Lots of Indians think Israel’s also better at killing terrorists. Not so. Indian forces killed many more non-state combatants than Israeli forces in 2009-2019 — 1,828 to 1,254. Population adjusted, both sides were identical, at 26 per 100,000. Bear in mind that Israel’s figures include civilians participating in hostilities, not necessarily armed and trained combatants, and India’s record is even more impressive.

Even though India kills more terrorists than Israel, it also loses more security force personnel — 674 in the 2009-2019 period, to 95 of Israel. This shouldn’t surprise us: Israel spends far more on resourcing its forces. Everything from air reconnaissance to night vision is routinely available to Israeli troops; not so for Indians.

One also needs to understand that India carries out counter-insurgency operations in a terrain tougher than the one faced by Israeli soldiers and next to a nuclear-armed neighbour aiding terrorists.

Think India needs to learn how to crush terrorism in Kashmir from Israel Think again

Updated Date:

also read

JKBOSE Class 11 2020 results for Leh Region announced at jkbose.ac.in; steps to check score
Sports

JKBOSE Class 11 2020 results for Leh Region announced at jkbose.ac.in; steps to check score

The last date to apply for re-evaluation of Class 10 and Class 12 Board papers is 30 April while students can apply for xerox till 26 April.

India more likely to respond with military force to Pakistan's provocations, says US intel report
World

India more likely to respond with military force to Pakistan's provocations, says US intel report

The report also said that although a general war between India and Pakistan is unlikely, crises between the two are likely to become more intense, risking an escalatory cycle

ED summons Mehbooba Mufti's mother Gulshan Nazir in money laundering case; PDP terms it political vendetta
India

ED summons Mehbooba Mufti's mother Gulshan Nazir in money laundering case; PDP terms it political vendetta

The ED wants to question Nazir in her seventies over a few lakh of rupees that were allegedly transferred to her account from the chief minister's discretionary fund