Sterlite Copper tells Madras HC that Tamil Nadu govt's closure order of Tuticorin unit is 'naked' discrimination

Vedanta group's Sterlite Copper on Wednesday told the Madras High Court that the Tamil Nadu government's closure order against its Tuticorin unit was nothing but discrimination. The state government had earlier justified its closure order in its counter affidavit. Unit general manager Sathyapriya said reports of the various committees, constituted by the National Green Tribunal, in support of the unit cannot be ignored.

Press Trust of India June 27, 2019 17:23:49 IST
Sterlite Copper tells Madras HC that Tamil Nadu govt's closure order of Tuticorin unit is 'naked' discrimination
  • Vedanta group's Sterlite Copper on Wednesday told the Madras High Court that the Tamil Nadu government's closure order against its Tuticorin unit was nothing but discrimination

  • The state government had earlier justified its closure order in its counter affidavit

  • Unit general manager Sathyapriya said reports of the various committees, constituted by the National Green Tribunal, in support of the unit cannot be ignored

Chennai: Vedanta group's Sterlite Copper on Wednesday told the Madras High Court that the Tamil Nadu government's closure order against its Tuticorin unit was nothing but "naked" discrimination. It said the order was only a knee-jerk reaction of the state to "appease" a section of public with vested interest.

The state government had earlier justified its closure order in its counter affidavit. Unit general manager Sathyapriya in her rejoinder to the Tamil Nadu government's counter claimed that the order dated 28 May, 2018 ordering closure of the Tuticorin unit was not a policy decision as "the same is clearly aimed at a singular industry rather than a class of industries".

Sterlite Copper tells Madras HC that Tamil Nadu govts closure order of Tuticorin unit is naked discrimination

File image of Sterlite Industries Ltd., copper plant in Tuticorin. Reuters

"It is arbitrary and unreasonable to classify Sterlite alone as a class in itself and hence such policy would be hit by Article 14 of the Constitution." She said reports of the various committees, constituted by the National Green Tribunal, in support of the unit cannot be ignored.

It was unfortunate that the state was taking an adversarial position and not considering the representations from more than 1,55,000 people supporting the opening and restart of the unit, she added. The company further claimed that the state has taken the protection of a "policy decision" only to circumvent the statutory requirements, restrictions and mandate of the 'Air and Water Act' and to seek to limit the grounds of challenge before the court of law.

She pointed out that the company had already deposited Rs 100 crore with the Tuticorin district collector which was imposed by the Supreme Court. "The interest accrued on the said compensation so deposited in 2013 has not been utilised by the district administration for improving the environment, including water and soil, of the vicinity of the plant as was directed by the apex court."

This in itself concludes the fact that there was nothing material to be carried out in terms of environment improvement in the area, the company said. The apex court had ordered the firm to pay Rs 100 crore as compensation for environmental damage around its Tuticorin-based copper smelting unit in Tamil Nadu. "The closure order issued by the Government of Tamil Nadu is nothing but a naked discrimination against the company," it said.

The issue pertains to a plea moved by Sterlite challenging the closure order which is slated to be taken up for hearing by a special division bench of justices T S Sivagnanam and V Bhavani Subbaroyan on 27 June. The government has submitted that permanent closure was ordered in May to prevent further pollution in the area.

Updated Date:

also read

SC to hear plea seeking direction to CBSE for maintaining original results on 6 December
Education

SC to hear plea seeking direction to CBSE for maintaining original results on 6 December

The plea stated that the petitioners have been either declared failed or awarded very less marks in the improvement examinations

'Trial in 99% of POCSO cases was still pending by December 2020'
India

'Trial in 99% of POCSO cases was still pending by December 2020'

According to a study, 42 percent of the total rape cases were committed against children below 18 years in 2020, compared to 47 percent in 2018 and 45 percent in 2019

Supreme Court irked over ONGC's approach to arbitration, asks AG to resolve
India

Supreme Court irked over ONGC's approach to arbitration, asks AG to resolve

The former judge, in the letter, said, I find it embarrassing to continue as a member of the Tribunal and the Claimant can't alone be asked to pay a fee decided by the Tribunal