Shortage of medicines at public hospitals forcing poor to turn to private pharmacies, says Chhattisgarh study

-Denny John New Delhi: As India readies itself for Ayushman Bharat, the national health protection scheme covering primary, secondary and tertiary healthcare, a study from Chhattisgarh reveals poor availability of generic drugs in the state’s public hospitals. Chhattisgarh had announced in 2013 a  policy to guarantee access to free generic medicines in all its public health facilities. Doctors at these facilities were also mandated to prescribe only generic medicines in the essential drug list (EDL) for patients receiving treatment there. Essential medicines “satisfy the priority health care needs of the population”, as per the  World Health Organization (WHO). There are 796 such drugs listed in Chhattisgarh. [caption id=“attachment_4110127” align=“alignleft” width=“380”] Representational image. GettyImage[/caption] In the  study, an analysis of 1,290 prescriptions from 100 public health facilities across 15 districts in Chhattisgarh showed that around 68 percent of the medicines prescribed were generic and from the EDL, but only 58 percent of them were available to the patients at the primary health facilities. The report titled ‘Access and availability of Essential Medicines in Chhattisgarh: Situation in Public Health Facilities’ was published in the January-February 2018 issue of the peer-reviewed Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care. The study was conducted by the State Health Resource Centre at Raipur as part of the evaluation of the implementation phase of the free generic medicine scheme in 2013-14. In 2003, Chhattisgarh was the first state in India to list an EDL, and in 2011 the government set up the Chhattisgarh Medical Services Corporation Limited for centralised procurement, storage and supply-chain management of drugs, surgical items and medical equipment required by its public health facilities. Easy availability of essential drugs is critical for India’s healthcare system. Indians are the sixth biggest out-of-pocket (OOP) health spenders in the low-middle income group of 50 nations, as IndiaSpend  reported in May 2017. And around  70 percent of the overall household expenditure on health is on medicines. An estimated 469 million people in India do not have regular access to essential medicines, according to the WHO. Various  studies have shown the rising out-of-pocket expenditures on healthcare is pushing around 32-39 million Indians below the poverty line annually. “Without the focus on the improvement in coverage and prescription of generic drugs, we may end up in a situation where public health spending goes up without a commensurate reduction in OOP health spending,” said Rajeev Ahuja, a development economist formerly with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and the World Bank. 35 percent of prescribed drugs had to be bought at private facilities As against the overall percentage of prescriptions with generic medicines (68 percent), Raigarh ranked the lowest at 55 percent, as per the study. However, in a third of the districts surveyed, less than 50 percent of generic drugs were available at public health facilities, the lowest being Bilaspur district (38 percent).

Over 35 percent of the generic and branded drugs were purchased from private facilities across all survey sites. Narayanpur reported the highest percentage of generic prescriptions and availability, at 87.37 percent and 84.15 percent, respectively. But the current situation in Chhattisgarh is an improvement over the shortages the state saw in 2011, when only  17 percent of essential paediatric medicines were available. Studies conducted in other states have shown up similar problems. In Punjab and Haryana, only 45.2 percent and 51.1 percent of prescribed medicines were  available at public health facilities. At the Jamnagar Government Medical College  in Gujarat, only 63.34 percent of the drugs prescribed were generic. Across  southern India, only 49.78 percent of the drugs were from essential drug list. A recent  study by IIT-Madras,  reported by IndiaSpend on 25 May, 2018, showed that within six months of upgrading primary health-care facilities (human resources, drugs and diagnostics), there was an overall fall in the financial burden on patients. (John is a public health professional and works as Evidence Synthesis Specialist with the Campbell Collaboration based in New Delhi.)