SC to hear plea challenging constitutional validity of Article 370 in April after request from J&K, Centre

The Supreme Court will hear the matter in the first week of April 2019 after Attorney General KK Venugopal, appearing for the Centre, sought adjournment on the ground that the current situation is very sensitive.

Press Trust of India November 16, 2018 18:57:15 IST
SC to hear plea challenging constitutional validity of Article 370 in April after request from J&K, Centre

New Delhi:The Supreme Court on Friday said it will hear in April a plea challenging the validity of Article 370 of the Constitution, which gives special status to Jammu and Kashmir, following a request by the state and the Centre.

A bench of Justices DY Chandrachud and MR Shah said it will hear the matter in the first week of April 2019 after Attorney General KK Venugopal, appearing for the Centre, sought adjournment on the ground that the current situation is very sensitive.

SC to hear plea challenging constitutional validity of Article 370 in April after request from JK Centre

File image of Supreme Court. PTI

"The political situation in the state is such that the matter should not be heard at this time," he said.

Senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi and advocate Shoeb Alam, appearing for Jammu and Kashmir said that a letter has been circulated seeking adjournment due to the ongoing nine-phase Panchayat polls in the state.

To this, the bench said that it can tag the matter along with a batch of pending petitions challenging Article 35A of the Constitution, under which special rights and privileges are granted to the "permanent residents" of the state.

The suggestion of the bench was opposed by the counsels for the state saying that the two issues are different entirely and the plea should not be tagged along with Article 35A pending petitions.

The bench then posted the matter for further hearing in first week of April, 2019.

On 3 April, the apex court had said that Article 370 of the Constitution is not a temporary provision.

The top court had said that in its earlier verdict of 2017 in the SARFESI case, it has been already held that Article 370 was "not a temporary provision".

"The issue concerned is covered by the judgement of this court in the 2017 SARFAESI matter, where we have held that despite the headnote of Article 370, it is not a temporary provision," the court had said.

The court was hearing an appeal filed by petitioner Kumari Vijayalakshmi Jha, against the Delhi High Court's 11 April 2017 order dismissing the plea seeking a declaration that Article 370 is temporary in nature.

The petitioner had claimed before the high court that Article 370 was a temporary provision that had lapsed with the dissolution of the Constituent Assembly in 1957.

The petition had said that the continuance of the temporary provision of Article 370 even after dissolution of Constituent Assembly of Jammu and Kashmir, and that of Jammu and Kashmir Constitution which has never got the assent of the President of India or Parliament or the government of India, "amounts to fraud on the basic structure of our Constitution".

Updated Date:

also read

Centre looks to restore J&K statehood, PM to discuss roadmap at all-party meet
Politics

Centre looks to restore J&K statehood, PM to discuss roadmap at all-party meet

News18 quoted sources privy to the developments as saying that the region will be granted statehood soon as promised in the past by the Centre, however, there will be no talks on restoring its special constitutional position

Kashmir’s status quo is fragile, PM’s all-party meet key to stopping a dangerous drift
India

Kashmir’s status quo is fragile, PM’s all-party meet key to stopping a dangerous drift

Although killings of terrorists have also been high — 174 ethnic-Kashmiri jihadists were shot last year, up from just 34 in 2016 — levels of violence remain higher than in the five years before the 2016 uprising, data from the South Asia Terrorism Portal shows

From elections, statehood to delimitation: Who said what at PM's all-party meeting with J&K leaders
Politics

From elections, statehood to delimitation: Who said what at PM's all-party meeting with J&K leaders

While the Centre focussed on development and Jammu and Kashmir getting its own elected government, all leaders from J&K demanded full-fledged statehood for the region