SC slams Punjab for 'drama' in Rajoana case

The court on Wednesday during the hearing of the matter had pointed to the different treatment different convicts on the death row receive.

hidden March 29, 2012 21:58:16 IST
SC slams Punjab for 'drama' in Rajoana case

New Delhi: The Supreme Court today criticised Punjab for enacting a "drama" to frustrate the execution of death sentence awarded to Sikh terrorist Balwant Singh Rajoana in the assassination of then Punjab chief minister Beant Singh in 1995.

The apex court bench of Justice GS Singhvi and Justice SJ Mukhopadhaya observed, "We would have liked to avoid everything... but what has happened in last four days in a particular state is a telling situation."

SC slams Punjab for drama in Rajoana case

Supreme Court of India. Reuters

"If decision was taken at an appropriate time, the public exchequer would have been saved many crore of rupees," the court observed.

The court described the entire thing as a drama.

The court further said, "When a person is convicted of a murder of a chief minister in broad daylight, it is being noticed that person is guilty of terrorism, and in this case he has found support of political parties. Parties have garnered support from such persons… how can they now leave them."

The court said this in the course of the hearing where it is examining the question whether a convict who has filed a mercy petition was entitled to commutation of death sentence to life imprisonment on the grounds of inordinate delay in deciding his mercy petition.

The court on Wednesday during the hearing of the matter had pointed to the different treatment different convicts on the death row receive. The court observed that those who have godfathers within and outside the country to orchestrate their case get a different treatment than those who are mute. The court wondered if "we are a country of drum beaters".

Appearing for the government, Additional Solicitor General Harin Rawal told the court that the president would be provided with the health record of the convict on death row only of the time when he had committed the offence and not concerning his health today.

Rawal said this while responding to the court's query Wednesday whether non placement of Devender Pal Singh Bhullar's latest health reports before the President at the time of deciding his mercy petition did not merit a judicial review of the rejection of his mercy petition.

Contesting Bhullar's plea that inordinate delay in deciding his mercy petition was in itself a ground for the commutation of his death sentence, Rawal said that mere delay was not enough for the remission of death sentence to life imprisonment.

Bhullar was convicted and awarded death sentence for his involvement in a bomb blast at Youth Congress office in 1993. Bhullar had filed the mercy petition on 14 January 2003 which was rejected by the President on 25 May 2011.

IANS

Updated Date:

also read

CBSE to conduct optional exam between 15 August to 15 Sept; all you need to know
India

CBSE to conduct optional exam between 15 August to 15 Sept; all you need to know

The CBSE said optional exam will be conducted fro main subjects only and marks obtained in this exam will be treated as final.

SC refuses to stay order removing encroachment on Aravali forest area in Haryana's Faridabad
India

SC refuses to stay order removing encroachment on Aravali forest area in Haryana's Faridabad

The apex court on 7 June had directed the state and the Faridabad municipal corporation to remove all encroachments in Aravali forest area near the village

'Really impressed': CJI responds to schoolgirl's letter lauding SC for saving lives in COVID-19 fight
India

'Really impressed': CJI responds to schoolgirl's letter lauding SC for saving lives in COVID-19 fight

Lidwina Joseph, a student of Kendriya Vidyalaya at Thrissur, enclosed in her letter a drawing depicting discharge of duties by the apex court where a judge is seen hammering down the coronavirus