SC rejects Arnab Goswami's plea to transfer FIR against him to CBI, grants him 3 weeks' protection from any coercive action

Press Trust of India May 19, 2020 15:53:05 IST
SC rejects Arnab Goswami's plea to transfer FIR against him to CBI, grants him 3 weeks' protection from any coercive action

New Delhi: In partial relief to Republic TV editor-in-chief Arnab Goswami, the Supreme Court on Tuesday quashed all criminal investigations related to the news show on Palghar mob-lynching except the initial one that is being probed by the Mumbai Police, but refused his plea for transfer of probe to the CBI.

Observing that journalistic freedom lies at the core of freedom of speech and expression, a bench of Justices DY Chandrachud and MR Shah granted protection to Goswami from any coercive action for three more weeks from today and said that he can approach the competent court for quashing of the FIR.

SC rejects Arnab Goswamis plea to transfer FIR against him to CBI grants him 3 weeks protection from any coercive action

File image of Arnab Goswami. CNN-News18

While quashing multiple FIRs lodged in different places with regard to the news show, the top court said they will have stifling effect and directed that no other FIR or complaint shall be entertained or pursued on basis of broadcast made by Goswami on 21 April.

Pronouncing the verdict through video conferencing, the apex court observed that the right of journalist under Article 19 (1) (a) is at a higher level and that India's freedom of press stays as long as journalists can speak truth to power, but this freedom is not absolute.

The top court on 11 May had directed that no coercive action should be taken against Goswami in the fresh FIR lodged by Mumbai Police on 2 May, for allegedly hurting religious sentiments by making some remarks during his news show.

Goswami has moved the apex court seeking to quash multiple FIRs lodged against him in various states over his alleged defamatory statements against Congress Chief Sonia Gandhi in the show.

Goswami had claimed in the top court that he was interrogated by Mumbai Police for over 12 hours over the FIR on alleged defamatory statements and one of the two investigating officers (IOs) probing the case against him has tested positive for COVID-19 .

The Maharashtra government had also moved the apex court alleging that Goswami has been misusing protection granted by the top court and has been "browbeating" the police by "creating fear psychosis".

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, supported Goswami for transfer of the probe to CBI saying that since the accused has made allegations against the police, which too has made certain accusations, the court must look at the possibility of having a probe by an independent agency.

The top court on 24 April had granted three-week protection to Goswami against any coercive steps in connection with some FIRs lodged against him in various states for alleged defamatory statements made during news show on Palghar mob-lynching of three persons, including two saints in Maharashtra.

Staying further proceedings in the three FIRs and 11 complaints lodged in different states except for the one FIR lodged in Nagpur city, the top court had said there is a need for the law to protect journalistic freedom within the ambit of Article 19(1) (a) (freedom of speech and expression) of the Constitution.

The FIRs and complaints were lodged in Chhattisgarh, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh and Jharkhand.

The top court had transferred the FIR lodged in Nagpur city to the NM Joshi Marg Police Station, Mumbai, where Goswami has lodged a case in connection with an attack on him and his wife allegedly by some Congress workers and said the senior journalist would cooperate in the investigation.

The 2 May fresh FIR, was lodged in Mumbai against Goswami and two others for allegedly hurting religious sentiments by making derogatory remark regarding a mosque located in suburban Bandra.

Hundreds of migrant workers had gathered in Bandra on 14 April demanding transport arrangements to go back to their native places, hours after Prime Minister Narendra Modi had announced extension of the nationwide lockdown due to COVID-19 till 3 May.

The FIR was lodged in Pydhonie police station in south Mumbai on 2 May by Irfan Abubakar Sheikh, secretary of Raza Education Welfare Society.

Updated Date:

also read

SC rejects EC's plea to expunge Madras HC remarks, says citizens have a right to know what transpires in courts
India

SC rejects EC's plea to expunge Madras HC remarks, says citizens have a right to know what transpires in courts

The top court said it is a staunch proponent of freedom of media to report court proceedings and that the EC's contention that press should be reporting orders only and not observations struck at principles of open court

SC quashes Maharashtra law granting Maratha reservations, says community can't be declared as backward
India

SC quashes Maharashtra law granting Maratha reservations, says community can't be declared as backward

The top court has struck down the Maharashtra State Reservation for Socially and Educationally Backward Classes (SEBC) Act, 2018

'Not system, Modi govt failed people': Sonia Gandhi demands all-party meet on COVID-19
India

'Not system, Modi govt failed people': Sonia Gandhi demands all-party meet on COVID-19

The Congress president also said that the Indian National Congress' performance in the just-concluded Assembly elections was 'very disappointing'