'Rising tide of violence, surveillance': Freedom of expression severely deteriorated under Modi govt, says PEN International

Pune/New Delhi: India has witnessed “a rising tide of violence, impunity, extended pre-trial detentions and surveillance” under the Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led NDA government, PEN International said on Saturday, as it wound up the 84th PEN International Congress with representation from over 80 countries in Pune. The international writers’ body called upon the Indian government to safeguard the freedom of expression in the country. It released a report titled “ India: Pursuing truth in the face of intolerance”, outlining how dissenting voices — journalists, writers, academics or students — “face intimidation, harassment, prosecution, online abuse and physical violence. “The report illustrates the varied ways in which critical voices are targeted and silenced. It highlights “directed attacks online and offline; the systematic stifling of academic research and freedom; and the continued marginalisation of and hostility towards women’s voices.” [caption id=“attachment_4972471” align=“alignleft” width=“380”] People attend a protest in New Delhi against the killing of Gauri Lankesh. Reuters[/caption] “Laws that stifle speech, an environment hostile to dissenting views, and emboldened critics online and in the real world have cast a chill over free expression in India. Journalists and writers have been sued, intimidated, threatened, and sometimes murdered. There is little political will to amend the laws that prevent free expression or to enforce laws that protect the writer,” said Salil Tripathi, chair of the Writers in Prison Committee. PEN International said in an official statement that it “calls on the Indian authorities to protect its writers, journalists and all others exercising their right to free expression” and to “bring its legislation in line with its obligations under international law”. “While this gathering has been about the promotion of peace-building and celebrating the power of the written word, it is also about protecting free expression and remembering those of us who pay the ultimate price for exercising this fundamental right. Today, we honour Gauri Lankesh, who was shot to death outside her home a year ago. Even though we welcome the progress that has been in the investigation, we’re still waiting for justice. Unless the cycle of impunity is broken, those who want to use violence to silence will be embolden to do so,” said PEN International president Jennifer Clement. Asked about the views and findings of the PEN as far as worsening of situations under the ruling regime is concerned, American-Mexican author Clement unequivocally said there has been “a rising tide of violence, impunity, extended pre-trial detentions, impunity and surveillance”. “We have quite a few recommendations to the Indian government: To ensure the safety of journalists and make sure that there is no impunity against them, to ensure that they are not harmed, as has been seen in several high-profile cases, train the police, launch public information campaign to inform citizens of their legal rights in the face of online harassment and threats,” Clement, the first female president of the body, said. She added that the PEN International felt “very strongly”, especially in a country like India, as “the differences are what unites people and not what divides them”. “The government should be thinking about the things that bring people together and not tear them apart. I think what PEN is concerned about is that India has always been a country that one could uphold for being tolerant and being democratic. It used to be (said) that India could be held as an example to the rest of the world. It’s very sad to see this turn. What would the future of such a democracy look like,” she asked. The 15-page report “India: Pursuing truth in the face of intolerance” is highly critical of the Modi government and opens with a poster of the firebrand journalist-activist Gauri Lankesh, who was murdered outside her Bengaluru home in September 2017. PEN said that it prepares “a freedom of expression report” every year on the country in which its Congress is being held. The report contends that “future generations will likely look back at the Bharatiya Janata Party’s win in 2014 elections” as “the beginning of a drastically different era in independent India”. Notably, of its three new vice presidents, chosen for their “literary merit”, two are dissenting voices from India: Tamil writer Perumal Murugan, who was himself hounded by right-wing activists, and Nayantara Sahgal, who has been at the forefront of protests by writers and intellectuals against the Modi government.