Prove you are 'Indian': MHA to RTI seeking details of Ishrat Jahan's probe panel

In a rare instance, the Home Ministry has asked an RTI applicant to prove he is an Indian before disclosing details about the one-member panel looking into the missing files related to the alleged fake encounter case of Ishrat Jahan.

PTI June 15, 2016 12:42:46 IST
Prove you are 'Indian': MHA to RTI seeking details of Ishrat Jahan's probe panel

New Delhi: In a rare instance, the Home Ministry has asked an RTI applicant to prove he is an Indian before disclosing details about the one-member panel looking into the missing files related to the alleged fake encounter case of Ishrat Jahan.

Senior IAS officer BK Prasad, Additional Secretary in the Home Ministry, heads the inquiry panel. The RTI application was filed with the Ministry seeking copies of reports submitted by the panel besides file notings related to the extension in service given to Prasad.

Prove you are Indian MHA to RTI seeking details of Ishrat Jahans probe panel

File image of Ishrat Jahan. IBN

"In this connection, it is requested that a proof of your Indian citizenship may please be provided," the Home Ministry said in its reply.

As per Right to Information Act, 2005, only Indian citizens can seek information. Usually, a proof of citizenship is not required to file an application under the transparency law. In rare cases, a public information officer can seek proof of nationality in case he has doubt over citizenship of an applicant.

"It is a way to block free flow of information and transparency by the government. Seeking proof of Indian citizenship must be discouraged. The Home Ministry appears to delay the information sought from it," said RTI activist Ajay Dubey.

Prasad, who heads the probe panel, is a 1983 batch IAS officer of Tamil Nadu cadre and was due to retire on 31 May. He has been given two months extension in service till 31 July.

Following an uproar in Parliament in March this year, the Home Ministry had asked Prasad to inquire into the whole matter of missing papers. The panel is yet to submit its report.

19-year-old Ishrat Jahan and three others were killed in an alleged fake encounter in Gujarat in 2004. The Gujarat Police had then said those killed were LeT terrorists and had come to Gujarat to assassinate the then Chief Minister Narendra Modi.

The probe panel has recently found a copy of a letter written by the then Home Secretary GK Pillai to the then Attorney General late GE Vahanvati from the hard disk of a computer of the Home Ministry, official sources said.

The papers, which disappeared from the Home Ministry, include the copy of an affidavit vetted by the then Attorney General and submitted in the Gujarat High Court in 2009 and the draft of the second affidavit vetted by the AG on which changes were made.

Two letters written by Pillai to Vahanvati and the copy of the draft affidavit have also so far remained untraceable.

Updated Date:

also read

Republic Day 2022 Updates: Grand flypast by IAF craft wows spectators; celebrations continue
India

Republic Day 2022 Updates: Grand flypast by IAF craft wows spectators; celebrations continue

Republic Day 2022 LATEST Updates: Last year, President Kovind hosted the ‘At Home’ reception at Rashtrapati Bhavan on the occasion of 72nd Republic Day. The ceremony has been cancelled this year in view of the COVID-19 situation

2022 Republic Day: Parade to see 24,000 people in attendance, foreign dignitary as chief guest unlikely
India

2022 Republic Day: Parade to see 24,000 people in attendance, foreign dignitary as chief guest unlikely

Out of the approximately 24,000 people who will be attending the parade this year, 19,000 would be invited and the rest would be the general public, who can purchase tickets, sources said

Lavanya episode shows how deep the missionary rot is in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh
India

Lavanya episode shows how deep the missionary rot is in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh

A study released by the Centre for Policy Studies, a Chennai think tank, in 2016 revealed that Tamil Nadu was the most favourable state in India for the growth of Christianity