Pakistan honours Maharaja Ranjit Singh, celebrates Bhagat Singh; but India opposed to Jinnah's portrait due to 'religious nationalism'
The question is why Pakistan thinks that these men are celebrated when India is going through a strong anti-Muslim phase. And it is because Pakistan also has a powerful Punjabi nationalism. More than half of Pakistan is Punjabi speaking.
The question is why Pakistan thinks that these men are celebrated when India is going through a strong anti-Muslim phase
More than half of Pakistan is Punjabi speaking. Of Pakistan’s five biggest cities, four — Lahore, Rawalpindi, Gujranwala, and Faisalabad — are in Punjab
In Pakistan, there has been no problem about the installation of the statues of these men, unlike the Jinnah portrait or other controversies that seem to be present in India these days quite regularly
On 28 June, Friday, an unusual report was published in Pakistan’s Dawn newspaper — founded by Muhammad Ali Jinnah: "In a colourful ceremony, the statue of the Sikh ruler Maharaja Ranjit Singh was unveiled at the Lahore Fort, at the Mai Jinda’s Haveli, on Thursday evening. The nine feet tall statue, made of cold bronze, shows the regal Sikh emperor sitting on a horse, sword in hand, complete in Sikh attire."
Sculpted by local artists, under the aegis of the Fakir Khana Museum, the statue is meant to invoke the feeling of the emperor being present, with its real-life proportions, and was unveiled on the king's 180th death anniversary, who passed away in 1839.
The unveiling ceremony was highlighted by some daring ‘gatka’ performances, or Sikh martial arts, where young boys displayed the different styles of attacking and sparring with various tools, including sticks that intend to simulate swords, a spiked ball and chain, and other weapons. The performances showed how a stealthily-trained warrior could manage to do the most daring feats, such as in the display of this skill, the stick or gatka wielding warrior easily broke earthen pots, and coconuts balanced on others’ heads, while two expert warriors sparred inside a circle of fire.”
Another unusual report was published on 24 March, 2019: "A motley group of followers of Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev Saturday paid tributes to the trio on their 88th martyrdom anniversary at Shadman Chowk in Lahore city of Pakistan, the spot which was once a part of a jail where they were hanged by the British on 23 March, 1931.
The spot reverberated with the chants of ‘Bhagat Singh Zinda Hai’ and ‘Shaheed Bhagat Singh Teri Soch Tey, Pehra Denge Thok Ke’ as Lahore residents, including women and children, with candles in their hands, paid tributes to the martyrs. The initiative was spearheaded by Bhagat Singh Memorial Foundation, which is run by Imtiaz Rashid Qureshi who had also filed a petition in Lahore High Court to rename Shadman Chowk as ‘Shaheed Bhagat Singh Chowk."
The question is why Pakistan celebrates these men when India is going through a strong anti-Muslim phase. And it is because Pakistan also has a powerful Punjabi nationalism. More than half of Pakistan is Punjabi-speaking. Of Pakistan’s five biggest cities, four — Lahore, Rawalpindi, Gujranwala, and Faisalabad — are in Punjab. About 80 percent of the Pakistani army is Punjabi.
The Sikh empire of Ranjit Singh was the only time in Indian history when Punjabis dominated northern India, and Singh is seen as a Punjabi hero, which he was. Singh’s armies marched into Kabul and he and Tipu Sultan were the last real independent rulers in a subcontinent when the British had defeated the rest. He was a great warrior and it is only after the death of Singh, that the British were able to conquer Punjab.
It may interest readers to know that the reason why the Dogra Rajputs of Jammu rule Kashmir is their betrayal of Punjab. Without this betrayal, Jammu and Kashmir would be two separate states today. To know how big the prize was, consider this: there were only five kingdoms in India which were big enough for their rulers to merit the 21-gun salute: Mysore, Hyderabad, Baroda, Gwalior and Jammu, and Kashmir.
Most Indians do not know that the history of 18th century India, after the death of Aurangzeb, there were a series of attacks by one Hindu ruler against another. The Marathas extorted so much money from the Rajputs that Maharaja Ishwari Singh, son of Jaipur’s founder Sawai Jai Singh, committed suicide in December 1750. In revenge, on 10 January, the Rajputs spent nine hours slaughtering a troop of 4,000 Marathas who had entered the city as conquerors. This is not taught in our history books. Knowledge of this will confuse most Indians because our understanding is coloured by our religious nationalism.
In Pakistan, there has been no problem about the installation of the statues of these men, unlike the Jinnah portrait or other controversies that seem to be present in India these days quite regularly. As Indians, we do not expect that our heroes are given any space in Pakistan, and that is why I say that these reports seem strange. But the fact is that Indians are mostly ignorant of Pakistan and our knowledge is second-hand and comes from a deranged Indian media.
Left to Right: In Jangalmahal, history of political partisanship, economic aspirations push voters towards BJP
Jangalmahal is now seen as one of the strongholds of the BJP, and the party claims it will win all seats in the region
Anti-France protests in Pakistan: At least 7 police officers and rangers taken hostage by Islamist party supporters
Rioting has rocked the country since Monday, when the leader of the now-banned Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan was detained in Lahore after calling for the expulsion of the French ambassador
What these two films have in common is how they create a sense of a setting as something inseparable from the inner lives of the protagonists.