Justice J Chelameswar says he stood up for 'certain issues and values'; asserts he had nothing personal against anyone

Supreme Court judge Justice Jasti Chelameswar, who retired on Friday, has said that he stood up for certain 'issues and values'.

IANS May 19, 2018 20:15:06 IST
Justice J Chelameswar says he stood up for 'certain issues and values'; asserts he had nothing personal against anyone

New Delhi: Supreme Court judge Justice Jasti Chelameswar, who retired on Friday, has said that he stood up for certain "issues and values" wherever he perceived things were going wrong and had nothing personal against anyone in the system.

"I stood up for certain issues and values. Wherever I perceived that things were going wrong, I stood up, I raised questions... If something is good, it is to be preserved. If something is doubtful, it is to be checked and rectified, I had nothing personal against anyone in the system," Justice Chelameswar said in a farewell event on Friday.

He also said the younger generation of lawyers has supported him in "democratising the institution", but acknowledged constitutional lawyers and jurists attacked him from every side.

"What is the law or the scripture which says judges cannot hold press conferences? They shouldn't hold a press conference to defend their judgments, I knew that when I opened my mouth I would have to go through all this and I was willing to take it...," he added.

Justice J Chelameswar says he stood up for certain issues and values asserts he had nothing personal against anyone

File image of Justice J Chelameswar. PTI

Justice Chelameswar had turned down the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA)'s request to participate in a farewell function it wanted to arrange for him, saying he wanted his retirement to be a "private affair". However, later in the evening on Friday, he attended a reception organised by Lawyers Collective.

On his last working day on Friday, he shared a bench with Chief Justice Dipak Misra, a custom and practice of the Supreme Court.

The 65-year-old judge has been at loggerheads with Justice Misra over the functioning of the apex court including the allocation of sensitive cases and on recommendation of judges for appointment to higher judiciary.

He was at the forefront of the unprecedented press conference on 12 January saying "all was not well" on the administrative side of the court.

At the gathering of Lawyers Collective, an advocacy NGO founded by activist senior lawyers Indira Jaising and Anand Grover, on Friday, Justice Chelameswar said in the last six months, wherever he went in the country, people have come up to him and said: "We are glad you did it".

He said he was willing to face the consequences of his actions, whether it be his abstention from collegium meetings after the NJAC judgment or the press conference he held.

He told the younger generation present at the gathering that they required to have courage and determination to fight the system if they want to bring a good change.

"But if you are convinced on principle that the fight is to be carried on for good change, please go ahead. If you have an opinion, speak up," he added.

Updated Date:

also read

COVID-19 pandemic offers perfect opportunity to improve India's legal system through disruptive tech, here's why
India

COVID-19 pandemic offers perfect opportunity to improve India's legal system through disruptive tech, here's why

Big data and machine learning can transform how we handle dispute resolution and may do wonders

High Court constitutes 3-member panel under ex-SC judge to probe Manika Batra's allegation of match-fixing
Sports

High Court constitutes 3-member panel under ex-SC judge to probe Manika Batra's allegation of match-fixing

Batra, who was left out of the Indian contingent for the Asian Table Tennis Championships, had moved the court earlier this year alleging that the national coach Soumyadeep Roy pressurised her to throw away an Olympic qualifier match in favour of one of his trainees.

Pakistan Parliament enacts law to give Kulbhushan Jadhav right to file review appeal against his conviction
India

Pakistan Parliament enacts law to give Kulbhushan Jadhav right to file review appeal against his conviction

Jadhav, a 51-year-old retired Indian Navy officer, was sentenced to death by a Pakistani military court on charges of espionage and terrorism in April 2017