ISB deletes tweet dissociating from Shamika Ravi amidst last year's plagiarism row; Brookings reinstates economist's 2019 piece
The International School of Business had attempted to disassociate itself from Ravi on 29 May with a tweet stating that she was 'not a permanent faculty member'.
Editor's note: This article was originally published on 29 May last year. The article and headline are being updated to reflect developments in the story
Update: On 27 May last year, The Indian Express withdrew a piece by economist Shamika Ravi on account of the author's alleged failure to make attributions to the work of economist Karthik Muralidharan and 2018 Nobel Laureate in Economics Paul Romer. Following this, the Brookings Institute briefly took down a piece by the author titled 'Accelerating Financial Inclusion in India'.
The piece soon reappeared on the website carrying a note that read, "This blog post and report were published with 2 sentences on page 6 that lacked proper citation of work originally printed in a report by the Government of India, as well as a sentence on page 7 that was not properly attributed to a publication from CGAP. As of June 9 2020, both have been updated to include these citations."
The International School of Business had attempted to disassociate itself from Ravi on 29 May with a tweet stating that she was 'not a permanent faculty member'. That tweet has subsequently been deleted and the school has reportedly sought a rapprochement with Ravi:
Some non-Covid update: Received multiple requests from @ISBedu to continue my association. The school has repeatedly assured me of valuing my contribution & wishes that it had handled matters better. I have agreed & look forward to a positive and mutually respectful association. — Prof Shamika Ravi (@ShamikaRavi) February 2, 2021
The original text of the article follows:
Two days after The Indian Express withdrew the piece by Ravi over allegations of plagiarism, the Indian School of Business took to Twitter to state that Ravi was not a permanent faculty at the institute, but rather an adjunct faculty who "taught in some of our programmes".
The Indian School of Business (ISB), on its Twitter handle, put out a series of tweets on Ravi, a former member of the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council and non-resident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, whose piece entitled 'A Pandemic Prescription', which appeared in the print and digital versions of the Indian Express, was withdrawn.
ISB would like to clarify that Dr Shamika Ravi is not a permanent faculty member at the ISB. She is an adjunct faculty member who has taught in some of our ISB's programmes. @IndianExpress recently withdrew Dr Ravi's press article titled 'A Pandemic Prescription.' dated May 25.
— ISB (@ISBedu) May 29, 2020
The ISB, noting that Ravi had publicly apologised for plagiarism, also said that the institute's management had formally written to Ravi to correct her Twitter handle signature which states her affiliation as 'Professor at ISB.' Ravi, responding to the ISB tweet, stated that she was not an adjunct faculty, but a visiting professor. She added that she was permanent faculty from 2005 to 2015 and that she had not heard from ISB management.
1) I am not an adjunct faculty but Visiting Professor @ISBedu. Was permanent faculty from 2005-15. Have taught too many courses to keep count in 16 yrs. 2) I put out a public apology LONG before IE did anything. 3) I've not heard from ISB management. 4) Grow up.Don't get bullied. https://t.co/M1dFAtkjZV — Prof Shamika Ravi (@ShamikaRavi) May 29, 2020
Ravi further retweeted an ISB tweet from 5 April, 2019, that congratulated her for being selected "Professor of the Year" for elective courses by the PGP Class of 2019.
— Prof Shamika Ravi (@ShamikaRavi) May 29, 2020
The Brookings Institution, which in a tweet on Wednesday, said it is "looking further into this matter" and is "committed to maintaining the highest integrity in its research and takes very seriously any allegations of plagiarism by its experts" has also seemingly withdrawn a paper by Ravi. The piece entitled 'Accelerating Financial Inclusion in India' was published on 5 March, 2019. Clicking on a URL for the paper on the Brookings website takes you to a webpage which gives the 'Page Not Found' error.
On 27 May, the Indian Express had published an op-ed explaining the particulars of why they were withdrawing Ravi's piece originally published on 25 May. The paper explained Ravi had failed to attribute part of the cost calculations needed to minimise the spread of the pandemic to work done by economist Karthik Muralidharan, after which it agreed to add the attribution in the online version. The paper was subsequently made aware of allegations that some other parts of the same piece were similar to sections of a paper entitled ‘Roadmap to Responsibly Reopen America’, published on 23 April by Paul Romer, a professor at New York University and 2018 Nobel Laureate in Economics. The newspaper explained that its editorial team found four sections, one to three sentences each, that consisted of substantial or verbatim quotation, unacknowledged, from Romer’s piece. Ravi wrote to the newspaper again saying she had spoken to Romer in light of the allegations of plagiarism, following which the paper contacted Romer and concluded that Ravi's piece did not meet its standards of professional integrity.
Tourism hotspot Sanya is a city of more than a million people on the southern island of Hainan, where 483 Covid cases were reported Sunday. All flights out of the city were cancelled over the weekend, with authorities also halting train ticket sales
Directorate General of Civil Aviation said it will be conducting "random checks" in aircraft across the country to see if the COVID-19 protocol is being enforced or not
The results show that certain animals are more able to make these types of 'pan-SARS virus' antibodies than humans, giving scientists clues as to how to make better vaccines