Five hurt in Mumbai overbridge collapse, two critical; Piyush Goyal orders joint audit as major mishap averted

An over-bridge at a railway station in Mumbai’s Andheri suburb collapsed on Tuesday during heavy rains, massively disrupting train services, injuring five people and putting the spotlight once again on the creaky infrastructure of this metropolis. The Brihamumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) said among the injured, one man and a woman were critical. The woman Asmita Katkar underwent a surgery at the Cooper Hospital in Ville Parle, while the second patient, Manoj Mehta survived a spinal cord injury and will undergo a surgery at the Nanavati Hospital. Union railway minister Piyush Goyal expressed regret at the incident and said that the government will take care of all the expenses of treatment, while they will be paid Rs 1 lakh each as compensation. Following the bridge collapse, Maharashtra chief minister Devendra Fadnavis asked the Mumbai police commissioner to ensure smooth traffic movement and directed the BMC to increase its bus service. Major disaster averted A major disaster was also averted as a packed train that was to pass Andheri station stopped a few metres from the collapsed bridge, thanks to motorman Chandrashekhar B Sawant’s quick action in stopping the train when he saw a portion of the bridge collapsing. “I immediately applied emergency brakes and the train stopped,” Sawant told reporters. “The collapse was accompanied by a big thud sound of debris falling,” he said. Goyal lauded the railways’ employee and announced a Rs 5 lakh as a reward for him. A part of the 47-year-old Gokhale over-bridge came down at 7.30 am before the commuter rush hour had started, which was the likely reason the casualty figure remained low. Normally, thousands of commuters use the bridge, which connects Andheri East and Andheri West stations. The falling bridge entangled with overhead wires which fell on the tracks below, halting local train services on the western line, officials said, causing immense inconvenience to Mumbaikars for whom local trains are a lifeline. Some long-distance trains were also cancelled or rescheduled. “Incessant rains apparently caused cracks in the (bridge), resulting in its collapse. Thankfully, no train was passing on the track under the bridge at that time,” said a civic official. Mumbai’s famous tiffin carriers, the ‘Dabbawalas’, who use local trains to ferry hundreds of thousands of lunch boxes from homes, were also unable to deliver on Tuesday as pounding rain lashed the city, clogging several roads with shin-high water. Goyal, who visited the accident site, ordered an inquiry by the Commissioner of Rail Safety whose report would have to be submitted within 15 days. Expressing regret over the accident, he said it was “very unfortunate” and “most unexpected”. He said around 700 employees of the railways, helped by some experts from Delhi and Lucknow, were working on the restoration work and the train services will be resumed completely by tonight. Western Railways spokesman Ravinder Bhakar told PTI that overhead equipment above the tracks was damaged and a team of engineers is working to restore services. Only nine months ago, in September, a stampede on a foot-over-bridge linking Elphinstone Road and Parel suburban railway stations killed 22 people and injured many. Piyush Goyal announces joint audit, safety inquiry The minister said the last safety audit of the Gokhale bridge had been conducted on 12 November last year and nothing wrong was found. He instead blamed the cantilever beam structure, which caused a huge chunk to collapse at the same time. Goyal said that during the next six months, a joint safety audit will be conducted by the railways, the BMC and the Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay on the 445 road over-bridges, foot- over-bridges and bridges over pipelines in Mumbai as part of efforts to improve safety for commuters. Another senior official said the structural audit of all foot and road-over-bridges, including the one which collapsed, is underway.   Political blame game  Mumbai NCP chief Sachin Ahir termed it as “another failure” of authorities and criticised the ruling BJP and the Shiv Sena for not doing enough for residents of the megacity. However, BJP leaders said it was time to help the stranded commuters rather than indulging in ‘blame game’. Guardian minister of suburban Mumbai Vinod Tawde said the railways should conduct a thorough probe into the incident. Mumbai Congress chief Sanjay Nirupam said the railways minister should ensure hassle-free and fearless journey for travellers. “The regular occurrence of accidents has shaken the confidence of rail passengers,” he said in a video message. The Western Railway has made arrangements for the refund of tickets of passengers travelling by long-distance trains which were cancelled because of the incident. Western Railways commuters were permitted to travel on alternative routes of the Central Railway. Private airlines Vistara and Jet Airways said they will accommodate passengers running late due to traffic congestion because of the incident. With inputs from PTI