Eighth round of talks between Centre, farmers fail to break month-long deadlock; next meet on 15 Jan

The eighth round of negotiations between protesting farmers and Centre also ended without any conclusion, as neither parties agreed to budge from their stand on the key demand of repeal of the three contentious farm legislations. In fact, very little headway could be made in Friday’s meeting, if the account of some of the members of the delegation is taken as an accurate representation of the day’s events. As per the account of farm leaders, Union Agriculture minister Narendra Singh Tomar stated at the outset that the government cannot and will not consider repealing the laws. Tomar, who had also met Home Minister Amit Shah before conducting talks with farmers, reportedly took a firm stand that the government was only interested in a clause-by-clause discussion on contentious topics within the laws. However, the farmers, who have been sensitive about the issue of total roll back of these legislations, took umbrage at this attitude and decided to dish out the silent treatment to the three Union ministers present in the meeting. As per PTI, after Tomar’s initial remarks, the farmers’ delegation sat their in complete silence, holding placards declaring, “We will either win, or die.” Eighth rounds of talks fail Sticking to their key demand of the repeal of three farm laws to end their protest, farmer leaders on Friday told the government their “ghar wapsi” can happen only after “law wapsi” but the Centre insisted talks must be limited to contentious clauses and ruled out a complete withdrawal of Acts. At the eighth round of negotiations with the 41-member representative group of protesting farmers, the government asserted the farm reform laws have been welcomed by a large section of farmers in various states and asked the unions to think about the interests of the entire country. Apart from Tomar, Minister for Railways, Commerce and Food Piyush Goyal and Minister of State for Commerce Som Parkash, who is an MP from Punjab, are holding talks with unions at Vigyan Bhawan in the heart of the National Capital, while thousands of farmers have stayed put at various Delhi borders to protest against the three laws they find pro-corporate and against the existing mandi and MSP procurement systems. At the outset, Tomar appealed to unions for discussions on the laws, while farm leaders reiterated their demand that the new Acts must be withdrawn, sources said, adding that the agriculture minister stressed on protecting the farmers’ interest of the entire country. “Our ‘ghar wapsi’ (return to home) can happen only if you do ’law wapsi’ (repeal of laws),” a farmer leader said at the meeting. “Ideally, the Centre should not interfere in agriculture matters as various Supreme Court orders have declared farming as a state subject. It seems you (the government) do not want to resolve the issue as talks have been happening for so many days. In that case, please give us a clear answer and we will go. Why to waste everyone’s time,” another farmer leader said at the meeting. All India Kisan Sangharsh Coordination Committee (AIKSCC) member Kavitha Kuruganti, who was also present in the meeting, said the government has told unions that it can not and will not repeal these laws. Around one hour after the meeting, the three ministers stepped out of the discussion hall for their own internal consultations, after union leaders decided to observe silence while holding out papers with slogans including ‘Jeetenge ya Marenge’ (We will either win or die). The union leaders, however, refused to take a lunch break and stayed put in the meeting room, a source said. Another union leader Hannan Mollah said farmers are ready to fight till death and going to court was not an option. He said the farmer unions will meet on 11 January to decide their next course of action. Jai Kisan Andolan union leader Ravinder Kaur was seen crying after the meeting and said many mothers have lost their sons and many daughters have lost their fathers. On 4 January, the seventh round of talks ended inconclusively as the unions stuck to their demand for a complete repeal of three farm laws, while the government wanted to discuss only the “problematic” clauses or other alternatives to end the stalemate. Before that, in the sixth round of talks held on 30 December last year, some common ground was reached on two demands — decriminalisation of stubble-burning and continuation of power subsidies. Earlier in the day, Union Minister of State for Agriculture Kailash Choudhury had hoped that a resolution will come out of Friday’s meeting. “I am hopeful that a resolution will be reached at Friday’s meeting. We could have ended the deadlock by now had the protesting farmer unions discussed the issues raised at the first meeting,” he told PTI. Choudhury also said there was no demand for the repeal of the three farm laws at the first meeting and this demand came up much later. Just before the meeting, Kuruganti had said: “If no solution arrived in today’s meeting, we will continue with our plan of tractor rally on 26 January.” “Our main demand is the repeal of the laws. We will not accept any amendments. The government is taking it as a prestige issue and not taking back the laws. But this is a life and death question for all farmers. There is no change in our stand since the beginning,” she added. Tomar says no decision at meet as unions did not offer alternatives to repeal of laws  Speaking to reporters after the meeting that lasted for little over two hours, Tomar said the government is still hopeful that union leaders will come with alternatives to discuss in the next round of talks on 15 January. But, he virtually ruled out repeal of the laws saying many other groups across the country are supporting these reforms. On whether the government made a proposal to farmers to join a pending case in Supreme Court on issues related to farmers’ protest, Tomar said the government did not make any such suggestion but it is always committed to follow whatever is decided by the Supreme Court. The agitating farmers took out tractor rallies on Thursday to press their demand for a rollback of the laws, while the Centre asserted that it was ready to consider any proposal other than a repeal of the legislations. Thousands of farmers, mainly from Punjab, Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh, are protesting at various border points of Delhi for over a month now against the three laws, despite the cold weather and heavy rains. Enacted in September 2020, the government has presented these laws as major farm reforms aimed at increasing farmers’ income, but the protesting farmers have raised concerns that these legislations would weaken the minimum support price (MSP) and “mandi” (wholesale market) systems and leave them at the mercy of big corporations. The government has maintained that these apprehensions are misplaced and has ruled out a repeal of the laws. While several opposition parties and people from other walks of life have come out in support of the farmers, some farmer groups have met the agriculture minister over the last few weeks to extend their support to the three laws. The government had sent a draft proposal to the protesting farmer unions last month, suggesting seven-eight amendments to the new laws and a written assurance on the MSP procurement system. With inputs from PTI