EC tells Supreme Court Narendra Modi biopic a 'hagiography', its public screening will tilt electoral balance
In its 20-page report submitted to the apex court bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi on the film titled 'PM Narendra Modi', the poll panel said that the biopic 'produces a political environment where an individual acquired cult status' and its public screening during the period when Model Code of Conduct (MCC) is in operation would favour a particular political party.
The Election Commission told the Supreme Court that the Narendra Modi biopic 'produces a political environment where an individual acquired cult status'
It also said the film's public screening during the period when Model Code of Conduct is in operation would favour a particular political party
The poll panel made the remarks in its 20-page report submitted to the apex court bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogo
New Delhi: The biopic on Prime Minister Narendra Modi is a "hagiography", which treats the subject with undue reverence, and its public screening during poll campaign will "tilt the electoral balance", the Election Commission (EC) has told the Supreme Court while opposing the release of the movie starring Vivek Oberoi before the polls end on 19 May.
In its 20-page report submitted to the apex court bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi on the film titled 'PM Narendra Modi', the poll panel said that the biopic "produces a political environment where an individual acquired cult status" and its public screening during the period when Model Code of Conduct (MCC) is in operation would favour a particular political party.
The poll panel said "there are several scenes depicting a major Opposition party as corrupt and showing them in poor light. Their leaders have been depicted in such a manner that their identification is clear and obvious to the viewers."
It said that the biopic was more than a biography and was a "hagiography" (which treats the subject as saints and gives undue reverence) and the construct of the movie was "unabashedly uni-dimensional", which puts an individual on a higher pedestal through use of specific symbols, slogans and scenes.
The report was submitted after the apex court had on 15 April directed the poll panel to re-examine its earlier order and take an informed decision on banning pan-India the release of the biopic after watching the full movie.
The court had asked the poll panel to provide its report to the producer of the movie.
The Election Commission said in its report that the movie eulogises the character of Modi and its "synopsis provided with the script ends on an interesting sentence — 'India is Modi and Modi is India'. This is reminiscent of the infamous statement by Congress leader DK Baruah, who had said 'Indira is India and India is Indira' in the 1970s."
"The committee is of the considered view that the public screening of the movie PM Narendra Modi during the period of MCC will tilt the electoral balance of the particular political party, therefore, the public screening of the movie PM Narendra Modi should not be allowed till last date of poll on 19 May in the ongoing elections."
It also said that the biopic "produces a political environment where an individual acquired cult status. The construct of this 135-minute movie is unabashedly uni-dimensional, which puts an individual on a higher pedestal through use of specific symbols, slogans and scenes.
It ends up eulogising an individual, giving him a saintly status".
Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for film producers who have challenged the poll panel's ban on the biopic's release till the current general election is over, had earlier told the top court that the poll panel has taken the decision after watching a two-minute promo, and not the entire movie.
The Election Commission's counsel Amit Sharma had said that the entire movie was not available and a decision to ban the release was taken after watching the trailer.
The bench had then asked the poll panel to watch the full movie and then take an informed decision on whether its release should be banned or not.
The commission had on 10 April stalled the release of the film until the polls end, asserting that any biopic material with the potential to disturb the level-playing field during elections should not be displayed.
The commission, in a separate order, had also directed the producers "not to exhibit the film titled PM Narendra Modi till further orders". The film was earlier set to release on 11 April.
Acting on the complaints of political parties, including the Congress, the poll panel had also said that any poster or publicity material concerning any such certified content, which either depicts a candidate (including prospective) for the furtherance (or purported to further) of electoral prospects, directly or indirectly, shall not be put on display in electronic media in the area where MCC is in force.
The Left had also opposed the release of the film, saying it would disturb the level-playing field for other parties in the election and was in violation of the Model Code of Conduct.
The Modi biopic, starring Vivek Oberoi, has been the most-talked about movie this election season. Directed by Omung Kumar, it tells the story of Modi's rise to power from his humble beginnings.
The apex court had on 9 April dismissed a petition filed by Congress leader Aman Panwar for a stay on the release of the biopic, saying the Election Commission would be an "appropriate" place to seek the redressal.
The apex court had said it was not entertaining the petition for the stay on the release of the film which would be "premature" in view of the fact that the movie is yet to be certified by the Censor Board.
It said even if the film is released on 11 April, as claimed by the Congress leader, it will be appropriate for him to seek a redressal from the Election Commission.
A Bench of Justices DY Chandrachud and MR Shah also said that West Bengal's law has failed to include valuable safeguards for homebuyers
Formulate national policy on hospital admission in two weeks, no action on social media posts, SC directs Centre
The apex court also directed the Centre to collaborate with the states in preparing a buffer stock of oxygen for emergency purposes and to decentralise the location of the emergency stocks
The apex court made it clear that Vedanta shall not be allowed to enter and operate its copper smelting plant under the garb of this order and the permission to run the oxygen plant would not create any equity in the company's favour