Delhi HC slams state government for not buying disabled-friendly buses due to high cost

The Delhi High Court on Wednesday came down heavily on the city government for not buying low-floor disabled-friendly CNG buses due to their high cost.

IANS December 13, 2017 22:47:09 IST
Delhi HC slams state government for not buying disabled-friendly buses due to high cost

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday came down heavily on the city government for not buying low-floor disabled-friendly CNG buses due to their high cost.

"For the last 10 years you have justified not buying low-floor buses, saying the price was unrealistic without saying what is realistic or carrying out an empirical study," the court said

Delhi HC slams state government for not buying disabledfriendly buses due to high cost

Representational image. Reuters

The court questioned the basis for the government's assessment that the cost cited by Tata Motors and Ashok Leyland for supplying the low-floor buses was "unrealistic, exorbitant and unjustifiable", asking it to take a "practical, pragmatic and realistic view".

"If you are comparing low-floor buses with standard floor buses to say the cost is unrealistic, then it is like comparing apples with oranges," it added.

"We are pained. Sometimes you have to see what you are balancing the cost against," said the court, adding that if there was only a single manufacturer of a specialised product, then the government should go for it by taking into account the interests of the disabled persons as well as the environment.

The observation came after the Delhi government's counsel told the court that it had invited bids for low-floor buses four times but there was only a single bidder (Tata Motors) and the cost was unreasonable and unjustifiable.

The court also impleaded Tata Motors and Ashok Leyland as parties in the matter, so that they could inform it about the basis for the costs of their low-floor CNG buses.

During the hearing, the court even said that it could send officials to jail for contempt of the Supreme Court's 19-year-old direction to augment its bus fleet.

However, the court said the city needed more buses now rather than officials in prison.

"We can still send you to jail. But what the city needs is buses, not you in jail."

In 1998 the Supreme Court had directed the government to augment its bus fleet from 5,000 to 10,000.

The court was hearing a PIL filed by a person suffering from locomotor disability, challenging the Delhi government's move to procure 2,000 standard floor buses at a cost of Rs 300 crore.

Updated Date:

also read

Supreme Court imposes Rs 8 lakh fine on two advocates for 'misadventure'
India

Supreme Court imposes Rs 8 lakh fine on two advocates for 'misadventure'

The lawyers had filed a plea on the issue of traffic density, air pollution and emission norms

Delhi HC fines former CBI director over plea to restore Twitter verification tag
India

Delhi HC fines former CBI director over plea to restore Twitter verification tag

The petitioner had moved against the micro blogging site Twitter for removing verified tag from his account

Marital rape: How understanding ‘context’ rather than just focusing on ‘consent’ will help resolve the issue
Opinion

Marital rape: How understanding ‘context’ rather than just focusing on ‘consent’ will help resolve the issue

It’s time we clear the ambiguity over the issue of ‘marital rape’. Either we decide to acknowledge it and make it a criminal offence, or we decide to exempt it from judicial scrutiny is a choice that the legislature and judiciary have to make