New Delhi: The Delhi government has reason to be satisfied with people’s response to its odd-even scheme, but environmental experts still believe it’s only a half-measure and a total solution to the air pollution problem needs to go much beyond keeping half the vehicles off the roads on a daily basis.
As many as 80 percent of the Delhiites surveyed have given a loud yes to the continuation of the scheme; 63 percent of respondents want it implemented on a permanent basis. Based on the survey report, Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal has announced the second phase of the odd-even formula from 15 April to 30 April.
Though a maximum number of people wanted the second phase to be implemented from Valentine’s Day (14 February) for a fortnight, the government chose to postpone it due to the forthcoming school and board examinations.
The government acknowledges that the odd-even scheme needs to be backed by other measures. Kejriwal proposed a two-tier elevated BRT corridor – one for cars and the other for buses—for smooth high-speed movement of vehicles. “We need a better public transport system,” he said.
The problem with the new announcement, however, is there’s no change in the original format of the scheme. Besides VVIPs, exemption to single women, women drivers (and with kids) and two-wheelers continue to be in place.
Ravi Agarwal, director, Toxics Link, remarked, “Creating more road spaces by constructing elevated BRT corridors is a faulty idea. First, it’ll damage the aesthetics of the city plan and second, it’ll lead to multiple-level pollution. The aim should be to have a better public transport system in place, rather than creating more road space and thereby inviting more number of cars on roads. Instead of spending on BRT corridors, investment should be made on expanding public transport system, so that people can voluntarily give up driving cars.”
Kejriwal announced that by the end of December, a fleet of 3,000 buses would be added to the existing strength.
Anumita Roy Chowdhury, executive director, Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) said, “There should be a clear strategy on the scaling-up of public transport system in Delhi. Only buying buses won’t help. The focus should also be on quality of service, safety for women travelling alone in late hours, wider coverage and last mile connectivity. Elevated corridors are bad news, as they will add to more congestion. In comparison to Mumbai or Kolkata, 23 percent of Delhi’s geographical area has roads.”
Delhi has the highest road density of 2,103 kilometres/100 square kilometres in India. According to experts, the Barapulla flyover was constructed to avoid jams (during the Commonwealth Games 2010) and facilitate the smooth movement of athletes, but at present, it witnesses massive traffic congestion.
“Delhi has maximum flyovers, yet commuters face severe traffic congestion on these flyovers. Elevated corridors will attract more cars, and people will buy new cars with alternative registration numbers to circumvent odd-even scheme,” she said.
The CSE in its earlier reports had expressed a strong concern over extending exemptions to women and two-wheelers.
“Continuing with exemption to women and two-wheelers is a major concern. Two-wheelers contribute more than 30 percent of the total pollution caused by the vehicles. It should have also been covered under the odd-even formula. And, should there be class differentiation? Majority of women use public transport in Delhi. Government shouldn’t have continued exemption to women and should have treated them at par. If two-wheelers are brought under the scheme, public buses and auto-rickshaws will get more space on roads to ply on, without facing traffic congestion,” added Roy Chowdhury.
According to environmentalists, bikes and scooters emit nearly 32 percent of air pollutants generated by the transport sector in Delhi, whereas private cars are the third biggest polluter—22%, after Diesel-run trucks, which causes nearly 28% of vehicular pollution. In Delhi, there are over 55 lakh two-wheelers including motorbikes and scooters as compared to over 27 lakh private cars.
“Exemptions are political considerations. Exempting two-wheelers is a political decision and not scientific. And, what’s the idea of exempting VIPs? Are others less important than a VIP in a democratic system? Unless there’s an efficient public transport system in place, number of cars will go on increasing. It’s a compulsion and not always a luxury,” added Agarwal.
Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go to Firstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.
Updated Date: Feb 12, 2016 09:53:30 IST