Custodial deaths of Jeyaraj and Fenix: Accused Tuticorin cops should be arrested immediately; law allows it
What has happened in Tamil Nadu's Tuticorin is worse than some of the most violent cases India has witnessed (since the Delhi gangrape case in 2012 for which 4 people involved were hanged, recently).
What has happened in Tamilnadu's Tuticorin is worse than some of the most violent cases India has witnessed (since the Delhi gangrape case in 2012 for which 4 people involved were hanged, recently).
A father and son — P Jeyaraj, 58, and his son Fenix, 38 — running a mobile accessory shop in Sathankulam town in Tuticorin district were arrested by some policemen allegedly for keeping the shop open past permitted hours. Tamil Nadu has imposed a strict lockdown to curb COVID-19.
The duo were taken to the police station where, as has been alleged by the family members, they were brutally assaulted. A few days later they were pronounced dead in jail.
In the Delhi gangrape case, too, the torture was brutal. There were evidences of objects being thrust into private parts. In this case, the police, whose duty is to uphold the law and protect its citizens, did this. Rakshaks turned bhakshaks.
In Prakash Kadam & Etc. Etc versus Ramprasad Vishwanath Gupta & Anr on 13 May, 2011, the Supreme Court held that policemen found guilty of fake encounters should be given the death penalty, treating it as a 'rarest of rare' case. The court observed:
"Policemen are persons who are supposed to uphold the law. In our opinion if crimes are committed by ordinary people, ordinary punishment should be given, but if the offence is committed by policemen much harsher punishment should be given to them because they do an act totally contrary to their duties."
So, if the accused in the 2012 Delhi gangrape case were hanged, the accused cops in the Tuticorin case should face the same fate, if held guilty by the court.
Instances of custodial deaths were mounting in our country, as noted by the Supreme Court in its landmark decision in DK Basu, Ashok K Johri versus State Of West Bengal, State Of UP on 18 December, 1996. Hence, section 176 Criminal Procedure Code was amended and a special procedure created for investigating custodial deaths.
For ordinary crimes, investigation is done by the police. But for custodial deaths Section 176 provided that investigation will be presided over by a judicial magistrate. The purpose of making this special provision for custodial deaths was obvious: the police investigation, in this case, might not fair since it will be one of their colleagues.
However, there is nothing in Section 176 which says that policemen accused of custodial death cannot be arrested before the enquiry by the magistrate is completed. In fact, in murder cases, the police usually arrest the accused immediately, and does not wait till the investigation is over.
It is surprising that the accused policemen have only been suspended. They should have been arrested, as was done to the killers of George Floyd in America. The inquiry and trial should thereafter be completed expeditiously, and if the accused are found guilty harsh exemplary punishment must be given, so that policemen across India learn that they cannot continue behaving as the cops did during the British Raj.
Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.
Tuticorin custodial deaths: Rajinikanth says those involved in 'brutal killing' of father-son duo should be aptly punished
Rajinikanth also expressed shock over the ''inappropriate behaviour'' of some policemen.
MK Stalin says DMK will seek CBI probe into custodial deaths of Jayaraj and Fenix as personalities demand justice on social media
Following social media outcry over the deaths, DMK president MK Stalin on Saturday said his party would approach the court seeking a probe by the CBI, if the state government failed to conduct a proper investigation into the "custodial death" of Jayaraj and Bennicks of Sathankulam
Custodial deaths of P Jayaraj and Fenix: Police reforms possible only when privileged class acknowledges their role in promoting broken system
A transparent police force that functions within the law will ensure broader social prosperity.