CIC may choose not to direct public authorities to provide more information under RTI, rules Delhi HC

Even if a public authority has the power to call for certain information, it is not mandatorily required to seek the data to provide it to anb applicant under the RTI Act, the Delhi High Court has held.

PTI January 28, 2018 13:51:33 IST
CIC may choose not to direct public authorities to provide more information under RTI, rules Delhi HC

New Delhi: Even if a public authority has the power to call for certain information, it is not mandatorily required to seek the data to provide it to an applicant under the RTI Act, the Delhi High Court has held.

The court said that the authority can only provide information which is available with it to an applicant under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.

"The Act is available to make transparent any information that they have. You cannot ask a public authority to mandatorily procure an information, even if they have the power to do so," Justice Vibhu Bakhru observed.

The observations by the court came while disposing of a plea challenging an order of the Central Information Commission (CIC) which had declined to direct the Delhi government to call for further information from a private unaided school regarding terms and conditions of service of its employees.

CIC may choose not to direct public authorities to provide more information under RTI rules Delhi HC

Representational image. PTI

The CIC had disposed of the plea of the RTI applicant, who was employed in the private school, with a direction to the Delhi government to provide him an audit report of affairs of the school which the institution would have submitted under the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973.

Upholding the CIC's 21 September, 2017 decision, the high court said there was "no infirmity" in it and added that private unaided schools are open to scrutiny by the Delhi government, but not the general public.

It also said," The fact that the public authority has the power to call for certain information does not make it mandatory for the said authority to seek that information and provide the same to any information seeker under the provisions of the RTI Act.

"The public authority can only provide the information as is available with it, provided disclosure of such information is not exempt under section 8 of the Act."

The court, in its order, however, said that if the Delhi government has any information other than the audit report pertaining to the affairs of the private school, the petitioner-RTI applicant can seek the same.

"Needless to mention that such information would be provided to the petitioner subject to the provisions of the Act," it said.

Updated Date:

also read

COVID-19 crisis: Oxygen concentrators stuck at customs, says Delhi hospital; HC demands details from Centre
India

COVID-19 crisis: Oxygen concentrators stuck at customs, says Delhi hospital; HC demands details from Centre

However, the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs has informed the court that there is no consignment is pending with the customs authorities

'Do some homework': Delhi HC comes down heavily on 'publicity interest litigations', imposes costs
India

'Do some homework': Delhi HC comes down heavily on 'publicity interest litigations', imposes costs

A bench of Chief Justice DN Patel and Justice Jasmeet Singh said some of the pleas appeared to be filed on ideas that came to the petitioners' minds while 'having tea or walking on the road'

India records 3.92 lakh COVID-19 cases today; create oxygen buffer stock, SC tells Centre
India

India records 3.92 lakh COVID-19 cases today; create oxygen buffer stock, SC tells Centre

Vaccination of people between the ages of 18 and 45 is slated to begin in the National Capital tomorrow. Meanwhile, Goa extended its curbs, and Haryana and Odisha announced their own lockdowns to stop spread of COVID-19