Centre defends death by hanging in SC, says it's quicker and safer than other forms of execution

The Centre said it didn't want to make the execution 'overly comfortable', since it's a punishment meant to be handed out only in the rarest of rare cases because the crime was barbaric and abhorrent in nature.

FP Staff April 24, 2018 13:49:42 IST
Centre defends death by hanging in SC, says it's quicker and safer than other forms of execution

The Centre has defended death by hanging as a means of execution, and said it was safer and quicker than administering lethal injection or death by firing squad.

The Centre was responding to a plea seeking an alternate method of execution, other than hanging.

Centre defends death by hanging in SC says its quicker and safer than other forms of execution

Representational image. PTI

As reported by Live Law, the Centre also said it didn't want to make the execution "overly comfortable", since it's a punishment meant to be handed out only in the rarest of rare cases because the crime is barbaric and abhorrent in nature. An overly comfortable punishment, it argued, would reduce the deterrence.

The Centre also argued that these were sensitive issues which are exclusively a matter of legislative policy and ought not to be entertained in a PIL.

It was responding to the original petition filed by Supreme Court advocate Rishi Malhotra, which called death by hanging a painful method, and said there needs to be an alternative which would provide for a more "dignified" form of death.

As reported by NDTV in October  when the petition was filed, Malhotra called hanging a convict to death a violation of the right to life which included right to a dignified death. He called hanging the "most cruel and inhuman" form of execution. "Execution should be as quick and as simple as possible, and should not prolong someone's trauma", he said.

He added that it takes over 40 minutes to declare a prisoner dead when s/he is hanged, but it's over in a few minutes in case of a firing squad or lethal injection.

In response, the Supreme Court urged the Centre to respond with a counter-affidavit which will mention if there are other ways of carrying out the death sentence. While clarifying that it wasn't concerned with the validity of the death sentence, the court stressed that it only wanted a more humane manner of executing convicts.

"The legislature may think of other modes by which a convict has to face death sentence to die in peace but not in pain, for it has been said for centuries nothing can be equated to painless death. We are absolutely conscious that our Constitution is a compassionate Constitution which recognises sanctity of life", the court said in October.

Updated Date:

also read

5 most memorable moments from State of the Union speeches
World

5 most memorable moments from State of the Union speeches

The State of the Union, or SOTU, is an opportunity for the president to speak in front of a guaranteed large television audience, as well as the full Congress, Supreme Court justices, and other top officials. It is a highly scripted affair that frequently manages to surprise and even shock

Collegium chaos: How Israel’s judicial reforms find a parallel in what India needs
Opinion

Collegium chaos: How Israel’s judicial reforms find a parallel in what India needs

The Collegium should be abolished forthwith, the NJAC created, and the primacy of the elected Parliament over an unelected judiciary should be asserted, and that too, unambiguously

Victoria Gowri sworn in as Madras HC judge: The controversy surrounding the appointment decoded
Explainers

Victoria Gowri sworn in as Madras HC judge: The controversy surrounding the appointment decoded

A section of the legal fraternity from Chennai, citing her ‘affiliation’ with the BJP and ‘hate speeches’ against minorities, urged President Draupadi Murmu to return Victoria Gowri's nomination to the SC Collegium. Gowri was sworn in on Tuesday after the apex court refused to entertain the plea cha