Ayodhya Ram Mandir issue: Muslim organisations sceptical of out-of-court settlement

Muslim organisations, including Babri Masjid Action Committee were sceptical about the Supreme Court's suggestion for talks to resolve the Ayodhya dispute.

PTI March 21, 2017 17:00:08 IST
Ayodhya Ram Mandir issue: Muslim organisations sceptical of out-of-court settlement

New Delhi/Lucknow: Muslim organisations, including Babri Masjid Action Committee were on Tuesday sceptical about the Supreme Court's suggestion for talks to resolve the Ayodhya dispute, saying attempts at out-of-court settlement in the past have been unsuccessful. "We are ready with Chief Justice (of India) mediating...we trust him. We are also ready we if he nominates a team for
hearing the matter. But out of court settlement is not possible. If SC passes an order in this regard, we will look into it," said Zafaryab Jilani, Convenor of the Committee which is a party to the case.

Ayodhya Ram Mandir issue Muslim organisations sceptical of outofcourt settlement

Representational image. AFP

His comments came against the backdrop of the apex court earlier in the day asking parties concerned to sit together to arrive at a consensus on Ayodhya issue, which has been dragging for decades. "It is a sensitive and sentimental issue and it's best that it is settled amicably," the SC observed. Jilani said that going by his experience of last three decades, he feels that the matter cannot be settled outside the court and referred to unsuccessful negotiation attempts made during the tenures of former Prime Ministers Chandrashekhar and P V Narasimha Rao."Let them hear us, we are prepared. But we are not ready for out of court settlement," Jilani said.

"In 1986, talks started between the then Shankaracharya of Kanchi Kamkoti and President Muslim Personal Law Board Ali Miyan Nadvi but it failed. "Later in 1990, Prime Minister Chandrashekhar, UP Chief Minister Mulayam Singh Yadav and Bhairon Singh Shekhawat talked but no results came. PM Narasimha Rao also constituted a committee and attempts of talks were made through Congress
leader Subodh Kant Sahai but in 1992 the mosque was demolished," he said. He said after the demolition, the then Muslim Personal Law Board President Rabe Hasan Nadvi had sought a written proposal from Shankaracharya of Kanchi in which he said Muslims should leave claim on three mosques, which was not acceptable.

The Secretary General of All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB), Maulana Wali Rahmani, said, "We have trust in the Chief Justice and if he is there we are ready for talks." "Talks were held earlier also but it can be initiated again. But talks should not be long," he added. Maulana Khalid Rashid of the AIMPLB alleged that the attempts in the past to resolve the issue were foiled by political parties.

"Negotiation have been made in the past a number of times between the two parties. But each time, political parties foiled our attempts...(So), we are of the view that let the Supreme Court decide once and for all," Maulana Khalid Rashid of the AIMPLB said. Rashid, however, said the Board respects the gesture of the CJI and the sentiments of Hindus. "If the parties wants me to sit with mediators chosen by both the sides for negotiations, am ready to take up the task. Even the services of my brother judges can be availed for the purpose," Chief Justice J S Khehar, who headed the SC bench, said on Tuesday.

The Allahabad High Court, had in its verdict on 30 September, 2010, directed three-way division of the disputed Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid site in Ayodhya. The verdict was challenged in the apex court.

Updated Date:

also read

Supreme Court says farmers have right to protest but can't block roads indefinitely
India

Supreme Court says farmers have right to protest but can't block roads indefinitely

The apex court has asked the farmer unions to respond to the plea seeking removal of protesters from Delhi's borders and posted the matter for further hearing on 7 December

Lakhimpur Kheri: SC tells UP government to not 'drag feet', record statements of 40 remaining witnesses
India

Lakhimpur Kheri: SC tells UP government to not 'drag feet', record statements of 40 remaining witnesses

The Uttar Pradesh government told the apex court that statements of only four out of 44 witnesses have been recorded by the judicial magistrate. The top court has posted the matter for hearing on 26 October

CJI NV Ramana-led Supreme Court bench to hear Lakhimpur Kheri matter tomorrow
India

CJI NV Ramana-led Supreme Court bench to hear Lakhimpur Kheri matter tomorrow

Ten people, including Union Minister of State for Home Ajay Mishra's son Ashish Mishra, have been arrested so far in connection with the case