Allahabad HC stays Kanpur admin’s notice seeking damages from locals for destruction of property during anti-CAA protest

The Allahabad High Court has stayed a notice issued by the Kanpur administration seeking damages from a local resident over the destruction of property during protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act.

Press Trust of India February 17, 2020 23:39:23 IST
Allahabad HC stays Kanpur admin’s notice seeking damages from locals for destruction of property during anti-CAA protest
  • The stay, ordered last week on a petition by Kanpur's Mohammad Faizan, comes against the backdrop of scores of similar recovery notices sent by district authorities in the state

  • Akhilesh Yadav mockingly reminded Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath of his remark that the state government will take revenge (“badla”) for the destruction of public property by making those responsible for it pay for the losses

  • Justices Pankaj Naqvi and SS Shamshery passed the stay order on Faizan's petition against the recovery notice issued on 4 January by an additional district magistrate

Allahabad: The Allahabad High Court has stayed a notice issued by the Kanpur administration seeking damages from a local resident over the destruction of property during protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act.

The stay, ordered last week on a petition by Kanpur's Mohammad Faizan, comes against the backdrop of scores of similar recovery notices sent by district authorities in Uttar Pradesh in recent weeks.

Allahabad HC stays Kanpur admins notice seeking damages from locals for destruction of property during antiCAA protest

Representational image. Reuters

Reacting to it, Samajwadi Party (SP) president Akhilesh Yadav mockingly reminded Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath of his remark that the state government will take revenge (“badla”) for the destruction of public property by making those responsible for it pay for the losses.

“What will the Badla Baba do now? Whom will he take revenge against for this ruling?” he tweeted in Hindi on Monday.

Justices Pankaj Naqvi and SS Shamshery passed the stay order on Faizan's petition against the recovery notice issued on 4 January by an additional district magistrate (ADM).

The bench said the notice violated the guidelines laid down by the apex court in 2009 when it heard the matter related to “Destruction of Public and Private Properties Vs State of A.P and others”.

The judges also said the issue was still pending before the Supreme Court.

The High Court bench has asked the state government to file its reply within a month. The case will now be listed for the week beginning 20 April.

The judges observed that the Supreme Court guidelines had said the power to compute damages and investigate liability for destruction of public property will be exercised by a serving or retired high court or district court judge as “claims commissioner”.

The petitioner's counsel argued that an executive officer like the ADM had no power to issue such a notice in view of the 2009 Supreme Court order.

The judges added that the rules under which the notice was served is also under challenge before the apex court.

So the operation of the notice should be put in abeyance till the issue is determined by the apex court, the bench said. In his tweet, Akhilesh targeted the chief minister.

“If you are the head, you should have the knowledge of rules and regulations and the intention and vision to do justice. This is a responsible post and not for speaking the language of revenge (“pratishod”),” he said.

Updated Date:

also read

West Bengal polls: Yogi Adityanath promises to form anti-Romeo squads if BJP voted to power
Politics

West Bengal polls: Yogi Adityanath promises to form anti-Romeo squads if BJP voted to power

The Uttar Pradesh chief minister also criticised the Trinamool Congress govt in the state for 'failing to bring in any positive change' in the ten years that it has been in power

Tika utsav is fine but poll rallies, Kumbh Mela without social distancing and masks big threat to India's war on COVID-19
Politics

Tika utsav is fine but poll rallies, Kumbh Mela without social distancing and masks big threat to India's war on COVID-19

Perhaps the time has come for politicians of all parties, not just the aam aadmi, to also exhibit that “Covid-appropriate behaviour”

'Not enough COVID beds, ambulances in Lucknow': UP minister paints 'worrying' scene in confidential letter
India

'Not enough COVID beds, ambulances in Lucknow': UP minister paints 'worrying' scene in confidential letter

Law minister Brajesh Pathak's purported letter also blamed the death of Padma Shri winner Yogesh Praveen on the lack of an ambulance, though the victim's family denied making this charge