AG declines consent for contempt case against Prashant Bhushan, says he expressed regret for tweet on CJI

The consent of the topmost law officer was sought by advocate Sunil Singh to initiate contempt proceedings against Bhushan for his tweet, saying that the activist-lawyer connected 'the personal life of CJI' with a pending case before him

Press Trust of India November 29, 2020 08:32:57 IST
AG declines consent for contempt case against Prashant Bhushan, says he expressed regret for tweet on CJI

File Image of advocate Prashant Bhushan. PTI

New Delhi: Attorney General KK Venugopal has declined consent for initiation of criminal contempt proceedings against Prashant Bhushan for his tweets in which he was critical of Chief Justice of India (CJI) SA Bobde being provided a special helicopter by the Madhya Pradesh government, saying the activist-lawyer later expressed regret.

On 21 October, Bhushan had said the CJI availed the special helicopter during his visit to Kanha national park while "an important case of disqualification of defecting MLAs of MP (Madhya Pradesh) is pending before him. Survival of MP govt depends on this case".

However, Bhushan on 4 November had regretted the error in his earlier tweet and tweeted: Elections were held yesterday to seats of defecting Cong MLAs in MP who were made ministers in the Shivraj Govt. The survival of the Shivraj govt will depend on their re-election, not on the decision of the case in CJIs court challenging their ministership. I regret this error in my tweet below."

The consent of the topmost law officer was sought by one advocate Sunil Singh to initiate contempt proceedings against Bhushan for his 21 October tweet saying that the activist-lawyer connected "the personal life of CJI with a pending case before him.

Though Venugopal termed Bhushan's earlier tweet about the CJI as wholly unwarranted, improper, devoid of legal basis, and prima facie contumacious, he declined the consent considering the regret expressed in his later tweet.

"I am of the opinion that the imputations contained in three tweets to the effect that the Chief Justice of India committed an act of impropriety in accepting facilities of the state of Madhya Pradesh during his visit to Kanha National Park while a case pertaining to the disqualification of certain members of the legislative assembly of MP was pending before him were wholly unwarranted, improper, devoid of legal basis and prima facie contumacious for following reasons", Venugopal said in his response to the lawyer.

He said firstly the CJI is one of the highest constitutional functionaries in the country and is entitled to receive protocol as befits the stature of his office and the state guests are entitled to be extended appropriate security.

The top law officer said he was initially of the mind to grant the consent to initiate proceedings for criminal contempt.

"However, I must bring to your attention subsequent developments he has expressed regret for the error made in his earlier tweet on 21 October. He has stated publicly that it was incorrect to state that the fate of the government of Madhya Pradesh depended on the case pending before the CJI. In these circumstances, I do not think that it would be in the public interest to give consent for proceedings on the basis of the original tweet in view of the subsequent tweet expressing regret. I accordingly decline consent", Venugopal said.

The Attorney General said the region CJI visited has been a Maoist affected region and that is why he was given the helicopter facility.

It is significant to note that on 4 November, a bench headed by the CJI disposed of a plea that had raised the issue of pendency of disqualification proceedings against some Congress MLAs who had joined the BJP and were appointed as ministers in the Shivraj Singh Chouhan government in Madhya Pradesh.

The top court, on 31 August, had imposed a token fine of one rupee against Bhushan as punishment in the contempt case against him.

Bhushan was earlier convicted for two tweets against the judiciary.

Updated Date:

also read

BJP sacks Harak Singh Rawat from Uttarakhand Cabinet; Meet the man with tantrums and ceaseless ambition
Politics

BJP sacks Harak Singh Rawat from Uttarakhand Cabinet; Meet the man with tantrums and ceaseless ambition

The BJP has put a full stop to the unending chain of Harak Singh Rawat’s bouts of unhappiness, tantrums, complaints, uncharitable statements on former chief ministers over five years.

UP Assembly election: Two ex-BJP ministers join Samajwadi Party in presence of Akhilesh Yadav
Politics

UP Assembly election: Two ex-BJP ministers join Samajwadi Party in presence of Akhilesh Yadav

Taking a dig at the flurry of resignations from the saffron party, SP chief Akhilesh Yadav said, “wickets gir rahe the (wickets were dropping).”

UP Assembly election: BJP repeats sitting MLAs for Noida, Jewar and Dadri seats for upcoming polls
Politics

UP Assembly election: BJP repeats sitting MLAs for Noida, Jewar and Dadri seats for upcoming polls

The announcement was made in Delhi during a press conference by the BJP, which had won 303 of the 403 assembly seats in the last elections in 2017 in Uttar Pradesh