 "Tanaav deserves a round of applause for casting local Kashmiri talent as Kashmiris")
About time, one would say. Applause Entertainment deserves a round of applause for casting local Kashmiri talent in their tense, thoroughly engrossing anti-militancy series Tanaav. In 2018, when Vidhu Vinod Chopra had tried to use local Kashmiri Pundits in his film Shikara, there was widespread outrage about local Kashmiri talent being used as junior artistes.
The Jammu administration had asked Kashmiri Pandits residing in migrant camps at Jammu to participate in the shooting of the film being produced by Vidhu Vinod Chopra Production. The official communiqué informed that each person, irrespective of age, will be provided Rs 800 per day. There was widespread outrage among the Kashmiri Pandits in Bollywood at what they saw as Vinod Chopra’s “pathetic patronizing attitude towards a community that has suffered enough already without having to be reduced to junior artistes in a Bollywood film.”
Tanaav is the first show set in Kashmir which has used local actors and technicians organically. The Kashmiri actors include veteran M. K Raina, Sumit Kaul, Ekta Kaul, Sheen Dass, Rocky Raina, Sahiba Bali and Arslan Goni.
Slow clap for casting director Mukesh Chhabra for getting it right each time.
In addition, Adhir Bhat, who wrote the dialogues for Tanaav is also a Kashmiri. Another proud Kashmiri in Tanaav, Kapil Mattoo has worked closely with director Sudhir Mishra from behind the scenes .
Shabana Azmi is all for this fruitful culture of casting beyond the traditional Bollywood net. “What inclusiveness does is to ensure a participative and cast and hence, a much wider audience for your product. Nowadays, I see cinema, particularly the crew, as a microcosm of world cinema. In Steven Spielberg’s Halo, the diversity was mind blowing even among the actors: there was Korean, African ,Chinese, Australians, Caucasians, Hungarians and Indian(yours truly!). Diversity and inclusiveness is very important to cinema now.”
However, inclusiveness is not always a desirable goal. There are limits to how much we can pretend that colour doesn’t matter. It does! Which is why there is so much inequality everywhere. In Armando Iannucci’s The Personal History Of David Copperfield, a stylish, slyly witty film but finally way too slight and colour-blissed to be taken seriously, the titular role of Charles Dicken’s young hero is played a brown actor Dev Patel, who is as convincing as Copperfield as he was when he played a Sikh in the 26/11 drama Mumbai Hotel.
Games
View AllPatel’s Copperfield looks like an Asian masquerading as Charles Dickens’ English hero born to a privileged mother (Morfydd Clark, who later in the film show up with incestuous bizarreness as David Copperfield’s love interest). There is no explanation at all as to why David’s mother is unmistakably Caucasian while the son looks as brown as the toast she enjoys at her breakfast every morning. Much later, David has a Caucasian friend James who’s played by Aneurin Barnard and his mother is a Black woman played by Nikki Amuka-Bird!
James’s mother has an important role in the impressionable David’ life. When they are together, I could only see the film’s producers trying to please as many communities and countries as possible. This is Gone With The Wind with blizzards blowing away physical credibility.
It was very hard for me to concentrate on the characters’ function in the sprawling Victorian coming-of-age saga when the director was way too taken up with converting Charles Dickens’ epic novel into a cauldron of cultural cosmopolitanism. Let’s look beyond colour and race by all means. But not at the cost of a film’s credibility!
Subhash K Jha is a Patna-based film critic who has been writing about Bollywood for long enough to know the industry inside out. He tweets at @SubhashK_Jha.
Read all the Latest News, Trending News, Cricket News, Bollywood News, India News and Entertainment News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
 "India–EU FTA to benefit Rs 6.4 lakh crore exports across key states and sectors, says Piyush Goyal")
 "Minnesota judge orders ICE chief to appear in court, warns of contempt over ignored orders")
 "Will reset in Indo-Canada ties be complete with Carney's visit?")
 "Zelenskyy sets 2027 target for Ukraine’s EU accession, stresses security guarantees")
 "India–EU FTA to benefit Rs 6.4 lakh crore exports across key states and sectors, says Piyush Goyal")
 "Minnesota judge orders ICE chief to appear in court, warns of contempt over ignored orders")
 "Will reset in Indo-Canada ties be complete with Carney's visit?")
 "Zelenskyy sets 2027 target for Ukraine’s EU accession, stresses security guarantees")
