Budget 2022: Taxing time for common folks but big bonanza for politicians; here's how to correct this anomaly

Union Budget 2022-23: It is common for good Samaritans to educate the children of their domestic help and such altruistic spending should be encouraged with a tax break

S Murlidharan January 21, 2022 09:54:42 IST
Budget 2022: Taxing time for common folks but big bonanza for politicians; here's how to correct this anomaly

Indian Union Budget 2022: Representational image. MoneyControl

A measly Rs 1.50 lakh is what one gets by way of deduction from taxable income towards savings and investments. And this has been caught in a time warp — no upward revision in the last decade or so whereas ideally it should be revised upwards every year in recognition of the erosion in the value of money. Its one-size-fits-all character is even more questionable. If under progressive system of taxation, the rates should go up with one’s income, then equally the avenue for tax-oriented savings should also be resilient to accommodate their greater savings urges and capacity.

It is not as if such loosening of purse strings would make a dent in the revenue of the exchequer given the fact that most saving/investment schemes under Section 80C are either flowing into governmental coffers or for capital formation like tuition fee for children and roof under one’s head. It is duplicitous to allow Rs 2 lakh towards set off of losses from self-occupied houses emanating from the interest component of the EMI, while being niggardly towards the principal component which is the upshot when it is jostled out by one’s contribution to provident fund.

The government should be indifferent between taxes and such cheap funds garnered for nation-building. Thus, the present scheme can be tweaked as follows:

On the first Rs 2 lakh of savings, 100 percent deduction from the gross total income;

On the next Rs 2 lakh of savings, 90 percent deduction;

On the next Rs 2 lakh of savings, 80 percent deduction and so on till the 50 percent deduction mark is reached. It would be apparent that for savings in excess of Rs 2 lakh, a progressive price is exacted from the individual in the form of less and less deduction at each successive stage which he should not mind because at the end of the day the money blocked in various schemes becomes available to them whereas tax is perceived to be going down the drain.

And the section should be broad-based. One finds the scheme singularly devoid of any attraction for senior citizens who have already hung their boots. They obviously won’t be contributing to their provident fund. Their children would be out of schools and colleges and therefore cannot claim tuition fees either. It is not the stage of their life when they would buy or construct a house and take the resultant burden of EMI. What they need is an avenue tailor-made for them. It is the time of their lives when most of them are constrained to pop blood pressure or diabetes pills, besides paying consultation fees to their doctors. None of these qualify for deduction. Section 80D giving tax benefits for health insurance premium doesn’t help them because health insurance policies in India are fixated on hospitalisation.

Tuition fees that qualify are those in respect of a maximum of two children of the taxpayer. Why should we view education so restrictively? A grandparent may come forward to educate his grandchildren especially when his son or daughter is facing financial difficulties. It is common for good Samaritans to educate the children of their domestic help. Such altruistic spending should be encouraged with a tax break.

Section 80GGC of the Income Tax Act confers a magnanimous, hackle-raising and eye-popping 100 percent deduction without any let or hindrance for contributions to political parties or electoral trusts made through banking channels. And this obnoxious dispensation has been allowed to continue despite knowing its dubious potential — money laundering. And there is a conspiracy of silence among political parties. How can Parliament be so tight-fisted when it comes to a laudable cause (80C) and be so unabashedly generous to donations to political parties?

The patent inequity would be even more glaring if one juxtaposes the no-holds-barred leg up to donations to political parties with deduction for donations to altruistic causes under Section 80G — only 50 percent of such donations are normally tax-deductible.

The author is a senior columnist. Views expressed are personal.

Read all the Latest News, Trending NewsCricket News, Bollywood News,
India News and Entertainment News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Updated Date:

also read

Opposition slams Uttar Pradesh budget, calls it a web of statistics and cliched exercise
Politics

Opposition slams Uttar Pradesh budget, calls it a web of statistics and cliched exercise

SP's Akhilesh Yadav said that the government failed to run schemes for the poor and for the development of the state's infrastructure

Uttar Pradesh: MLAs banned from taking selfies inside Assembly premises
Politics

Uttar Pradesh: MLAs banned from taking selfies inside Assembly premises

The Speaker specified that the mobile phones of MLAs will be confiscated for taking selfies and carrying out photo sessions

Philips TAA4216BK Wireless Sports Headphones Review: Truly gym-proof with solid battery backup
News & Analysis

Philips TAA4216BK Wireless Sports Headphones Review: Truly gym-proof with solid battery backup

One of the rare on-the-ear sports headphones with IP55 sweat protection in this budget.