US Presidential Election: Despite small numbers, Indian-Americans can play an outsize role in influencing outcome

Indian-Americans are among the wealthiest and most educated of all immigrant groups in the US

The Conversation September 04, 2020 10:15:47 IST
US Presidential Election: Despite small numbers, Indian-Americans can play an outsize role in influencing outcome

By Sumit Ganguly

Senator Kamala Harris being picked by Joe Biden as his running mate has put a spotlight on the Indian-American community in the United States.

The interest, in part, stems from her origins: Her mother, Shyamala Gopalan, was a biologist from Chennai. Her father, Donald Harris, an economist, was from Jamaica. After her parents divorced, her mother raised Kamala Harris and her sister as members of the Black Church. But her mother also took Harris to Hindu temples.

In her memoir Harris writes about her Indian origins.

I am a political scientist of Indian origin who has followed the rising trajectory of Indian-Americans in American politics.

Though Indian-Americans constitute a mere 1.5 percent of the population their impact on American politics can be disproportionate. Indian-Americans are among the wealthiest and most educated of all immigrant groups in the US.

The question is: How exactly do they vote?

Presence in American politics

At four million, Indian-Americans are one of the fastest growing immigrant groups in the United States and the second-largest immigrant group after Mexicans.

The community, however, started with modest numbers, owing to severe restrictions on immigration prior to the the passage of the landmark Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965.

This legislation, that ended immigration on the basis of national origins and prioritised highly skilled workers, led to a dramatic increase of immigration from Asia. A disproportionate segment of those who formed the first wave of migrants were middle class professionals: doctors, educators and managers.

US Presidential Election Despite small numbers IndianAmericans can play an outsize role in influencing outcome

Congressman Dalip Singh Saund in 1958. Associated Press

In 1957, Dalip Singh Saund became the first Asian-American to be elected to the US. House of Representatives, coming from a district in southern California. A naturalised US citizen of Indian heritage, he was subsequently elected for two more terms before he suffered a stroke in 1962 and was too ill to run again.

Indian-Americans were a minority in Saund’s constituency, California’s 29th District, which includes part of Los Angeles County. Saund pursued a campaign that could overcome widespread suspicion, distrust and even outright hostility toward immigrants from South Asia.

In 2005, another Indian-American, Piyush “Bobby” Jindal, became the second Indian-American to be elected to the House of Representatives. In 2011, Pramila Jayapal, became the first Indian-American woman in the US House of Representatives. Today there are five Indian-Americans in Congress, including Kamala Harris in the Senate.

Being a high-earning and educated immigrant group makes Indian-Americans a very attractive pool of potential donors for political campaigns. In the current election season they have emerged as significant donors. Not surprisingly, both Republicans and Democrats make ardent efforts to court them especially in highly contested regions.

Affluent Indian-American vote

Since the days of President Ronald Reagan, the Republican Party had tried a “big tent” strategy, an effort to accommodate people of various political leanings. That, however, is no longer the case, especially under President Trump.

The approach was ostensibly designed to broaden the appeal of the party especially to hitherto marginalised communities and immigrant groups of colour including those from various developing nations as well as Hispanics.

The party did attract particular individuals of Indian-American origin who rose to positions of considerable prominence, such as Bobby Jindal, the former governor of Louisiana, and Nikki Haley, the erstwhile American ambassador to the United Nations whose parents emigrated to the US from Punjab.

However, the party could not genuinely broaden its Indian-American base across the country. Both these individuals also distanced themselves from their religious roots by converting to Christianity.

Particular episodes also alienated Indian-Americans from the party. In one such episode in 2006, George Allen, a former Republican senator from Virginia, while running for office during a campaign rally referred to a young Indian-American as Macaca, a certain species of monkey. “This fellow here, over here with the yellow shirt. Macaca or whatever his name is. He’s with my opponent, he’s following us around everywhere,” he said.

The incident, which attracted media attention, has long since rankled members of the community. But some affluent Indian-Americans do tend to vote for the Republican Party.

When Trump visited India in February 2020, he received a huge reception especially at an extravaganza organised in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s home state of Gujarat.

Leaning Democratic

However, a majority of Indian-Americans either identify with the Democratic Party or lean Democratic politically.

In the past, a 2012 Pew survey showed 65 percent of Indian Americans are Democrats or lean Democrat. According to a more recent 2020 survey that political scientist Karthick Ramakrishnan has conducted, 54 percent of Indian-Americans are leaning toward the Democratic nominee, Joseph Biden, while 29 percent are in favour of the Republican incumbent Donald Trump.

The same survey also shows that there are 1.8 million Indian-Americans, whose vote in crucial swing states ranging from Arizona to Wisconsin could help tip the election one way or another.

There may be several likely explanations for the overwhelming level of support among Indian-Americans for the Democratic Party. For the past several decades, Democrats have been more welcoming of immigrants and minorities. And most Indian-Americans tend to have more liberal political leanings. It may be worth noting that as many as 84 percent of the Indian-American community had voted for President Obama.

Whether the same trend is repeated is yet to be seen.US Presidential Election Despite small numbers IndianAmericans can play an outsize role in influencing outcome

Sumit Ganguly, distinguished professor of Political Science and the Tagore chair in Indian Cultures and Civilizations, Indiana University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

As US polls draw near, Joe Biden, in a rarity, attacks Donald Trump from battleground Pennsylvania
World

As US polls draw near, Joe Biden, in a rarity, attacks Donald Trump from battleground Pennsylvania

Playing up his local, middle-class roots, Biden focussed on Trump’s stewardship of the coronavirus, casting the president as a callous leader who cannot empathise with the concerns of most Americans

Ruth Bader Ginsburg passes away at 87: US Supreme Court judge and champion of women's rights dies of pancreatic cancer
World

Ruth Bader Ginsburg passes away at 87: US Supreme Court judge and champion of women's rights dies of pancreatic cancer

Ginsburg became the court's second female justice and a liberal icon for her sharp questioning of witnesses and intellectually rigorous defenses of civil liberties and equal protections under the law

Iran executes wrestler Navid Afkari for murder during 2018 protests; IOC expresses shock at decision
Sports

Iran executes wrestler Navid Afkari for murder during 2018 protests; IOC expresses shock at decision

Reports published abroad say Afkari was convicted on the basis of confessions aired on television after being extracted under torture, prompting online campaigns for his release.