UK extradition decision a victory for Assange, not press freedom, lawyers and campaigners say

By Michael Holden LONDON (Reuters) - A British judge's decision on Monday not to extradite Julian Assange is a victory for the WikiLeaks founder but was not an endorsement of freedom of speech and leaves a shadow over investigative journalism, lawyers and campaigners said. Judge Vanessa Baraitser ruled that Assange, 49, should not be sent to the United States to face 18 charges including breaking an espionage law, on the grounds that his mental health issues meant he was at risk of suicide

Reuters January 05, 2021 00:11:03 IST
UK extradition decision a victory for Assange, not press freedom, lawyers and campaigners say

UK extradition decision a victory for Assange not press freedom lawyers and campaigners say

By Michael Holden

LONDON (Reuters) - A British judge's decision on Monday not to extradite Julian Assange is a victory for the WikiLeaks founder but was not an endorsement of freedom of speech and leaves a shadow over investigative journalism, lawyers and campaigners said.

Judge Vanessa Baraitser ruled that Assange, 49, should not be sent to the United States to face 18 charges including breaking an espionage law, on the grounds that his mental health issues meant he was at risk of suicide.

But she rejected all his legal team's arguments that the case was politically motivated and concluded that his actions had gone beyond any protection offered to a free press.

"We will never accept that journalism is a crime in this country or any other," Assange's partner Stella Moris said outside the court.

His supporters said the ruling could pose serious problems for publishers dealing with leaked classified information.

"There are very serious concerns about the judge's ruling with respect to free speech and what that will mean for other British journalists in the future who ... do not have the same medical conditions as Mr Assange," his lawyer Jennifer Robinson told Reuters.

"This was not a win from a free speech point of view. I think all journalists ought to be looking very carefully at this."

Baraitser's ruling said the United States had met the legal tests to satisfy extradition, and that the accusation Assange had encouraged hacking of U.S. government computers meant he had gone beyond the role of an investigative journalist.

"In this case Mr Assange's alleged acts were unlawful and he does not become immune from criminal liability merely because he claims he was acting as a journalist," she said.

Jameel Jaffer of Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute, which seeks to defend freedom of speech, said a particular concern was the U.S. prosecution stance that Assange had broken a spying law simply by publishing secrets.

"The result is that the U.S. indictment of Assange will continue to cast a dark shadow over investigative journalism," Jaffer said.

Assange is not the first high-profile extradition case to fail on concerns about the accused person's mental welfare.

In 2012, British interior minister and later Prime Minister Theresa May overruled the courts to block sending computer hacker Gary McKinnon to the United States, where he was accused of causing more than $700,000 damage to U.S. military systems, because of the risk he could kill himself.

Two years ago, Lauri Love, who has Asperger's syndrome, was also spared extradition over accusations of involvement in hacking at agencies including the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the U.S. army because of suicide concerns.

"This decision may reflect a broader concern with how the United States would treat suspects with documented psychological health issues if extradited," Daniel Pannett of London law firm Linklaters, said of the Assange verdict.

"So long as a disparity remains between detention conditions in the United States and UK, this argument could be seen more frequently in extradition cases moving forward."

(Additional reporting by Natalie Thomas; Editing by Catherine Evans)

This story has not been edited by Firstpost staff and is generated by auto-feed.

Updated Date:

TAGS:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Republicans face growing corporate backlash after Capitol assault
World

Republicans face growing corporate backlash after Capitol assault

By Andy Sullivan and David Shepardson WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Republicans in the U.S. Congress faced growing blowback on Monday from businesses that said they would cut off campaign contributions to those who voted last week to challenge President-elect Joe Biden's victory. The announcements by Dow Inc., AT&T Inc.

Guardians of Congo's gorillas unbowed as ambushed colleague is buried
World

Guardians of Congo's gorillas unbowed as ambushed colleague is buried

By Djaffar Al Katanty GOMA, Congo (Reuters) - A line of Congolese park rangers raised their guns in salute on Monday as the coffin bearing their colleague Burhani Abdou Surumwe, a 30-year-old father of four, was buried in the black volcanic soil of a Muslim cemetery outside Goma.

COVID-19 fuelling education's tech disruption, deepening digital divide
World

COVID-19 fuelling education's tech disruption, deepening digital divide

TORONTO/NEW YORK (Reuters) - The COVID-19 pandemic deepened inequities in accessing and benefiting from education but the future of learning could be a more equal one, participants told Reuters Next panels on Monday.