U.S. court allows 'No-Fly List' lawsuits, dissenters warn of danger

By Jonathan Stempel NEW YORK (Reuters) - A divided federal appeals court on Thursday said American Muslims who landed on the 'No-Fly List' because of their refusal to become government informants can sue FBI agents for damages, prompting dissents that said the decision was dangerous and defied U.S.

Reuters February 15, 2019 04:06:13 IST
U.S. court allows 'No-Fly List' lawsuits, dissenters warn of danger

US court allows NoFly List lawsuits dissenters warn of danger

By Jonathan Stempel

NEW YORK (Reuters) - A divided federal appeals court on Thursday said American Muslims who landed on the "No-Fly List" because of their refusal to become government informants can sue FBI agents for damages, prompting dissents that said the decision was dangerous and defied U.S. Supreme Court precedents.

In a 7-3 vote, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan refused to revisit its May 2018 decision by a three-judge panel allowing Muhammad Tanvir, Jameel Algibhah and Naveed Shinwari to seek monetary damages for being put on the list, despite no evidence they threatened airline or passenger safety.

The plaintiffs, all U.S. citizens or permanent residents who were born abroad, had sought damages under the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

They said their inclusion on the No-Fly List for refusing to spy on Muslim communities caused them to lose jobs, be unable to visit family and be stigmatized in their communities. None remains on the list.

Circuit Judge Dennis Jacobs, one of Thursday's dissenters, said Congress intended the 1993 law to restore religious freedom that was curtailed in a 1990 Supreme Court decision, Employment Division v. Smith, and did not create a damages remedy.

He said the panel's decision threatened "substantial social costs," including the risk that government officials tasked with protecting national security might not do their jobs out of fear they might be sued and held personally liable.

"The safest course for a government employee in doubt would be to avoid doing one's job, which is not a choice in need of encouragement," Jacobs wrote. "The panel opinion is quite wrong and actually dangerous."

Another dissenter, Circuit Judge Jose Cabranes, called the decision "a transparent attempt to evade, if not defy" Supreme Court precedents on liability of government officials.

A spokesman for U.S. Attorney Geoffrey Berman in Manhattan, whose office defended the FBI agents, declined to comment.

Ramzi Kassem, a City University of New York School of Law professor representing the plaintiffs, said they deserved the chance to hold accountable the FBI agents "who forced them to choose between the tenets of their religion and being able to fly to see their families."

In another recent No-Fly List case, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco voted 8-3 on Jan. 2 that the government should pay millions of dollars to lawyers for a Muslim woman it put on the No-Fly List after mistakenly branding her a terrorist. That case began in 2005.

The case is Tanvir v Tanzin et al, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 16-1176.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; editing by Dan Grebler; editing by Jonathan Oatis)

This story has not been edited by Firstpost staff and is generated by auto-feed.

Updated Date:

TAGS:

also read

France, Germany to agree to NATO role against Islamic State - sources
| Reuters
World

France, Germany to agree to NATO role against Islamic State - sources | Reuters

By Robin Emmott and John Irish | BRUSSELS/PARIS BRUSSELS/PARIS France and Germany will agree to a U.S. plan for NATO to take a bigger role in the fight against Islamic militants at a meeting with President Donald Trump on Thursday, but insist the move is purely symbolic, four senior European diplomats said.The decision to allow the North Atlantic Treaty Organization to join the coalition against Islamic State in Syria and Iraq follows weeks of pressure on the two allies, who are wary of NATO confronting Russia in Syria and of alienating Arab countries who see NATO as pushing a pro-Western agenda."NATO as an institution will join the coalition," said one senior diplomat involved in the discussions. "The question is whether this just a symbolic gesture to the United States

China's Xi says navy should become world class
| Reuters
World

China's Xi says navy should become world class | Reuters

BEIJING Chinese President Xi Jinping on Wednesday called for greater efforts to make the country's navy a world class one, strong in operations on, below and above the surface, as it steps up its ability to project power far from its shores.China's navy has taken an increasingly prominent role in recent months, with a rising star admiral taking command, its first aircraft carrier sailing around self-ruled Taiwan and a new aircraft carrier launched last month.With President Donald Trump promising a US shipbuilding spree and unnerving Beijing with his unpredictable approach on hot button issues including Taiwan and the South and East China Seas, China is pushing to narrow the gap with the U.S. Navy.Inspecting navy headquarters, Xi said the navy should "aim for the top ranks in the world", the Defence Ministry said in a statement about his visit."Building a strong and modern navy is an important mark of a top ranking global military," the ministry paraphrased Xi as saying.