U.S. appeals court questions Asian-American bias claims against Harvard

By Nate Raymond BOSTON (Reuters) - A federal appeals court on Wednesday appeared skeptical of arguments that Harvard discriminates against Asian-American applicants, a claim made in a closely-watched lawsuit challenging the use of race as a factor in U.S. college admissions. Members of a three-judge 1st U.S.

Reuters September 17, 2020 03:10:34 IST
U.S. appeals court questions Asian-American bias claims against Harvard

US appeals court questions AsianAmerican bias claims against Harvard

By Nate Raymond

BOSTON (Reuters) - A federal appeals court on Wednesday appeared skeptical of arguments that Harvard discriminates against Asian-American applicants, a claim made in a closely-watched lawsuit challenging the use of race as a factor in U.S. college admissions.

Members of a three-judge 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel in Boston questioned why it should conclude a trial judge wrongly rejected the claims by Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), a nonprofit founded by anti-affirmative action activist Edward Blum.

Conservatives have long criticized affirmative action. Legal experts say the case could go to the U.S. Supreme Court, giving its conservative majority a chance to reconsider past decisions that allowed race to be considered as a factor in admissions.

Blum's group, which counts Asian-American applicants as members and has President Donald Trump administration's support, contends the Ivy League school engaged in impermissible "racial balancing" to benefit other preferred minority groups, such as Blacks and Hispanics.

SFFA lawyer William Consovoy argued that despite high academic scores, Asian Americans were admitted a lower rates than other groups because of racial stereotyping by admissions officers who gave them low "personal" rating scores.

Consovoy asked the court to consider how it would evaluate such low scores if they were given to well-qualified Black applicants for police or firefighting jobs.

"I think this court would be skeptical or concerned that this was discrimination and not that African American firefighters or police officers actually had worse personal qualities," he said.

A U.S. Justice Department lawyer, Eric Dreiband, argued that Harvard in adopting its admissions system gave "no serious consideration of race-neutral alternatives."

But their arguments faced questions from panelists including U.S. Circuit Judge Juan Torruella, who asked "what is the evidence of racial profiling here?"

Seth Waxman, Harvard's lawyer, argued that a "mountain of evidence" showed it did not intentionally discriminate against Asian Americans.

He urged the court to uphold U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs, who last year ruled Harvard had no "workable and available race-neutral alternatives" to ensure a diverse student body.

U.S. Circuit Judge Sandra Lynch during the arguments pointed to past Supreme Court rulings that allow universities to consider race as one factor to remedy disadvantages minority students have faced because of racial prejudice.

"Harvard can in fact consider other things than merely class ranking and the academic achievements of the Asian-American applicants," she said.

(Reporting by Nate Raymond in Boston; Editing by Noeleen Walder and Grant McCool)

This story has not been edited by Firstpost staff and is generated by auto-feed.

Updated Date:

TAGS:

also read

France, Germany to agree to NATO role against Islamic State - sources
| Reuters
World

France, Germany to agree to NATO role against Islamic State - sources | Reuters

By Robin Emmott and John Irish | BRUSSELS/PARIS BRUSSELS/PARIS France and Germany will agree to a U.S. plan for NATO to take a bigger role in the fight against Islamic militants at a meeting with President Donald Trump on Thursday, but insist the move is purely symbolic, four senior European diplomats said.The decision to allow the North Atlantic Treaty Organization to join the coalition against Islamic State in Syria and Iraq follows weeks of pressure on the two allies, who are wary of NATO confronting Russia in Syria and of alienating Arab countries who see NATO as pushing a pro-Western agenda."NATO as an institution will join the coalition," said one senior diplomat involved in the discussions. "The question is whether this just a symbolic gesture to the United States

China's Xi says navy should become world class
| Reuters
World

China's Xi says navy should become world class | Reuters

BEIJING Chinese President Xi Jinping on Wednesday called for greater efforts to make the country's navy a world class one, strong in operations on, below and above the surface, as it steps up its ability to project power far from its shores.China's navy has taken an increasingly prominent role in recent months, with a rising star admiral taking command, its first aircraft carrier sailing around self-ruled Taiwan and a new aircraft carrier launched last month.With President Donald Trump promising a US shipbuilding spree and unnerving Beijing with his unpredictable approach on hot button issues including Taiwan and the South and East China Seas, China is pushing to narrow the gap with the U.S. Navy.Inspecting navy headquarters, Xi said the navy should "aim for the top ranks in the world", the Defence Ministry said in a statement about his visit."Building a strong and modern navy is an important mark of a top ranking global military," the ministry paraphrased Xi as saying.