Speed bump or tortuous path? At televised debate, Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn manoeuvre on Brexit

In Prime Minister Boris Johnson's telling on Tuesday night, Brexit was simple, a speed bump on the road to British prosperity

The New York Times November 20, 2019 10:29:47 IST
Speed bump or tortuous path? At televised debate, Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn manoeuvre on Brexit

London: In Prime Minister Boris Johnson's telling on Tuesday night, Brexit was simple, a speed bump on the road to British prosperity.

But in the eyes of the Labour Party leader, Jeremy Corbyn, it was anything but, opening the door to a decade of tortuous trade talks and a sell-off of Britain's cherished public services.

Those clashing messages, delivered to occasional groans from a studio audience on Tuesday night, formed the core of the first debate before Britain's General Election next month, one that could determine whether Britain leaves the European Union or stays.

The argument befit an election consumed less by the merits of Brexit than by how painlessly Britain can move beyond it.

Johnson hammered again and again at the need to "get Brexit done", casting it as the first step to solving everything from climate change to an erosion of trust in British democracy. Corbyn, on the other hand, refused to say even whether he wanted Britain to quit the European Union — arguing instead that the least disruptive way forward was returning the choice to Britons in a second referendum.

In a campaign that has seemed stuck in neutral, with Johnson's Conservative Party holding a steady lead and Britons irritated by both main candidates, some analysts said that simply holding his own gave Corbyn a chance to turn the tide. But with Labour lawmakers antsy that their party is running out of time to close a double-digit polling deficit, it was not clear whether it would be enough.

Speed bump or tortuous path At televised debate Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn manoeuvre on Brexit

File image of British prime minister Boris Johnson. AP

Johnson is banking on Britons being so weary of a logjam in Parliament over Brexit that they overlook Corbyn's criticisms and give Johnson the majority to push through his exit agreement. That deal made only halting progress in Parliament last month.

"Whether you voted for Leave or Remain, people want to get Brexit done, and to unleash the potential of this entire country," Johnson said. "We have a deal that is oven-ready."

Though the audience grew audibly annoyed with Johnson’s recurrent pleas to "get Brexit done", the message makes up a big part of his appeal in a country that has watched lawmakers argue over the issue for three years, to little effect.

Likewise, Johnson tugged incessantly at one of Corbyn's biggest vulnerabilities: His refusal to say whether he would campaign for Leave or Remain in a second referendum. At a moment when nearly all Britons seem to have made up their minds on Brexit, Corbyn's silence has generated mistrust among anti-Brexit voters, even if Labour has clearly articulated its preference for a second public vote.

Corbyn, who is trying to hold together a coalition that includes both Leavers and Remainers, grew most passionate discussing Britain's National Health Service.

Brandishing documents that he said described secret government meetings with American trade negotiators, Corbyn accused Johnson of wanting to "sell our National Health Service to the United States" during discussions over a post-Brexit free trade agreement.

And he briefly quieted a restive audience by telling the story of a friend who he said had died the day before of breast cancer after waiting eight hours for help.

"The NHS is a wonderful and brilliant institution, but it is suffering under the most incredible pressure," Corbyn said, citing thousands of nursing vacancies and long waits in emergency departments.

Labour trails by an average of roughly a dozen percentage points in polls, with Corbyn garnering the worst popularity ratings of a major party leader heading into a British election since the data was first tracked 40 years ago.

Hopes that Labour could repeat its dramatic comeback in the 2017 General Election — perhaps with the rollout of its policy proposals this week — are fading as the party has failed to make up ground.

And the Liberal Democrats — a centrist party that wants to revoke Brexit altogether and could hurt the Conservatives in some seats, is struggling, too.

Speed bump or tortuous path At televised debate Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn manoeuvre on Brexit

File image of Jeremy Corbyn, leader of Britain's Labour Party. Reuters

Tuesday night's televised debate, still a relatively new element in British elections, featured a few stinging one-liners.

"A money forest, he's got," Johnson said of Corbyn’s big spending plans.

But Corbyn was also ready when Johnson warned of a "chaotic coalition" between Labour and the pro-independence Scottish National Party, saying that Johnson had presided over "nine years of chaotic coalitions already".

There were laughs from the audience, too, when Johnson, not known for being scrupulous with his facts, answered a question about personal integrity by saying that the truth mattered.

Near the end of the debate, the conversation landed on a topic that in recent days has overshadowed the election altogether: Prince Andrew's disastrous interview about his friendship with the disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein.

Corbyn said that the monarchy "needs a bit of improvement".

But Johnson, who has already antagonised Queen Elizabeth II during his short time in office, said it needed no such thing.

"The institution of the monarchy is beyond reproach," he said.

Benjamin Mueller c.2019 The New York Times

Updated Date:

also read

Why 'partygate' may spell the end for rule-breaker UK PM Boris Johnson
World

Why 'partygate' may spell the end for rule-breaker UK PM Boris Johnson

Revelations that the prime minister and his staff partied while Britain was under coronavirus restrictions have provoked public outrage and prompted many in the Conservative Party to consider dumping their leader

'Partygate': The scandal that has Boris Johnson on the backfoot and London police making inquiries
World

'Partygate': The scandal that has Boris Johnson on the backfoot and London police making inquiries

Troubles mounted for Britain’s embattled prime minister Boris Johnson on Tuesday as the London police formally began investigating allegations that he and his staff organised parties at the PM’s office and residence during Covid lockdowns in 2020.

Trouble mounts for Boris Johnson as Scotland Yard opens 'partygate' probe
World

Trouble mounts for Boris Johnson as Scotland Yard opens 'partygate' probe

Scotland Yard confirmed that the Metropolitan Police will investigate potential lockdown breaches related to alleged parties at the UK prime minister's official residence at 10 Downing Street