Pen is not mightier than Moscow: Two anti-Ukraine War poets get 7 and 5 years in jail

Two men were given lengthy prison sentences by a Moscow court on Thursday for reading poetry critical of the invasion of Ukraine. An AFP journalist present at the hearing witnessed the supporters of Artyom Kamardin and Yegor Shtovba yelling “Shame!” from the courtroom as they were sentenced to seven years and five years, respectively, in prison. Thousands of people have been detained by Russian authorities for merely expressing opposition to the offensive in Ukraine, and criticism is now essentially forbidden. The 33-year-old Kamardin claimed that the officers had sexually assaulted him during his arrest and had made him record an apology video under duress while threatening to break up with his girlfriend. On the eve of his arrest he had recited his poem “Kill me, militia man!” on a Moscow square where dissidents have been gathering since the Soviet era. Kamardin also shouted offensive slogans against the imperial “New Russia” project aiming to annex the south of Ukraine. Both were convicted of “inciting hatred” and “calling for activities threatening state security”. Kamardin told the court he did not know his actions broke the law and asked for mercy. “I am not a hero, and going to prison for my beliefs was never in my plans,” he said in a statement, posted on his supporters’ Telegram channel. - ‘Under torture’ - After the sentencing, his father Yury said: “This is a total outrage!” Around two dozen friends came to support the defendants along with the poets’ parents and wives. Kamardin’s wife Alexandra Popova was in the crowd. “It is a very harsh sentence. Seven years for poems, for a non-violent crime,” she said, before being detained. In an interview with AFP in late 2022, she had recounted her then boyfriend’s arrest, saying officers threatened her with “gang rape”, hit her and sprayed superglue on her cheeks and mouth. Meanwhile Kamardin was taken to a separate room, where – as he told his lawyer – he was beaten and raped with a barbell. Kamardin was also forced to film an apology video. - Sorry for ’leaving you’ - Shtovba, 23, also insisted he did not break the law. In his last statement in court, published by independent site Mediazona, he asked the judge: “What have I done that’s illegal? Read poetry?” He also addressed his mother, who he said depended on him financially. “Mom, I know that you, more than anyone, believe in my innocence… Still, I’m sorry for how things turned out, leaving you and dad alone.” Nikolai Dayneko, who was arrested at the same time, was sentenced to four years in prison last May after entering a pre-trial agreement, according to OVD-info. This is the latest in a string of heavy sentences against Russians who protested the offensive, in trials critics denounce as absurd. In mid-November judge Oksana Demiasheva sentenced artist Alexandra Skochilenko to seven years in prison for swapping price tags with slogans criticising Russia’s offensive in Ukraine. Skochilenko had replaced five price tags in a branch of one of Russia’s largest supermarket chains in Saint Petersburg with messages about the conflict. The trials of ordinary Russians usually take place away from public attention, unlike those of prominent critics. Most of Russia’s high-profile opposition figures have fled the country or are behind bars, including Alexei Navalny. (with inputs from AFP)