Islamic State hold in Syria, Iraq on verge of collapse, but fight not over, says US commander General Joseph Votel

Washington: President Donald Trump is expected to declare near-total triumph over the Islamic State group in Syria in his State of the Union address Tuesday, but US defence officials are increasingly fearful that the militants are simply biding their time until the Americans leave the battlefield as planned.

Islamic State militants have lost territory since Trump's surprise announcement in December that he was pulling US forces out, but military officials warn the fighters could regroup within six months to a year after the Americans leave.

Islamic State hold in Syria, Iraq on verge of collapse, but fight not over, says US commander General Joseph Votel

US Central Command Commander General Joseph Votel testifies before a Senate Armed Services Committee. AP

A Defense Department watchdog report released Monday warned of just such a possibility.

The Islamic State group "remains a potent force of battle-hardened and well-disciplined fighters that 'could likely resurge in Syria' absent continued counterterrorism pressure," the report from the inspector general said.

The top commander of US forces in West Asia, General Joseph Votel, told a Senate committee on Tuesday that of the 34,000 square miles (88,060 square kilometres) of territory that Islamic State once held, it now controls less than 20 square miles (51.7 square kilometres).

"It is important to understand that even though this territory has been reclaimed, the fight against Islamic State and violent extremists is not over and our mission has not changed," Votel, commander of US Central Command, told the Senate Armed Services Committee.

"The coalition's hard-won battlefield gains can only be secured by maintaining a vigilant offensive against the now largely dispersed and disaggregated Islamic State that retains leaders, fighters, facilitators, resources and the profane ideology that fuels their efforts."

Votel said there are now between 1,000 and 1,500 Islamic State fighters in the small area they still control in the southern part of the Euphrates River Valley near the Iraqi border. The remainder, he said, have "dispersed" and "gone to ground," suggesting they retain the potential to return.

Trump's decision to leave Syria, which he initially said would be rapid but later slowed down, shocked US allies led to the resignations of Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and the top envoy to the anti-Islamic State coalition, Brett McGurk.

Votel was asked at Tuesday's hearing whether he was asked for his advice about a Syria withdrawal before Trump announced his decision.

"I was not consulted," the general said.

The withdrawal will fulfil Trump's goal of bringing troops home from Syria, but military leaders have pushed back for months, arguing that Islamic State remains a threat and could regroup. US policy has been to keep troops in place until the extremists are eradicated.

Fears that Islamic State fighters are making strategic manoeuvres ahead of a US pullout could also fuel criticism that Trump is telegraphing his military plans — the same thing he accused President Barack Obama of doing in Afghanistan.

US officials in recent weeks say Islamic State has lost 99.5 percent of its territory and is holding on to fewer than 10 square kilometres of turf in Syria — an area smaller than New York's Central Park. In late November and December that figure had been estimated at between 400 and 600 square kilometres, according to officials briefed on the matter.

But several defense officials said Monday that many fighters fled to ungoverned spaces and other pockets in the north and in the west and are likely hiding out until they can regroup.

Trump said in a weekend interview that the caliphate is "almost knocked out."

"We're at 99 percent right now, we'll be at 100," he said on CBS' "Face the Nation."

US officials say that Islamic State fighters hold only several villages in the Middle Euphrates River Valley that amount to significantly less than 10 square kilometres. But, they say they don't expect that area to be cleared of militants for another several weeks, at best.

Officials say that overall, there are about 2,000 Islamic State militants in Syria.

The Defense Department watchdog report warned that even with the Islamic State forces on the run, the group "is still able to coordinate offensives and counter-offensives, as well as operate as a decentralized insurgency."

The report, which covers October through December 2018, also includes a classified section that was provided to Congress and includes a more detailed Pentagon assessment on the impact of the troops withdrawal and the status of Islamic State militants and other foreign fighters in Syria.

According to the report, US Central Command believes that Islamic State fighters will continue to conduct "opportunistic attacks" on US troops as they withdraw. And it says, "If Sunni socio-economic, political, and sectarian grievances are not adequately addressed by the national and local governments of Iraq and Syria it is very likely that Islamic State will have the opportunity to set conditions for future resurgence and territorial control."

Central Command said that the Islamic State group is "regenerating key functions and capabilities more quickly in Iraq than in Syria," but unless there is sustained counterterrorism pressure, Islamic State militants "could likely resurge in Syria within six to twelve months and regain limited territory" in the Middle Euphrates River Valley.

Despite Trump's order to withdraw, American officials maintain that the goal remains the "enduring defeat" of the Islamic State group and are moving ahead with a long-planned meeting of top diplomats from the 79-member US-led anti-Islamic State coalition this week. The aim of the conference is to recommit the coalition to that aim and ensure that the departure of US troops does not overly complicate that mission.

Trump himself is expected to speak to the gathered foreign ministers at the State Department-hosted conference on Wednesday is widely expected to reiterate and expand on his anti-Islamic State message from the State of the Union, officials said.

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go to and hit the Subscribe button.

Updated Date: Feb 05, 2019 23:00:45 IST

Also See