For Notre-Dame, lessons from a fire-damaged New York cathedral

By Jonathan Allen NEW YORK (Reuters) - Before the restoration of Notre-Dame de Paris can begin, engineers may have to tap nearly every stone in the cathedral and listen for subtle sounds of damage, according to specialists who repaired one of the largest cathedrals in the world in New York after a devastating 2001 fire.

Reuters April 19, 2019 03:07:21 IST
For Notre-Dame, lessons from a fire-damaged New York cathedral

For NotreDame lessons from a firedamaged New York cathedral

By Jonathan Allen

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Before the restoration of Notre-Dame de Paris can begin, engineers may have to tap nearly every stone in the cathedral and listen for subtle sounds of damage, according to specialists who repaired one of the largest cathedrals in the world in New York after a devastating 2001 fire.

The rebuilding is unlikely to be quick, warned architects and engineers who spent over five years repairing the Episcopal Cathedral of St. John the Divine after its fire. French President Emmanuel Macron's vow to restore the Paris landmark within five years after a fire consumed Notre-Dame's roof and toppled its spire on Monday may prove unrealistic, they said.

"Everything is done in 'cathedral time,'" said James Patterson, director of facilities and capital projects at St. John's on Manhattan's Upper West Side near Columbia University. "Cathedral clocks move much slower than everybody else's clocks."

Patterson, along with other specialists who worked on the St. John's restoration, described the challenges and satisfactions that may lie ahead in Paris where $1 billion has been pledged to restore the 850-year-old landmark.

The fire at St. John's destroyed much of the unfinished north transept of the 19th-century Gothic Revival structure, silenced its grand organ and left what remained blackened with thick, tarry deposits.

Patterson and others recalled the joy of discovering sculptors, stonemasons, stained-glass specialists and others around the world who can rival the artisans of earlier centuries in their decorative work. There were less obvious considerations to contend with, too, such as how to ensure the majesty of the nave's acoustics were not dampened by repairs to the walls and ceiling.

"The organ masters are very sensitive to it," said Raymond Pepi, the lead building conservationist on the project.

But before all that, the specialists had to inspect, repair and clean the fire-blasted stones.

SOUNDING STONES

As with Notre-Dame, much of St. John's masonry is limestone. If rapidly heated by a fire and then rapidly cooled by water, limestone can crack, weakening the structure's stability, and its surfaces can powder and flake.

To check which blocks needed to be patched up or replaced outright, Nat Oppenheimer, the structural engineer on the St. John project, and his colleagues "sounded" thousands of limestone blocks throughout the cathedral over a period of months.

Though more modern technology and techniques were used in aspects of the restoration, Oppenheimer said the old-fashioned approach of tapping stones with a small hammer or dragging a chain across them, listening for tell-tale sounds of hollowness, had not been supplanted.

"It's like playing an instrument," he said.

Some cracks can be strengthened with plastic or steel pins. The St. John's team also mixed up centuries-old mortar recipes to fill in damaged joints. Where a stone's surface is flaking or "sugary," it can be mechanically tooled away, although that comes with drawbacks.

"If one stone is slightly recessed from another stone, that throws a shadow on the stone," said Pepi, the president of Building Conservation Associates, which helped oversee the St. John project. "It's not aesthetically satisfying or pleasing."

Notre-Dame's fire appears to have been mainly fueled by centuries-old oak timbers that made up its roof. That will have left deposits of wood fibres and resins clinging to stones throughout the cathedral, and trial and error may be needed to determine the best way to clean them, Pepi said.

At St. John's, Pepi and his team conducted "literally hundreds" of tests, which took about a year.

"We tested chemical reagents, organic solvents, mineral abrasives," he said. "We tried trying to shoot crushed-up dry ice at the stone under high pressure."

In the end, they settled on spraying the tarry stones with liquid latex rubber. After the rubber dried, it could be peeled away, bringing the deposits with it, leaving clean stone behind.

With the restoration funded in part by an insurance settlement of $42 million, the full length of the cathedral was reopened to the public in 2008, Patterson said, although building work on what is sometimes nicknamed "St. John the Unfinished" continues to this day.

The renovation of Notre-Dame will also be an opportunity to consider modern upgrades.

Pepi also worked on the recent $175 million restoration of St. Patrick's Cathedral, a landmark Neo-Gothic structure on Manhattan's Fifth Avenue.

As with Notre-Dame, St. Patrick's roof has wooden scaffolding, and Pepi recalls the city's Fire Department all but insisted that a modern fire-prevention system be installed.

"The Fire Department told us: 'We're not going up there if there's a fire,'" Pepi said.

They settled on a modern misting system that would quell a fire in the rafters, but would minimize water damage that sprinklers might cause in plaster vaulting below.

(Reporting by Jonathan Allen; Editing by Frank McGurty and Lisa Shumaker)

This story has not been edited by Firstpost staff and is generated by auto-feed.

Updated Date:

TAGS:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Airline easyJet's first-half loss widens as COVID-19 hurts travel, seeks cash
Business

Airline easyJet's first-half loss widens as COVID-19 hurts travel, seeks cash

(Reuters) - Budget airline easyJet on Wednesday reported a bigger loss for the first half as it took a 160-million-pound hit ($199 million) from failed fuel hedging as the COVID-19 pandemic brought global air travel to a virtual standstill. The London-listed company reported a pretax loss of 353 million pounds for the six months ended March 31 from a loss of 272 million pounds last year. Revenue rose 1.6%, though easyJet took a hit from strikes in France, and storms Ciara and Dennis.

Bayer settles Roundup cancer lawsuits for up to $10.9 billion
Business

Bayer settles Roundup cancer lawsuits for up to $10.9 billion

FRANKFURT (Reuters) - Bayer AG on Wednesday said it agreed to settle U.S.

Sudan to establish trade financing fund in face of forex shortage
Business

Sudan to establish trade financing fund in face of forex shortage

KHARTOUM (Reuters) - Sudan will create a trade financing fund with a portfolio of $2 billion to aid the import and export of key commodities such as wheat, the Finance Ministry said, as the supply of foreign currency in circulation dwindles. Sudan's economy is at risk of freefall, hammered by an inflation rate of more than 100% and frequent shortages of bread, fuel and medicine. The country's currency has also fallen to a record low of 150 Sudanese pounds to the dollar on the black market compared with 55 at the official rate