Dear India,Pakistan: Stop blaming each other for everything

On the Indian subcontinent, regional trouble is blamed on the foreign hand. Such stupidity is commonplace among the state, the people and the media.

Aakar Patel November 18, 2012 10:36:56 IST
Dear India,Pakistan: Stop blaming each other for everything

On the Indian subcontinent, regional trouble is blamed on the foreign hand. This is because our citizens unreservedly love their nation and its constitution. It is the mischief of the neighbour that must be supressed.

Such stupidity is commonplace in our parts among the public, state and media.

Dear IndiaPakistan Stop blaming each other for everything

Reuters

It is of a piece with the unthinking and closed-minded view that is unique to us in India and Pakistan.

India first enoucntered this 30 years go when its troubles in Punjab were blamed on Pakistan. Those angered, those agitating, those killed in encounters, were all agents of the enemy state. The vocabulary of the state evolved and common people began using phrases like asamajik tatva (anti-social element) which came from propaganda.

When Muslims in Kashmir began a ferocious protest under the Jamaat e Islami and the umbrella organisation of Hurriyat, the villain was Pakistan.

Even today, when the trouble is behind us, it will be difficult to find an Indian analyst who can say what is obvious to the world. That a large number of Kashmiri-speaking Muslims reject the Indian constitution.

The primary cause of Kashmir's trouble was unrest in the population. The militancy, whether local or imported, was secondary. Guerilla war, which is what was waged against India, cannot be prosecuted without a base in the population. But this violence became the narrative and there the solution was focused.

President Musharraf switched off the jihad in Kashmir (something India hasn't thanked him for) and the violence wilted after 2002. It is almost gone today. But can we think of Kashmir as any other Indian state? I don't think so, and the reason is that many, if not most people in the valley are still sullen, and attracted to the Jamaat e Islami and its calls for bandh.

I am visiting there in a few weeks and will have an update on this then.

Meanwhile Pakistan has the same attitude problem, recently blaming India for the trouble in Balochistan.

As a long term observer of the Urdu press, this was not surprising to me. But I was taken aback to read that even people like Najam Sethi were talking of Indian mischief in Balochistan.

Analysts should get out more, because gathering information from mostly state sources will leave too much for them to filter out.

Then there is talk of Indian intervention in Fata and elsewhere through the Tehreek e Taliban Pakistan.

Even the damage done by Talibs to the Pakistan Navy is debited to India. Why? Because the aircraft they shot down were India-specific.

No logic is more advanced than this. But if Talibs consider the Pakistani state their enemy, and they do, it is only to be expected that they will pinch it where it hurts.

The fact that this has not crossed these analysts minds (If it has, I have yet to hear it), shows the extent of their paranoia.

I wonder who they think in the Indian government authorises such mischief. Manmohan Singh? Sonia Gandhi? If so, they don't know much about India.

The sad fact is that our problems are mostly of our own making. Our constitution, whether Indian or Pakistani, is not universally loved internally. We should try selling it more to those who don't accept it.

To accept our neighbours have more sovereignty than we do over our territory, which is what we do when we blame the foreign hand, is ridiculous.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

A history of riots in India shows how the Hindu right used religious processions to foment disorder
India

A history of riots in India shows how the Hindu right used religious processions to foment disorder

Governments can ensure that religious processions don't end in violence. For that though, the lives of innocent citizens, especially minorities, should matter to them

2020, year of the pandemic: How this visually-impaired Chennai woman struggled with daily commute in the face of govt apathy
India

2020, year of the pandemic: How this visually-impaired Chennai woman struggled with daily commute in the face of govt apathy

From the moment she steps out of her home till she reaches her Chepauk office, Aruna Devi requires assistance from passersby at multiple points. “That there is still no policy to cater to something as basic as transportation shows that there is no concern for us,” says the Chennai revenue official

Why remove Donald Trump now? A guide to the second impeachment of a president
World

Why remove Donald Trump now? A guide to the second impeachment of a president

While the House moved with remarkable speed to impeach Trump, a Senate trial to determine whether to remove him cannot begin until 19 January, his final full day in office