As US polls draw near, Joe Biden, in a rarity, attacks Donald Trump from battleground Pennsylvania
Playing up his local, middle-class roots, Biden focussed on Trump’s stewardship of the coronavirus, casting the president as a callous leader who cannot empathise with the concerns of most Americans
Joe Biden faced his first sustained questioning from voters as the Democratic presidential nominee Thursday, as Pennsylvanians pressed him on issues including health care, racism and policing at a CNN town hall-style event held less than seven weeks before Election Day.
At a gathering in Moosic, Pennsylvania, not far from his childhood home in Scranton, Biden — who played up his local, middle-class roots — sought at every opportunity to turn the focus to President Donald Trump’s stewardship of the coronavirus , casting the president as a callous leader who cannot empathise with the concerns of most Americans and who has exacerbated the hardships they face.
“You lost your freedom because he didn’t act,” Biden declared. “The freedom to go to that ballgame, the freedom for your kid to go to school, the freedom to see your mom or dad in the hospital. The freedom just to walk around your neighbourhood, because of failure to act responsibly.”
The appearance offered a test of his verbal agility less than two weeks before the first presidential debate, after Biden spent the summer largely off the campaign trail with limited and often controlled interactions with the news media. Headed into the evening, he may have benefited from the low expectations Republicans have set about his ability to communicate clearly, seeking to throw doubt on his mental acuity.
But as the night got underway, while there was the occasional tangent, Biden delivered a relatively energetic performance defined by withering criticism of Trump and palpable enthusiasm for connecting with voters after many months without much significant interaction with them, indicating to several that he would be open to follow-up conversations.
The setting reflected the extraordinary nature of campaigning in a pandemic: a stage was constructed in a parking lot at PNC Field, where the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre minor league baseball team plays. Biden and CNN’s Anderson Cooper stood a significant distance from each other, and the Democratic nominee often gestured with his mask in hand. Audience members listened from their cars, as if it were a drive-in movie, according to CNN. And voters stood at a distance from Biden as they asked him questions.
Biden seemed keenly focused on the location, making frequent references to his working-class ties as he sought to connect in a region where Trump’s populist message had significant appeal in 2016. The former vice president has long hoped to cut into Trump’s advantage with white voters without college degrees.
“Maybe it’s my Scranton roots, I don’t know — but when you guys started talking on television about, ‘Biden, if he wins, would be the first person without an Ivy League degree to be elected president,’ I’m thinking, ‘Who the hell makes you think I have to have an Ivy League degree to be president!’” Biden demanded. Numerous presidents have lacked Ivy League degrees, but he earned applause in the crowd.
“We are as good as anybody else,” Biden continued. “Guys like Trump who inherited everything and squandered what they inherited are the people that I’ve always had a problem with, not the people who are busting their neck.”
A number of Biden’s allies have urged his campaign to talk more about the economy, an area where Trump has traditionally had an advantage, according to polls. Earlier Thursday, as Trump’s campaign unfurled new ads focused on the economy, Biden’s advisers painted the president as an opponent of “working people.”
“I really do view this campaign as a campaign between Scranton and Park Avenue,” Biden said that evening. “All he thinks about is the stock market.”
“How many of you all own stock?” Biden continued. “In my neighborhood in Scranton, not a whole hell of a lot of people own stock.”
In a statement, Tim Murtaugh, a Trump campaign spokesman, said that Biden should have received more scrutiny of his plans and record on matters including the economy.
“This was classic Joe Biden: untethered to the facts, his own record, or reality,” he said in a statement.
Trump made his own campaign appearance Thursday in Mosinee, Wisconsin, where he spoke outdoors for more than 90 minutes to a crowd on a blustery airport tarmac just feet from a wingtip of Air Force One, which was parked behind him.
In rambling remarks, Trump warned that the 2020 election was a choice “between law and order on one side and chaos on the other".
“On 3 November, Wisconsin will decide whether we will quickly return to record prosperity or whether we will allow Biden and the Democrats to impose a $4 trillion tax hike, ban American energy, confiscate your guns” and “shut down the economy”, Trump said, in remarks that significantly distorted Biden’s agenda. He also proclaimed Speaker Nancy Pelosi “crazy as a bedbug” and said he looked forward to seeing what Vice President Mike Pence “does to” Biden’s running mate, Senator Kamala Harris of California, in their debate next month.
Biden, often seeming to be in a punchy mood, lobbed his own attacks on Trump’s sense of reality.
“He may be really losing it — he’s president,” Biden said, as he addressed the civil unrest that has played out in some American cities. “I am not the president. This is Donald Trump’s America. You feel safer in Donald Trump’s America?”
Biden’s appearance came as he has sought to centre the presidential campaign on the response to the coronavirus . On Wednesday, he stepped up his warnings that Trump was politicising the rollout of a vaccine, and at the town hall, he discussed the issue at length, stressing his deference to scientists even as he described the staggering uncertainties that would accompany the successful deployment of a vaccine.
The opinion of the federal government’s top infectious disease expert would be important, he said: “I don’t trust the president on vaccines,” he said. “I trust Dr Fauci. If Fauci says a vaccine is safe, I’d take the vaccine.”
Throughout the event, Biden blasted Trump’s handling of the coronavirus crisis — as he has many other times in recent months — and pointed to revelations from a new book by journalist Bob Woodward that the president knowingly minimised the risks of the coronavirus . He also sought to connect many voters’ questions back to that subject.
But the issues that arose were wide-ranging, and Biden, who visited firefighters after the event, seemed keenly attuned to the politics of Pennsylvania.
“I will win Scranton,” Biden later insisted to reporters, according to a pool report. “Listen to me. I will win Scranton. And we were losing Scranton and Lackawanna County till I got put on the ticket. This is home. I know these people.”
Asked by reporters whether he believed that he was the reason Barack Obama had won the county, he replied: “I know I helped in this county. I helped in this state. We were losing by seven points in Pennsylvania. I get announced as the candidate. Five days later, we were up by six.”
It was not immediately clear what polls Biden was referring to — a RealClearPolitics compilation of polls from the 2008 race, when Biden was added to the ticket, did not show Obama losing Pennsylvania in the general election.
In a critical battleground state that Trump won in 2016, one where hydraulic fracturing is both a contentious issue and a source of jobs, Biden declared that there was “no rationale” for eliminating fracking at the moment.
As Biden focused on Pennsylvania, Trump declared his love for the state of Wisconsin, although at times he had a curious way of showing it: he had to ask the crowd how to pronounce Mosinee and then did not repeat it himself.
“I don’t know why the hell I like Wisconsin, but for some reason,” he said, trailing off, as the crowd — in which many people did not wear masks — chanted, “We love you!”
Also Thursday, Biden embraced a proposed income subsidy that is a focus of growing Democratic support. The plan, an expansion of the child tax credit, would offer $3,000 per child a year ($3,600 for those under age six) for all but the wealthiest families — essentially creating a guaranteed income for families with children.
Analysts have estimated the move would cost roughly $100 billion a year, a significant sum but less than half the annual cost of Trump’s tax cuts, which mostly benefit the wealthiest Americans.
Katie Glueck c.2020 The New York Times Company
Texas governor Greg Abbott, has declared his stance at a time when Biden administration is set to issue rules requiring employers with more than 100 workers to be vaccinated or test weekly for the coronavirus. Several major companies, including Texas-based American Airlines and Southwest Airlines, have said they would abide by the federal mandate.
The US treasury secretary said it would be “catastrophic” if the government did not have the resources to pay its bills
French President Emmanuel Macron and US Secretary of State Antony Blinken met in Paris to explore ways to overcome the rift that led France to take the unprecedented step of recalling its ambassador to the US.