16 US states sue Donald Trump for declaring national emergency to fund border wall, claim move violates Constitution

Sixteen US states sued US president Donald Trump's administration on Monday over his decision to declare a national emergency to fund a wall on the southern border with Mexico, saying the move violated the constitution.

Agence France-Presse February 19, 2019 08:46:06 IST
16 US states sue Donald Trump for declaring national emergency to fund border wall, claim move violates Constitution
  • Sixteen US states sued US president Donald Trump's administration over his decision to declare a national emergency to fund the border wall with Mexico

  • The lawsuit, filed in a federal court in California, said the president's order was contrary to the Presentment Clause that outlines legislative procedures among others

  • The move had been previously announced by Xavier Becerra, the AG of California, who said they had legal standing because they risked losing moneys intended for other important purposes

San Francisco: Sixteen US states sued US president Donald Trump's administration on Monday over his decision to declare a national emergency to fund a wall on the southern border with Mexico, saying the move violated the constitution.

The lawsuit, filed in a federal court in California, said the president's order was contrary to the Presentment Clause that outlines legislative procedures and the Appropriations Clause, which defines Congress as the final arbiter of public funds.

16 US states sue Donald Trump for declaring national emergency to fund border wall claim move violates Constitution

File photo of US president Donald Trump. AP

The move had been previously announced by Xavier Becerra, the attorney general of California, who said his state and others had legal standing because they risked losing moneys intended for military projects, disaster assistance and other purposes. Several Republican senators have decried the emergency declaration, saying it establishes a dangerous precedent and amounts to executive overreach.

California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon and Virginia are party to the complaint seeking an injunction.

"Use of those additional federal funds for the construction of a border wall is contrary to Congress's intent in violation of the US Constitution, including the Presentment Clause and Appropriations Clause," the complaint said. It added that Trump had "veered the country toward a constitutional crisis of his own making."

"Congress has repeatedly rebuffed the president's insistence to fund a border wall, recently resulting in a record 35-day partial government shutdown over the border wall dispute," the document read.

"After the government reopened, Congress approved, and the president signed into law, a $1.375 billion appropriation for fencing along the southern border, but Congress made clear that funding could not be used to build President Trump's proposed border wall."

The complaint added that the Department of Homeland Security had violated the National Environmental Policy Act by failing to evaluate the environmental impact of the wall in California and New Mexico. Friday's declaration enables the president to divert funds from the Pentagon's military construction budget and other sources.

Updated Date:

also read

High-tide flooding and how a moon wobble may put US coastline at risk in the mid-2030s
World

High-tide flooding and how a moon wobble may put US coastline at risk in the mid-2030s

There is a concern that a leap in flood numbers on almost all US mainland coastlines, Hawaii and Guam and only the far northern coastlines, including Alaska’s, may be spared

JEE Main 2021 session 4 to be held from 26 August; application deadline extended
India

JEE Main 2021 session 4 to be held from 26 August; application deadline extended

NTA has also declared in its new notification that a correction window will not be opened due to limited time

JEE Main 2021 phase 4 application window closes at 9 pm; apply on jeemain.nta.nic.in
India

JEE Main 2021 phase 4 application window closes at 9 pm; apply on jeemain.nta.nic.in

The decision has been taken by the agency keeping in mind the difficulties that aspirants are facing due to the COVID-19 pandemic