Supreme Court ban on polluting fireworks could be boon for Diwali 'green crackers'

The song and dance between civil society, torch-bearers of Indian culture and rituals and the law plays out like clockwork every year before Diwali. We complain about the inhuman quality of air pollution around Diwali, worsened by burning of extremely toxic and polluting firecrackers and governments, forced to take a back seat on this culturally sensitive issue stay mum. The Supreme Court almost always intervenes and tries to bring some respite. Following the SC’s verdict on banning the sale and use of polluting firecrackers and urging citizens to resort to green firecrackers, the Union Minister for Science and Technology, Dr Harsh Vardhan, announced that a set of less-polluting ‘green’ firecrackers have been developed by scientists. The idea of ‘green fireworks’ has largely been welcome in light of  **pollutions woes** , and even brought on a joke or five in the days after the Supreme Court verdict restrictions about fireworks.

#GreenFirecrackers is like saying healthy pizza

— Champ McStark (@BolshoyBooze) October 23, 2018

What’s #GreenFirecrackers ??

Sukhe patte jalana hai ??🙄

— Fidus Achates (@Sohni_Bose) October 23, 2018

Jaisa aap kahein MiLords 😊 pic.twitter.com/MOAPOijAJD

— Ankur Singh (@iAnkurSingh) October 23, 2018

SC imposing ban on crackers #GreenFirecrackers pic.twitter.com/n0XGzsbCrd

— Ankur Singh (@iAnkurSingh) October 23, 2018

Jokes aside, the concept of a ‘green firecracker’ remains elusive to the majority. What about regular firecrackers makes them so polluting?  How are ‘green fire crackers’ any better for people and the environment?  [caption id=“attachment_5473151” align=“alignnone” width=“1280”] Sivakasi Fireworks.[/caption] They will not compromise on the light or sound of regular firecrackers, but are made from chemicals that would leave lower traces of particular matter once used, a press release said. What goes into a ‘regular’ firecracker? It takes a lot of different chemicals to create the right colour, brightness and duration of burn in firecrackers. Traditionally, they are made out of a combination of three or more of the following:

• A Fuel: sustains the heat for as long as the firecracker burns — the most widely used fuel is charcoal.
• An oxidising agent: produces the oxygen required to keep the mixture inside the cracker burning — like nitrates, chlorates or perchlorates.
• A reducing agent: burns oxygen to produce the massive energy required by the explosion — often sulphur or charcoal.
• Regulating agents: metals compounds that are added to control how fast the cracker burns — coloured metals like cobalt, copper and magnesium are used in sparklers and glittery variants.
• Binders: organic glue or resin used to hold the firecracker together.
• Colouring agents: different chemicals and metals used to produce variety of colours — like strontium, lithium, barium, chlorine or copper.

Each and every component of fireworks causes varying degrees of pollution — all of them pollute the air and release toxic fumes when burned. But some of them, like nitrates from the oxidising agents and heavy metals from colouring agents, create lasting effects after a celebration. Some of the biggest concerns from bursting thousands of fireworks in an already polluted city come from particles and heavy metals that linger in the air well after firecrackers are burnt, worsening the air quality. Cheap Thrills and Toxic Consequences The short-lived spike in pollution immediately afterwards fireworks is also caused by burnt leaves, heavy metals and toxic smoke which travels as it is airborne, causing suspended particulate matter and potentially, acid rain. The finer particulate pollutants can trigger asthma, respiratory discomfort or chemical sensitivity in people exposed to the smoke, while heavy metals can cause long-term damage to the skin and lungs. While the effects of greenhouse gases — carbon dioxide and ozone — from burning fireworks is often not irreversible, it still remains a problem for cities already dealing with pollution woes.

A week ago, the Supreme court verdict on bursting of firecrackers in Tamil Nadu restricted the bursting of firecrackers to between 8pm and 10pm. The verdict also mandated that only green firecrackers be used in any celebrations, which will be sold through licensed vendors. The Supreme Court clarified that the ban on any other firecrackers was restricted only to the Delhi-NCR region in **a statement** on Tuesday. But nationwide, efforts to monitor the levels of pollution during Diwali will be underway. “All state pollution boards and the Central Pollution Control Board will regulate and measure the particulate matter (PM) 2.5 and PM 10 in the air, seven days ahead and after Diwali,”  Vijay Panjwani, Central Pollution Control Board advocate told press. Green Firecrackers: An oxymoron or really a solution? Researchers from two national labs — the Central Electrochemical Research Institute (CECRI), Tamil Nadu and the National Environmental Engineering Research Institute (NEERI) in Nagpur — have developed these controversial ‘green firecrackers’. They are still far from eco-friendly, but are nevertheless given the tag of ‘green’ for being 25-30 percent less polluting than regular fireworks. Three prototypes were developed by these national labs and named SWAS (safe water releaser), SAFAL (safe minimum aluminum) and STAR (safe thermite cracker). Researchers tweaked the composition of regular firecrackers in ‘flower pots’, ‘jil jils’ and ‘atom bombs’ by replacing the more-polluting aluminum oxides with magnesium oxides. This reduced the particulate matter released from exploding these crackers, the press release said. NEERI researchers have created green crackers in which harmful chemicals like barium and potassium nitrate were replaced with zeolites (metals readily soluble in water) and magnesium, respectively. [caption id=“attachment_5473191” align=“alignnone” width=“1280”] Diwali fun and games in a Northeastern residence. Image courtesy: OhMyIndia[/caption] Some of them, like the ‘bijli’ crackers, have also been modified to replace the use of ash as a desiccant (to dehydrate and give a longer lasting burn), and lower particulate matter emissions by 25-30 percent. These eco-friendly firecrackers release water vapour as a ‘dust suppressant’, which would help bring suspended pollutants in the air down using humidity. How soon will the green firecrackers be sold? Greener crackers have been demonstrated to the manufacturers and their reaction has been positive, Dr Harsh Vardhan  told press. These crackers match the performance of conventional crackers in terms of sound. The green crackers were developed in multiple laboratories across the country, and sent for approval by manufacturers to the Petroleum and Explosives Safety Organisation (PESO). The chances of them being rolled out in time for Diwali celebrations this year, though, looks highly unlikely. “We are working on them," said Dr Vardhan when asked about when the crackers would reach markets. “We will let you know when they are ready for the market.” Until these green fireworks materialise in markets, it falls to the hands of the public to choose less polluting fireworks — within permitted emission and decibel levels. The alternative? Abstain from them altogether, or live with breaking the new law.