About half of the world today lives without access to the internet.
Reports like the one released by the 'Queen of the Internet' Mary Meeker suggests that 3.8 billion people, which is roughly 51 percent of the entire global population, are internet users. That still leaves a significant population in the dark. There’s a long way to go before the idea of open and omnipresent information reaches to the globe’s most remote regions. But that gap is shrinking by the year. As the prices of mobile plans and phones continue to hit new lows, millions of new users are going online every quarter.
A goldmine of data and users in the making
While it’s a positive step forward for the world, it’s also a burgeoning goldmine for tech companies who are otherwise running out of new users to enrol. A common trend has emerged among the roadmaps of these behemoths of late. They are all reorienting themselves to ensure their products are there whenever this new wave of users, famously referred to as the Next Billion Users, logs on to the internet for the first time.
The most apparent signs of this shift can be found in India where companies like Facebook and Google have raced to gain a head start before the rest catch up. In the last few years, a number of industries including mobile carriers, internet giants and even the government have come together to fix what has ailed the development of these disconnected areas’ so far.
The results are beginning to show too. Studies predict double-digit growth in 2019 and estimate the number of internet users to reach 627 million — primarily driven by the rapid adoption in rural sectors — in India.
In addition to products catering to such emerging markets, we’ve witnessed a vast range of initiatives designed to put in place the infrastructure needed to enable this goal of spawning a billion new internet users. That has led to accessible networks, projects which aim to spread awareness as well as educate, and much more.
“India is and will remain a “must-present market” on every organisation’s strategic roadmap for the next two decades, primarily because of the huge hitherto unconnected almost billion users. This huge base is not on smartphones, do not use the internet on a daily or monthly basis. Every company is trying to make products for these users. They are making efforts around internet literacy in the hope that this huge base starts using their services in the next few years, start using smartphones and hence further entrenching them in the life of these consumers, in one of the largest population bases in the world,” commented Navkendar Singh, research director of Devices and Ecosystem, India and South Asia, IDC.
KaiOS and the rise of smart feature phones
KaiOS, an operating system targetting affordable non-touchscreen smart feature phones, has played a vital role in building a platform to deliver modern services into the hands of people who can’t afford a smartphone. Its app store offers some of the most widely used apps such as WhatsApp, YouTube, Google Maps and Xender on phones that cost just around $30.
KaiOS is also what powers Reliance’s JioPhone and JioPhone 2 which has, in a matter of a couple of months, reached the top and become the country’s most sought after feature phone. On KaiOS, people even have the option to speak to a voice assistant in their regional language and perform actions like sending messages on WhatsApp. Both Reliance and Google have even invested in KaiOS’ parent startup.
At the time of writing, one out of three 4G users in India is from a rural area. While Reliance Jio itself might still lag behind incumbents, it has made possible that statistic. Its disruptive arrival in the telecom space three years ago forced other carriers to revamp their tariffs to be more affordable and competitive. Globally, India now has the cheapest average 4G rate at $0.26 for one gigabyte.
Google's aim to reach the grassroots
Google, since the inception of its Next Billion Users division, has remained at the forefront as well. Along with bringing its services to feature phones, Google has been instrumental in filling the infrastructure and education cracks. Its network of free Wi-Fi now spans across four hundred railways stations in the country.
Internet Saathi, for which Google has partnered with Tata Trusts, works to improve digital literacy among women from villages and trains them on how to employ technology for business and education.
Neha Barjatya, chief Internet Saathi, Google India, said in an interview, “Till now over 58,000 Internet Saathis have worked across 208K villages in 18 Indian states. The program has already benefited over 22 million women and I am happy to share that the female to male ratio of Internet users in rural India has gone up from one in 10 in 2015 to three in 10 in 2017.”
Apart from that, Google has announced a series of new tools in an attempt to bring every new internet user under its ecosystem. Project Navlekha, for instance, allows regional publications to offer their content online with minimal effort and earn through Google’s advertising network, AdSense. It’s letting Android users pay via cash for apps.
Not to forget Android Go, a stripped down version of Android built to run on underpowered phones and choppy networks. The operating system comes with a battery of ‘lite’ apps that carry features such as the ability to read out articles and offline mode. Despite having its apps on KaiOS and an Android spinoff for entry-level phones, Google’s even reportedly prepping a new operating system for feature phones.
Google’s aggressive and early participation has proved lucrative for the company. In India, YouTube’s monthly user base stands at about 225 million, Google Search dominates more than 90 percent of the market, and its payments app, Google Pay leads the UPI charts. Google’s biggest draw in such scenarios is still for its advertising business and it is in a position to leverage the new set of data to attract companies who want to target the low-income population.
Facebook focussing on Express Wi-Fi
Facebook has been another prominent player looking to capitalise on a largely untapped share of the market. It owns the only IM app available on KaiOS — WhatsApp — further strengthening its supremacy in India. A Bloomberg study even found that in some regions, handsets with internet access are dubbed “WhatsApp phones.”
Unlike Google, Facebook has to also deal with challenges that come with being the most active social network. The misinformation wildfire has spiralled out of control on Facebook and its subsidiary WhatsApp. It has forced the social media leader to run skits across various localities, highlighting the ill consequences of forwarding provocative content or fake news without verification. These skits, which are performed by volunteers on the streets, are accompanied by mobile stations housed inside trucks where spectators can go through a demo of how WhatsApp and Reliance Jio’s network can augment their businesses.
In India, Facebook runs digital education programs for teaching people how to stay safe online. For this, it has collaborated with NGOs and other organisations like the Centre for Social Research and Cyber Peace Foundation. A spokesperson told us the social network has held 500 training sessions and reached over 100K people. Together with the Learning Links Foundation, the company conducts news literacy training sessions too.
Like Google, Facebook offers a network of free and paid Wi-Fi hotspots in the country called ExpressWiFi. As per reports, Facebook now has over a thousand hotspots in India through partnerships with Tikona, AirJaldi, Shaildhar and Netvision. ExpressWiFi points are usually located at local convenience stores whose owners earn a fee every time a user upgrades to the premium data packages. Fortunately, Facebook didn’t repeat its Free Basics mistakes in the case of ExpressWiFi and doesn’t favour any particular website or app.
Amidst several controversies and increased scrutiny in the west, Facebook is desperately scouring for alternative markets for growth and revenue. And the pivot has worked in favour of Facebook so far.
Back in 2017, India outpaced the United States to be Facebook’s most active country and the year’s fourth quarter was the first time Facebook’s daily average users in North America declined. In December last year, Facebook said its nine percent bump in active users was primarily led by India.
To further expand ad revenue in India, Facebook is trying to convince small and medium businesses to promote their products online. In its first Indian investment, the company acquired a stake in the social commerce platform, Meesho, which connects SMEs with customers through WhatsApp.
India's answer to Big Tech: BharatNet
India’s government has been a proactive presence here as well. Its BharatNet initiative has managed to bring online more than 1,25,000 panchayats through an optical fibre.
At the just concluded Union Budget 2019, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman gave a further boost to BharatNet initiatives. Sitharaman said that under the Pradhan Mantri Grameen Digital Saksharta Abhiyan (PMGDISHA), BharatNet would be targeting internet connectivity in local bodies in every Panchayat in India. This activity is expected to be speeded up under the Universal Service Obligation Fund (USOF). PMGDISHA is part of the government's Digital India program.
Designing an internet that speaks and understands major Indian languages
Further, India’s vernacular diversity often eludes western tech companies. According to various analysts, there are more than 200 million non-English users in the country and the number is projected to expand to 550 million in the next three years. While most operating systems and apps bundle support for a wide gamut of local languages in their software, it ends up throwing a wrench in the more advanced functions like detecting misinformation. To attract the next billion users, tech companies will have to reach users in their mother tongue.
The absence of ample digital literacy exacerbates Facebook’s struggle with fake news. The social media company does have Indic partners for detecting non-English fake news content but these efforts have barely been able to make a dent. On top of that, Facebook has failed to play a proactive play and reports have previously found some of those fact-checking partners were themselves reporting unverified claims.
Plus, regional languages have been a centrepiece of a number of Google products. Its AI is today compatible with tens of Indian languages. Yet, its algorithms on platforms like YouTube and Google are still one of the most active perpetrators of misinformation. Features such as smart recommendations often end up acting in favour of fake news if the user has in the past clicked any related link or video.
“Platforms themselves algorithmically control what information appears on your search feed, news feed. They limit the content that can be viewed, creating an atmosphere that is polarised and partisan”, Factly, a fact-checking platform wrote in a study.
IndusOS, which develops Indic-first system apps for Android-based skins, has been one of the key drivers of the regional OS trend. It enables phone makers to offer essential apps like the app store, virtual keyboard in a wide range of local languages. At the time of writing, IndusOS’ homegrown app store, Indus App Bazaar is home to 400,000 apps developed by leading companies including Samsung.
IndusOS’ focus on regional services has numbers to back it up too. It’s now India’s second most used mobile platform. It’s worth noting, though, that technically IndusOS is not an operating system. It runs on Android and partners with local OEMs to preload its set of system apps. India’s second largest mobile operating system is KaiOS.
IndusOS’ CEO, Rakesh Deshmukh believes, “100 percent of the next growth in smartphone users is going to come through users who prefer their native language. Keeping this in mind, we have developed Indus App Bazaar, India’s App Store, where users can discover and consume digital content and services in their preferred language.”
Like others, however, Deshmukh refuses to address the repercussions of this surge of internet users.
With little time to recalibrate their products and hardly any substantial improvements in digital literacy among these new users, companies seem to have overlooked the part that comes after they’ve managed to bring a new user onboard.
Stitching a surprising set of behavioural patterns
Unlike what companies’ pitch suggest or you may think, behavioural patterns of these new, low-income internet users are largely similar to the ones in more established areas.
“Users are drawn to new applications and technologies. Not based primarily on pragmatic ends. But mainly for leisure purposes such as entertainment, pornography, social network. These kinds of drivers get people to go online. Of course, when they are there, they engage in other kinds of networks. WhatsApp groups allow them to talk about everything like share wedding photos, share jokes, religious sayings, and all kinds of not very pragmatic content,” stated Payal Arora, who has authored the book The Next Billion Users that explores the digital life beyond the west.
As the internet and its various intricacies are still a new concept in villages, a lot of concerns loom over this dramatic shift. Privacy remains at the top of the pyramid and the majority of new users are not aware of what they usually give up on, for free services like Google.
Plus, the effects of India’s misinformation woes are gradually trickling down to these low-literacy regions. In the past year, there have been numerous incidents that highlight how companies like Facebook need to come up with better solutions for fake news before putting their foot down to capture the next billion users.
Arora believes the absence of education is not to be predominantly blamed for the mob lynchings and other similar cases. “That can be misleading because a number of users are actually well aware that there is a lot of fake content being circulated. There's a larger discussion that needs to be had about the accountability that media systems have to these users. This has become a political strategy. So my argument is that it's not so much about education and awareness. It has to do with politics, the way in which these mainstream has been using misinformation to create polarised public and how they are linked to political parties. That is really the bigger problem,” she added.
Scratching the surface of the numbers, companies and the government advertise, also sheds light on the fact that the underlying groundwork necessary to enable India’s next big chunk of internet users is still far from what it should be.
India’s rapidly accelerating digital revamp has entered the radar of international startups. Based out of the UK, BuffaloGrid is one of them and its network of solar-powered charging stations are addressing foundational hurdles like the lack of electricity. In addition to allowing villagers to charge their phone, the BuffaloGrid box acts as a Wi-Fi hotspot too. These stations sit in local stores and require the user to go through a setup process, after which they can charge and surf the web. BuffaloGrid says its services are freemium and the user is not charged until a certain point. However, it didn’t say what it costs once the complimentary quota expires.
BuffaloGrid also joined hands with WhatsApp earlier this year to spread the latter’s ‘Spread Joy, Not Rumours’ campaign. Locals are shown a short video clip outlining the steps they should take to spot fake news before they can avail BuffaloGrid’s services. “To date over 70,000 people have used BuffaloGrid’s solar charging technology across Bihar, Karnataka and Uttar Pradesh,” said BuffaloGrid’s director in India, Sameer Sinha.
“The Indian Government has taken great steps to bring power to rural communities but our research shows there’s a long way to go before every home is connected. Our field research team has spoken to hundreds of people without access to electricity and many more who still experience regular power cuts. We also think Indian telecom players have done an incredible job at connecting communities but the ongoing industry pricing war has stifled innovation and left millions disconnected or dissatisfied,” said BuffaloGrid’s Sinha.
It’s just the beginning
India’s tech landscape has gone through a dramatic upgrade in just the last couple of years. And no tech company wants to be left behind. But there’s a lot that needs to be taken care of to ensure the digital divide is as little as possible.
The government often also overlooks the foundational pillars such as electricity while leveraging the idea of a more connected India for political gain. After years of living in the shadows, India’s remote regions are able to step forward through the internet. Now, it’s the government and private players’ responsibility to build a level playing field.
Disclaimer: Reliance Industries Ltd which owns Reliance Jio and Jio Phone is the sole beneficiary of Independent Media Trust which controls Network18 Media & Investments Ltd, the publisher of Firstpost and tech2
The author is a freelance technology journalist from Ahmedabad. He tweets from @phonesoldier.
Facebook, Twitter and others take down footage of German synagogue shooting incident
Supreme Court rejects plea to link social media accounts with Aadhaar, says Madras High Court also hearing matter
Facebook is requested not to use encrypted messages as it does not let officials peek
WhatsApp was extensively exploited during 2019 elections in India: Report