tech2 News StaffMar 22, 2017 17:36:20 IST
Update: We spoke to an HDFC Bank spokesperson regarding the issue. The story has been updated with the bank's response.
Have you heard of micro-transactions? They spell profit for game companies and headaches for gamers. The banking world, or at least, one bank in particular, has taken the lesson to heart and taken things a step further.
Karthik Srinivasan, a Digital Marketer from Bangalore was going through his email when he discovered that HDFC Bank had been charging him Rs 100 per quarter for a program he never signed up for.
On delving deeper, he discovered that the service was an opt-out program that had been activate for his account without his express consent. Worse still, the opting out requires a member to actually read their spam-like banking emails, from top to bottom, discover the fine print that states that the offer is an opt-out one and then click on a link to opt-out of the service.
— Karthik (@beastoftraal) February 1, 2017
But what’s Rs 400, right? That still doesn’t equate to hundreds of crores of rupees.
Rashmi R. Padhy took to Medium to break down why the money is real and why this is indeed a scam.
Pointing to VAS (Value-Added-Service) fraud that was prevalent some years ago, Padhy notes that telcos used to offer VAS as “free” trials. After the trial was over, these telcos would charge you for the service and keep doing so until you opted out.
The value of the transactions was small, but scaled up, the telcos likely earned in hundreds, if not thousands of crores. The rising number of complaints caught the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India’s (Trai) attention and the practice was halted.
— Karthik (@beastoftraal) February 18, 2017
HDFC Bank appears to be doing the same thing. The bank essentially upgrades you to a free Classic / Preferred Banking trial program without your consent and then charges you Rs 100 — plus service tax — per quarter till you opt out.
Since most people would not read the mailer that explains all this and since the price isn’t placed up front, most people will not opt-out because they simply don’t know.
Padhy breaks down the calculations as follows. Charging 1.2 Cr customers a fee of Rs 400 a year, HDFC is set to earn upwards of Rs 400 Cr a year. For free, without the explicit consent of its members.
The calculation may not be as cut and dried as Padhy puts it and the numbers might be much lower. This doesn’t, however, change the fact that the program is inherently fraudulent. And other banks might soon follow suit, if they haven’t already.
As heinous as the practice might seem, it is currently perfectly legal for it to do what it’s doing.
— Karthik (@beastoftraal) March 22, 2017
Most people may not even be aware of the service or the charge. A charge of Rs 400 a year can easily get lost in the tens of thousands of transactions that we perform every year. And how many of us actually peruse through our monthly bank statements in that much detail anyway? Many more of us probably delete bank mails the moment they arrive in the first place.
Srinivasan did not take this charge laying down. On discovering the charge, an average person might simply have opted out, vented a bit on social media and left it at that. Srinivasan is, however made of more Gandhian stuff. As Office Chai puts it, Srinivasan is now on an online ‘satyagraha’ to get HDFC Bank to apologise for trying to scam its customers in such a way.
Srinivasan first explained the whole scam in his blog, where he outlined the steps he’s taken, HDFC’s official response and his emails to the banking ombudsman and HDFC’s Board of Directors. He then vowed to tweet to HDFC Bank every single day for the whole of 2017 with a link to his blog. This effort began on 1 February.
The end goal is simply an apology from the bank for treating its customers like this.
Srinivasan’s ‘satyagraha’ is now into its 50th day.
We spoke to an HDFC spokesperson about this issue and did not receive a convincing argument in favour of the bank's practices. The spokesperson basically described the program in question and defended the practice by saying that, "The customer is intimated several times through different means and given the option to exit (opt out) if he chooses to. This includes the 12 monthly statements."
We specifically asked them why the program isn't an opt-in one and what they think of Srinivasan's 'satyagraha' and whether they intend to respond to it. We received no response. Basically, HDFC Bank is saying that the practice is perfectly legal and it's the customers' fault for not reading all mailers and bank statements in full.
For a more detailed perspective on the events, check out Srinivasan's blog here. In the blog, he also outlines how you can fight against HDFC’s practices.
We’ve reached out to Srinivasan for further comment.
Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.