Apple to approach US court to dismiss 'massive & vague' DoJ antitrust case

Apple is set to make its case today in a US court, seeking to dismiss a massive antitrust lawsuit brought by the Department of Justice (DoJ) and several states. The tech giant argues that the accusations, which target its iPhone, App Store, and overall business practices, are both exaggerated and baseless.

This legal battle has been brewing since March 2024, when the DoJ filed the suit. **Apple** initially moved to dismiss the case in August and is now taking its defence to the courtroom.

At the heart of Apple’s argument is the claim that sharing its proprietary technology with competitors would stifle innovation, rather than promote fairness. Meanwhile, DoJ lawyers will continue to push their case, which alleges that Apple has engaged in monopolistic practices that harm consumers and competitors alike.

More from Tech

How ChatGPT is becoming everyone’s BFF and why that’s dangerous America ready for self-driving cars, but it has a legal problem

DoJ’s key accusations against Apple

The DoJ’s lawsuit includes several accusations of anticompetitive behaviour. One of the central claims is that Apple forces customers to use its iPhones to participate in its Messages ecosystem. However, Apple points out that this accusation is outdated, as the company had already announced support for the cross-platform RCS messaging standard before the lawsuit was filed.

Another major contention is the alleged denial of access to the iPhone’s NFC technology, which competitors could use for payment systems. Apple counters that this claim misrepresents its practices, insisting that it has not restricted rival companies unfairly. These examples, according to Apple, highlight the case’s lack of substance and misalignment with the current reality.

Apple’s chances of dismissal

While **Apple** believes the lawsuit has no merit, the stakes are incredibly high. The case is not a simple dispute with a rival but a comprehensive, bipartisan effort by the federal government and multiple states. Dismissing the case outright would require the court to agree with Apple’s argument that the DoJ’s claims are fundamentally flawed.

Despite Apple’s confidence, legal experts suggest that dismissal is unlikely at this stage. Such a move would be unusual for a case of this magnitude, particularly one involving a federal agency and state governments.

Editor’s Picks

1

Apple faces EU's first fine under new digital antitrust rules over App Store violations 2

EU slaps Apple with a €500 Million fine for alleged antitrust violations in music streaming

A prolonged legal battle ahead for Apple

Even if today’s motion is unsuccessful, Apple’s legal team is prepared for a lengthy fight. The company has already made it clear that it views this lawsuit as unnecessary and counterproductive, especially as it argues that any alleged antitrust behaviour was resolved before the case even began.

While the chances of dismissal may be slim, the likelihood of the DoJ securing a win appears equally uncertain. What’s clear, however, is that this case is set to drag on for years, leaving the tech industry watching closely as one of its biggest players takes on the government.