US appeals court ruling keeps Cristiano Ronaldo hush-money case with Nevada federal judge

Ronaldo's attorneys have said that media reports about the 2009 encounter were based on electronic data that was illegally hacked, stolen and sold by cyber criminals.

The Associated Press February 09, 2021 10:03:10 IST
US appeals court ruling keeps Cristiano Ronaldo hush-money case with Nevada federal judge

Cristiano Ronaldo is accused of sexually assaulting a woman in Las Vegas in 2009. AP

Las Vegas: A US appeals court is letting a federal judge in Nevada decide claims by a woman suing football star Cristiano Ronaldo over a $375,000 rape case hush-money settlement reached more than a decade ago.

US District Judge Jennifer Dorsey said last September she would decide whether Kathryn Mayorga was mentally fit to enter the confidentiality agreement with Ronaldo's representatives in 2010.

Mayorga's attorney, Leslie Mark Stovall, appealed part of Dorsey's ruling that said a dispute over the legality of the agreement was eligible for arbitration. The ruling also allowed Ronaldo's attorneys keep documents out of the case and stated that the case was not eligible for a jury trial.

The order by the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco was dated 13 January and an attorney for Ronaldo in Las Vegas, Peter Christiansen, declined comment Monday about the case being returned to Dorsey.

Stovall did not immediately respond to telephone and email messages seeking comment.

The Associated Press generally doesn't name people who say they are victims of sexual assault, but Mayorga gave consent through Stovall in 2018 to be identified.

Mayorga, now 37, is a former teacher and model who lives in the Las Vegas area.

Stovall acknowledges she received money not to talk about meeting Ronaldo at a Las Vegas nightclub in 2009 and going with him and other people to his hotel suite where she alleges he sexually assaulted her in a bedroom. She was 25 at the time. He was 24.

Mayorga went public with the account in a lawsuit filed by Stovall in Nevada state court in September 2018. The case was moved to federal court a few months later.

Mayorga alleges that Ronaldo or his associates violated the confidentiality agreement by allowing reports of it to appear in European publications in 2017.

Ronaldo, 36, is Portuguese and is one of the richest athletes in the world. He plays in Italy for the Turin-based football club Juventus and captains his home country's national team.

Through his lawyers, he has maintained sex with Mayorga was consensual.

His attorneys have said that media reports about the 2009 encounter were based on electronic data that was illegally hacked, stolen and sold by cyber criminals.

Christiansen has said they believe documents have been altered, and complain that Mayorga's lawsuit damages Ronaldo's reputation.

Mayorga's lawsuit claims conspiracy, defamation, breach of contract, coercion and fraud and seeks to void the 2010 deal. Stovall maintains Mayorga didn't break the agreement, that Ronaldo should pay at least $200,000 more, and the case should be decided in a courtroom.

Ronaldo's legal representatives have succeeded in keeping details of the settlement sealed, arguing that Mayorga agreed to out-of-court mediation to resolve disputes.

Stovall has said that Mayorga was pressured by Ronaldo's representatives to accept the deal while she was mentally unfit and not in condition to consent. Mayorga's attorney has said she had learning disabilities as a child.

Dorsey said in October she plans to decide whether Mayorga lacked the mental capacity to sign off on the settlement agreement.

If Mayorga was fit, the judge said, the agreement binds her to confidentiality and an arbitrator's decision about whether the contract was legal and valid.

No hearing date has been set for the case to continue under Dorsey's supervision.

Updated Date:

Subscribe to Moneycontrol Pro at ₹499 for the first year. Use code PRO499. Limited period offer. *T&C apply

also read

Premier League: Pressure of coaching at highest level 'like oxygen,' says Tottenham boss Jose Mourinho
Sports

Premier League: Pressure of coaching at highest level 'like oxygen,' says Tottenham boss Jose Mourinho

Mourinho's job has come under scrutiny after a run of five Premier League defeats in six games left them ninth in the table — nine points outside the top four.

Premier League: West Bromwich Albion manager Sam Allardyce says relegation 'might not affect' his credibility
Sports

Premier League: West Bromwich Albion manager Sam Allardyce says relegation 'might not affect' his credibility

Second-bottom Albion are 11 points from safety and looked destined to drop into the Championship with only 13 games left to climb out of the relegation zone.

Bundesliga: Bayern Munich teenager Jamal Musiala announces decision to play for German national team
Sports

Bundesliga: Bayern Munich teenager Jamal Musiala announces decision to play for German national team

Musiala turns 18 on Friday and marked only his fourth Champions League appearance by slotting home a first-half goal as Bayern routed Lazio 4-1 in Tuesday's last 16, first leg tie in Rome.