George Floyd killing: Football rules highlight sports remains out of touch with on-field activism as players protest against injustice

Four players this weekend in German football took a stand in support of the protesters, making their point in the first major football league to resume during the coronavirus pandemic.

The Associated Press June 01, 2020 12:39:22 IST
George Floyd killing: Football rules highlight sports remains out of touch with on-field activism as players protest against injustice

To most watching Borussia Dortmund star Jadon Sancho remove his jersey to reveal a handwritten "Justice for George Floyd" message on his undershirt, it was a powerful expression of activism on a football field.

To the Bundesliga referee overseeing that game, it was an action requiring punishment.

Rarely has a rule looked so out of touch.

George Floyd killing Football rules highlight sports remains out of touch with onfield activism as players protest against injustice

Jadon Sancho of Borussia Dortmund celebrates with a 'Justice for George Floyd' shirt. AP/Getty Images

At one of the world's few globally televised sports on Sunday, Sancho showed the football world Floyd's death resonated far beyond the United States.

Floyd, a black man, was filmed gasping for breath on Monday in Minneapolis while being pressed under the knee of a white police officer for several minutes. Floyd's death has sparked days of protests across the U.S.

And four players this weekend in German football took a stand in support of the protesters, making their point in the first major football league to resume during the coronavirus pandemic.

The referee who penalized Sancho, Daniel Siebert, was following global football rules when he showed Sancho a yellow card. FIFA rules state players should be cautioned for removing their jersey while celebrating. Any messages on undergarments — from the political and religious to the personal — have been prohibited since 2014, although the penalty is left to each league to decide.

But in removing his jersey to reveal the slogan, Sancho highlighted a cause far bigger than sports.

"The booking of Jordan Sancho, or any other player, for making a statement in support of a man who has been unjustly killed is the wrong decision," Piara Powar, executive director of the football's anti-discrimination Fare Network, told The Associated Press. "This is not a party-political cause, or an issue that poses a threat to football but an expression of concern and solidarity from minority players."

George Floyd killing Football rules highlight sports remains out of touch with onfield activism as players protest against injustice

Achraf Hakimi of Borussia Dortmund displayed a 'Justice for George Floyd' shirt after scoring. AP/Getty Images

Dortmund teammate Achraf Hakimi revealed his own yellow "Justice for George Floyd" T-shirt when he netted Dortmund's fourth goal against Paderborn. The Moroccan was not booked — the rule wasn't even applied equally.

Representatives for the Bundesliga did not respond to requests for comment.

"We have to come together as one & fight for justice," the 20-year-old Sancho tweeted. "We are stronger together!"

"Denying high-profile athletes an opportunity to express concern on big issues," Piara said, "is neither correct nor can it be controlled in the post-Kaepernick era."

San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick took a knee during the national anthem in 2016 in silent protest of police brutality and racism that kicked off a period of pregame activism in the NFL.

Bundesliga player Marcus Thuram invoked Kaepernick on Sunday after he scored for Borussia against Union Berlin, dropping to his left knee. and resting his right arm on his right thigh and bowing his head.

George Floyd killing Football rules highlight sports remains out of touch with onfield activism as players protest against injustice

Schalke's Weston McKennie wears an armband with the words "....for George" during the Bundesliga. AP

A day earlier, American midfielder Weston McKennie of Schalke, wore an armband with the handwritten message "Justice for George" around his left arm.

"Rather than commenting on what a player should or shouldn't be doing," said Mary Harvey, chief executive of the Centre for Sports and Human Rights, "shouldn't our focus be on why players felt the need to do this in the first place?"

European football has been plagued by racial incidents at games, with few people facing consequences. As a young black player, Sancho spoke out against the scant punishment for offenders in the stands and on the field.

"It puts the confidence down in players," he said last year, "and the love of the sport will go very soon if it doesn't stop."

From Kaepernick to the NBA's LeBron James to Sancho, athlete activism is not going away.

Had Sancho, a 20-year-old England international, received a second yellow card in Sunday's match for Dortmund, he would have been ejected.

"It is a disciplinary reaction to a fundamental assertion of human rights and that is precisely what we don't need right now," Brendan Schwab, executive director of World Players Association, told the AP.

Three years ago, FIFA made a commitment to respect human rights in places the governing body hosts events. Denying players the right of freedom of expression inside stadiums is in direct conflict with that commitment.

The rule (Law 4.5) prohibiting slogans and statements on equipment needs revisiting.

"How can it be that certain rights are not available on a sports field?" Schwab said. "Sport needs to embrace the positive consequences that will come from it being a social leader, particularly at a difficult time."

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Donald Trump retweets racist video of Florida supporter yelling 'white power', deletes it after widespread outrage
World

Donald Trump retweets racist video of Florida supporter yelling 'white power', deletes it after widespread outrage

The edited racist video shows a white man riding in a golf cart bearing “Trump 2020” and “America First” signs during what appears to be an angry clash over the president and race between elderly white residents of a Florida retirement community. Trump deleted the tweet more than three hours after posting it.

Bundesliga: Werder Bremen avoid relegation by beating Heidenheim on away goals in playoff
Sports

Bundesliga: Werder Bremen avoid relegation by beating Heidenheim on away goals in playoff

Werder Bremen hung on to seal Bundesliga survival on away goals by drawing at second-division Heidenheim 2-2 in the second leg of their relegation-promotion playoff on Monday.

Jimmy Kimmel apologises for blackface in '90s sketches: 'Looking back, many of these were embarrassing'
Entertainment

Jimmy Kimmel apologises for blackface in '90s sketches: 'Looking back, many of these were embarrassing'

Jimmy Kimmel issued an apology for his 90s blackface impressions of NBA player Karl Malone and other Black celebrities but said his delay in addressing the subject came in part to avoid handing a victory to his foes.